Chapter 5: The Night of the Fire

Written by

in

Reading settings

It happened on a Tuesday night, nineteen days after the girls came to the mansion, and two days before the city council was due to vote.

Alexander had spent the day in meetings, and he had come home late, and tired, and quietly hopeful. His lawyer had bought the debt on the St. Agnes land that morning — quietly, through a holding company, so that Kane would not know until it was too late. The honest inspector had filed his report: the building was old, but it was sound, and the condemnation order was a fraud. The councilman had promised to read the report aloud at the vote.

It was going to work. Alexander could feel it. For the first time in weeks, he allowed himself to believe that the home was safe, and that the girls would never have to run again.

He was sitting in his study, reading the inspector's report for the third time, when Rosa came in, her face pale, a telephone in her hand.

"Alexander," she said. "It is Sister Agnes. The home is on fire."

He was on his feet before she finished speaking, his chair falling backwards onto the rug. He did not remember picking up his coat. He did not remember running to the car. He remembered only the drive — the rain-slick streets, the red light of the fire already glowing against the low clouds long before he reached the South Side, and the sound of his own heart hammering in his chest.

The girls had woken when they heard the front door slam. Gabriella was the first out of bed. She ran to the window and saw the black car tearing down the hill, and she knew, instantly, where it was going. She did not hesitate. She did not stop to think. She ran down the stairs, pulled on her shoes, and shouted for her sisters.

"Sophie! Harper! Nora! The home is on fire! We have to go!"

Rosa caught her at the front door, and for a moment Gabriella thought the old woman would stop her. But Rosa looked at her — at her fierce hazel eyes, at her chin lifted the way it lifted when she had decided something — and Rosa did something she would later say she should not have done, and would do again in a heartbeat.

"Then we go together," Rosa said, and she took the car keys from the hook, and she drove the four girls through the rain, behind Alexander's car, toward the fire.

St. Agnes Home was burning from the back. The shed where the firewood and the old paint were stored had gone up first, and the flames had spread to the rear wall of the building, licking at the wooden window frames, sending thick black smoke rolling across the garden. The younger children — ten of them, from four years old to thirteen — were standing in the street in their nightdresses, barefoot in the rain, crying and shivering, while Sister Agnes, in her robe, counted them over and over again, her voice shaking.

"Fourteen," she said. "There should be fourteen. Where is — oh, God. Where is little Mary? Mary is still inside!"

Gabriella did not think. She pushed through the crowd, past Sister Agnes, past the neighbours who were shouting for her to stop, and she ran toward the back door of the burning building.

She had almost reached it when a hand caught her shoulder and pulled her back.

"NO!" Alexander's voice was like thunder. He had arrived seconds before, and he had seen the small figure in the pink dress running toward the fire, and his heart had stopped. "Gabriella, no! You do not go into a burning building!"

"Mary is in there!" Gabriella cried, struggling against his grip. "She is four years old! She sleeps in the back room! Please, let me go!"

"Listen to me." Alexander knelt down in the wet street, in front of her, his hands on her shoulders, his face inches from hers. "Listen to me, Gabriella. You are brave. You are the bravest girl I have ever known. But brave does not mean running into a fire. Brave means staying here and helping me. Do you understand?"

Gabriella stared at him, tears and rain running down her face, and then she nodded, once, and Alexander stood up, and he turned toward the building, and he did something he had not done in twenty years: he ran into a burning building.

The smoke was thick inside, and the heat pressed against his face like a hand. He covered his mouth with his sleeve and moved through the dark hallway, calling Mary's name, and he found her in the back room, under the bed, curled into a small ball, crying silently, her face black with soot.

He picked her up, wrapped her in his coat, and carried her out through the smoke and the rain, into the street, where Sister Agnes took her with a cry, and the neighbours cheered, and the fire engines — which had finally arrived — began to spray water onto the flames.

And then, as the fire began to die, a black car pulled up at the end of the street, and Marcus Kane got out of it.

He stood there in the rain, in his brown suit, looking at the burning building, and at the children in the street, and at Alexander Hayes standing in the middle of it all with soot on his face and a small girl's hand in his, and he smiled his cold, oil-smooth smile.

"Mr. Hayes," he said. "What a terrible accident. Old buildings, as I have said. So flammable."

Alexander walked toward him, slowly, through the rain. His men, who had arrived with the fire engines, moved to follow him, but he held up one hand, and they stopped.

"Kane," he said, his voice low and calm, the way it was when he was at his most dangerous. "I know what you did. Your men cut the wires. Your men set this fire. And you are going to pay for it."

"Prove it," Kane said, and his smile widened. "You cannot prove anything. It was an accident. The inspector said so. The building was condemned."

"The inspector," Alexander said, "was your man. And he has already told the police everything."

For the first time, Kane's smile faltered. "What?"

"Your inspector came to see me this morning," Alexander said. "He is not as brave as he thought he was. He told me about the report you paid him to write. He told me about the men you sent to cut the wires. And he told me about the money you paid the councilman — the same councilman who is, at this very moment, sitting in a police station, telling them everything he knows."

It was not entirely true — the councilman was not in a police station yet — but Alexander had learned long ago that a lie told at the right moment, in the right voice, could do the work of a hundred truths. And he could see, in Kane's eyes, that it was working.

"And there is something else," Alexander said. He took a small phone from his pocket — Sister Agnes's phone, which she had given him that afternoon, after the third time Kane's men had driven past with their lights off. "Sister Agnes records everything, Kane. Every visit. Every threat. Including the day you stood in her hallway and said it would be a shame if anything happened to those pretty little girls. The police have the recording. They have the inspector. They have the councilman. And in the morning, they will have the men who set this fire — because my men followed them here tonight, and they are waiting at the end of the street."

As if on cue, two police cars turned into the street, their lights flashing red and blue through the rain. And behind them came Alexander's men, walking two frightened, soot-covered men between them — the men who had set the fire, caught as they ran from the shed.

Kane looked at the police cars. He looked at the arsonists. He looked at Alexander Hayes, standing in the rain with a small girl's hand in his, and for the first time in his life, Marcus Kane understood what it felt like to be afraid of someone.

"You cannot do this," he whispered. "I have money. I have lawyers. I have —"

"You have nothing," Alexander said. "You threatened children, Kane. And children have a way of finding the one man you should never have threatened them in front of."

The police took Kane away in handcuffs, in the rain, in front of the whole street, while the children of St. Agnes watched from the pavement, wrapped in blankets, and Sister Agnes stood in her robe, holding little Mary, and wept with relief.

The fire was out by midnight. The building was damaged, but it was standing — the rear wall blackened, the shed gone, but the home itself saved. The children were taken to the mansion for the night, all fourteen of them, and Rosa made cocoa for all of them, and laid out blankets in the great hall, and the mansion — which had once been the coldest house in Chicago — was full of small, sleeping children, and the sound of their breathing, and the smell of cocoa and wood smoke.

Late that night, when all the children were asleep, Alexander sat by the fireplace in the living room, and the four girls came and sat with him. Gabriella sat on his left, Harper on his right, Nora at his feet, and Sophie in his lap, her elephant tucked under her arm.

And then, without a word, the girls picked up the old brass lantern that stood on the mantelpiece — the lantern Rosa had lit every night for thirty years — and they held it together, all four of them, their small hands around its handle, and they set it on the hearth, where its warm light glowed against the marble and the dark wood.

"We did it, Daddy," Gabriella said quietly, and then she stopped, and her eyes went wide, because she had called him Daddy, and she had not meant to say it out loud — not yet, not like that.

Alexander looked at her. He looked at Harper, and Nora, and Sophie, and at the lantern glowing on the hearth, and at the fourteen small children sleeping in his hall, and he felt something in his chest break open, and heal, all at the same time.

"Yes," he said, and his voice was rough with tears. "Yes, you did. All of you."

And the fire crackled, and the lantern glowed, and the rain fell softly on the roof of the big house on the hill, and for the first time in five years, Alexander Hayes was home.

The morning after the fire dawned grey and cold, and the whole city seemed to be holding its breath. Alexander was up before sunrise, and he drove back to St. Agnes with his lawyer and the honest inspector, to walk through the damage in the daylight and to see, with his own eyes, what could be saved.

The shed was gone — nothing but blackened timber and ash. The rear wall of the home was scorched, and two windows were broken, and the smell of smoke hung in the air like a fog. But the building stood. The roof was sound. The front rooms, where the children slept and ate and did their lessons, were untouched.

"It can be repaired," the inspector said, tapping the walls, peering at the beams. "A month of work, perhaps six weeks. The structure is good. Whoever built this place built it to last."

"The repairs start tomorrow," Alexander said. "I will pay for all of it. And I want a new alarm system, and new locks, and lights on every corner of the property. No one will ever walk up to this house in the dark again."

Sister Agnes, who had come with them in her coat and her stout shoes, walked through the garden, touching the blackened wall with one hand, and then she turned to Alexander, and she said, "Mr. Hayes, in twenty-two years, I have seen this home threatened by storms, by the Depression, by mayors and by men like Kane. And do you know what I have learned? A home is not a building. A home is the people in it. And last night, when those children stood in the street in the rain, they were not afraid — not really — because they knew someone was coming for them. You came, Mr. Hayes. That is what a home is."

That afternoon, the police came to the mansion to take statements. A detective named Ruiz, a patient woman with tired eyes, sat in the study with Alexander and asked her questions, and Alexander answered all of them — about the inspector, about the recording, about the men his people had caught running from the shed. And when she asked him why he had done it — why a man like him had risked himself for a children's home — he looked at the four small girls, who were sitting on the rug by the fire, doing their lessons, and he said, "Because they are my daughters, Detective. And that is the whole of it."

The detective wrote it down. And then she closed her notebook, and she said, "Mr. Hayes, in twenty years on the job, I have arrested a great many men. I have very rarely met one who became a better man because of it. Whatever you were before, I hope you keep being whatever you are now."

The council vote, when it came two days later, was not even close. The inspector's report was read aloud. The recording of Kane's threats was played. The councilman who had taken Kane's money resigned that same morning, in disgrace. And the rezoning was defeated, eleven votes to one, while Sister Agnes sat in the gallery, holding little Mary's hand, and wept with relief.

Marcus Kane, from his cell, sent one message through his lawyer: that he was sorry, and that he would not trouble them again. Alexander read the message, folded it, and put it in the fire. Some apologies, he decided, were best answered with silence — and with a house full of children, laughing, in a home that would stand for another hundred years.

More posts