Chapter 2: THE SECRET BENEATH THE INSURANCE CLAIM

Written by

in

Reading settings

For several seconds, nobody moved.

Marco stood beside Samantha, his attention fixed on Ethan.

“What did you mean?” he asked.

Ethan swallowed.

“Your brother wasn't the only Bellini who was betrayed.”

Marco's expression didn't change.

“Explain.”

“Not here.”

“You're in no position to negotiate.”

Ethan looked toward Samantha.

“She knows about the archive. She has the original records. You need to understand that Victor isn't the only person involved.”

Marco glanced at Gianni.

“Take him upstairs.”

Ethan immediately protested.

“You can't keep me here!”

Gianni approached with two security officers.

“We're not asking you to stay.”

“I'll call the police.”

Marco adjusted his watch.

“That's an excellent idea. Tell them exactly why you were trying to steal confidential evidence from an insurance investigator.”

Ethan's mouth closed.

The security officers escorted him toward the private elevator. Nobody struck him, threatened him, or needed to. His own knowledge of Marco Bellini's reputation was sufficient.

Samantha watched until the elevator doors closed.

Then she turned toward Marco.

“Where are you taking me?”

“Somewhere secure.”

“I have a car.”

“Your car is probably being watched.”

“You don't know that.”

“I know Ethan.”

“You know him?”

Marco looked at her.

“I know enough.”

She folded her arms.

“I'm not going anywhere with a stranger just because he happens to drive an expensive car.”

For the first time, Marco seemed genuinely interested in her response.

“Fair enough.”

He reached into his jacket and produced a business card.

“Marco Bellini. My office is on the sixty-first floor. You can call your colleague, your supervisor, or the police. But you shouldn't walk out of this building alone.”

Samantha examined the card.

It contained a name, a telephone number, and a discreet company logo.

Nothing else.

“You're expecting me to trust you?”

“No.”

His answer surprised her.

“I'm expecting you to think.”

She looked toward the garage entrance.

A black SUV was parked near the ramp. Two men stood beside it, watching the elevator.

“Are those your people?”

“Yes.”

“Are they following me?”

“They're watching the entrance.”

“That's not reassuring.”

“It wasn't meant to be.”

She almost laughed despite herself.

Marco opened the rear passenger door of the Bentley.

“You can come upstairs, use a secure telephone, and decide what to do next. Or you can leave through the lobby with my security team following at a distance.”

Samantha considered both possibilities.

The second sounded exhausting.

She entered the Bentley.

Marco followed her.

***

Halstead Tower's sixty-first floor was nothing like the ballroom downstairs.

The elevator opened into a private reception area furnished with dark walnut panels, polished stone, and enormous windows overlooking Chicago.

There were no photographs.

No personal decorations.

Everything appeared expensive, deliberate, and cold.

Gianni was waiting beside the reception desk.

“She's safe?” he asked.

“She is.”

Gianni looked at Samantha.

“Miss Reed.”

“You know my name too?”

“Your name has been mentioned.”

“By whom?”

Gianni glanced at Marco.

“Not by me.”

Marco removed his jacket and handed it to an assistant.

“Prepare the conference room. No one enters without permission.”

“Understood.”

Samantha followed Marco into a room with a long black table and floor-to-ceiling windows.

A glass of water appeared in front of her.

She didn't touch it.

Marco sat opposite her.

“Show me the archive.”

“No.”

He nodded.

“Then tell me what you discovered.”

“Why should I?”

“Because Ethan is not the only person who wants that information.”

“That's exactly why I don't want to show it to you.”

Marco leaned back.

“Do you know what happened at the Mercer warehouse?”

“An electrical fire in 2022. Three people died. The insurance company paid out a claim of nearly nine million dollars.”

“Four people died.”

Samantha looked up.

“Four?”

“My brother Luca was inside.”

The room became very quiet.

Marco looked toward the city.

“He was thirty-one. He had gone to the warehouse to meet a property manager. When the fire started, two employees were trapped inside. Luca helped them reach an exit.”

“Was he killed in the fire?”

“Yes.”

His answer was immediate.

She watched his face.

“You expect me to accept that?”

“No. I expect you to verify it.”

He opened a folder.

Inside were copies of bank transfers, claim summaries, and corporate registrations.

“Four years ago, the insurance payout was divided among three companies. Two were legitimate businesses. The third was Meridian Recovery Holdings.”

Samantha recognized the name.

“Ethan's company.”

“Not originally. It was created through several layers of ownership. Ethan became its administrator later.”

“Why?”

“Because someone needed a person who could access Northstar's internal systems.”

She looked at the documents again.

“Victor Hale.”

Marco nodded.

“Victor controlled the financial approvals. Ethan controlled the data.”

“And what did you control?”

“Other things.”

His tone made it clear he wouldn't elaborate.

Samantha pushed the folder away.

“What's M-17?”

“A project number.”

“For what?”

“Moving money through false claims, shell companies, and legitimate insurance payouts.”

“How much?”

“More than fifty million dollars.”

Samantha stared at him.

“Fifty million?”

“Possibly more.”

“And you think the tablet proves it?”

“I think it contains the original ledger.”

She shook her head.

“The tablet has encrypted records, not a complete ledger.”

“There's a second layer.”

“How do you know?”

“Because Luca sent a message to my brother's private account three days before he died.”

Marco opened another file.

It contained a printed message.

*If anything happens to me, look beneath the first payment. The second ledger will tell you who really owns the money.*

Samantha read it twice.

“Why didn't you give this to the police?”

“I did.”

“And?”

“The report disappeared.”

“That's impossible.”

Marco looked at her.

“You work in insurance. Surely you understand that paperwork can disappear when enough people are paid to make it disappear.”

She didn't have an answer.

***

At 1:15 a.m., Samantha finally agreed to examine the tablet.

Marco had insisted on using a secure computer without connecting it to any external network.

She opened the M-17 directory.

The first layer contained payment records.

The second contained authorization histories.

The third was locked.

A password prompt appeared.

“That's strange,” she murmured.

“What?”

“This isn't a normal company archive. The directory has been built around a hidden access structure.”

“Can you open it?”

“Maybe.”

She examined the encryption metadata.

A series of dates appeared.

One corresponded to the day Ethan had been dismissed from Northstar.

Another corresponded to the day the Mercer claim was approved.

The final date was the day Luca died.

Samantha entered her investigator credentials.

The screen rejected them.

She tried again.

Nothing.

“Whoever created this expected a different authorization key.”

Marco leaned forward.

“Can you identify it?”

“Not yet.”

She opened the metadata.

A list of authorized personnel appeared.

Victor Hale.

Ethan Cole.

A former Northstar director.

And one unfamiliar name.

S. REED — INVESTIGATIVE ACCESS.

Samantha frowned.

“That's impossible.”

Marco studied the screen.

“Your name?”

“Yes.”

“Were you assigned to this investigation four years ago?”

“I was nineteen.”

“Then someone used your credentials.”

She opened the authorization history.

The file showed an access attempt made six months earlier.

It had originated from Ethan's company terminal.

Samantha felt sick.

“He used my credentials.”

“Can you prove that?”

“Not yet.”

She looked at Marco.

“Why would he need my identity?”

“To make the records appear legitimate.”

Her phone vibrated.

Olivia.

Samantha answered immediately.

“Olivia?”

“Where are you? I've called you twelve times.”

“I'm safe.”

“Where?”

Samantha hesitated.

“Halstead Tower.”

“Are you alone?”

“No.”

A pause.

“Is Ethan with you?”

“No.”

“Good. Listen carefully. Someone accessed your Northstar account after you left the ballroom. Your supervisor has been asking questions.”

“Who accessed it?”

“We don't know. But they downloaded a file using your authorization.”

Samantha looked at the tablet.

“What file?”

Olivia lowered her voice.

“An internal transfer authorization.”

“Which one?”

“The Mercer settlement.”

Samantha felt the room tilt.

“That's impossible.”

“Sam, the system says you approved it.”

“I never approved anything.”

“Then someone has your signature.”

Samantha looked toward Marco.

He had been watching her carefully.

“Olivia, don't open anything else. Don't download anything. Don't answer questions from Victor Hale.”

“Why?”

“Because I think someone is framing me.”

The call ended.

For a moment, Samantha couldn't speak.

Marco moved the glass of water closer.

“Now you understand why Ethan wanted the tablet.”

“He's framing me.”

“Yes.”

“He wants the company to believe I stole the records.”

“He wants you to become the official explanation for everything that happened.”

Samantha stood.

“I need to leave.”

Marco remained seated.

“Where?”

“To find proof.”

“Then we find it.”

She turned toward him.

“I'm not asking you to help.”

“Good. I don't require permission to investigate something that concerns my family.”

“That sounds convenient.”

“It is.”

She walked toward the door.

Marco rose.

“Samantha.”

She stopped.

“If you walk out now, you'll be alone against people who have already demonstrated that they can manipulate your professional identity.”

“I've handled difficult investigations before.”

“This isn't an ordinary investigation.”

“I'm aware.”

He stepped closer, leaving enough distance for her to move freely.

“You stay with me.”

Her eyes narrowed.

“That's an order?”

“No.”

“Then don't phrase it like one.”

Marco looked at her for a long moment.

“Stay because you choose to. Not because I can make you.”

Samantha glanced toward the tablet.

Then toward the dark windows.

Finally, she returned to her chair.

“Until morning,” she said.

Marco nodded.

“Until morning.”

The conference room settled into silence after Samantha returned to her chair. Beyond the glass, Chicago glittered beneath the dark sky, but the city seemed strangely distant from the sixty-first floor.

Marco remained by the window, his hands resting in his trouser pockets.

Samantha watched him for a moment. “You said Luca sent you a message three days before the fire. Was that the last time you heard from him?”

“No.” Marco turned slightly. “I spoke to him the evening before.”

“What did he say?”

“He wanted to meet. He sounded tired, but not frightened. Luca rarely admitted when something worried him.”

“Did he tell you about M-17?”

“He said the numbers didn't match. He had found payments that appeared twice in different records, and a company that existed on paper but seemed to have no real business. He believed someone had changed the original agreements.”

“Did you believe him?”

“I believed he was concerned. I didn't understand how far the problem went.” Marco looked down at the city. “I told him to bring the documents to me the next morning.”

“But he never came.”

“No.”

Samantha let the silence sit between them. “Why didn't you go looking for him that night?”

“I did. I called him after our conversation. His phone went to voicemail. I thought he had gone back to the warehouse to check something, and I assumed he would call when he finished.” His jaw tightened. “By the time I learned about the fire, the official report was already being prepared.”

“That's why you've spent four years searching?”

“That's part of it.” He turned to face her. “I spent the first year trying to establish what happened at the warehouse. The second following the money. The third trying to find the records Luca said would identify the people behind the transfers. Every trail ended at a company that had been dissolved, an account that had been emptied, or a person who suddenly remembered nothing.”

“And this year?”

“This year I learned Northstar still had an archive that hadn't been completely erased.”

Samantha glanced at the tablet. “You knew someone inside the company might find it.”

“I knew someone had to. I didn't know it would be you.”

“Did Luca ever tell you why he kept investigating after he realized the agreements had been changed?”

Marco considered the question. “He said people had trusted those policies. Small businesses, families, workers. They believed the insurance would protect them if something went wrong. He couldn't accept that someone had turned that promise into a way to steal from them.”

Samantha's expression softened. “That sounds like someone worth remembering.”

“He was.” Marco paused. “He was also stubborn. He thought he could persuade people to do the right thing if he showed them enough proof.”

“Sometimes proof isn't enough.”

“I learned that too late.”

She looked at him carefully. “You keep saying you were searching for the ledger. But I think you were searching for something else as well.”

“What?”

“An answer that would make his death feel less senseless.”

Marco didn't reply immediately. His eyes stayed on the lights below.

“Maybe,” he said at last. “I spent the first year trying to establish what happened at the warehouse. The second following the money. The third trying to find the records Luca said would identify the people behind the transfers. Every trail ended at a company that had been dissolved, an account that had been emptied, or a person who suddenly remembered nothing.”

Samantha lowered her gaze to the cross pendant resting against her dress.

“I know what it's like to have someone else's version of events placed in front of you and be told to accept it.”

Marco looked back at her. “Is that what happened with Ethan?”

“Not exactly. But he was very good at explaining what I supposedly meant, what I supposedly wanted, and why I supposedly needed him to decide things for me.” She met Marco's eyes. “I won't do that again.”

“You shouldn't.”

“And I won't become another person who carries your questions for you.”

“I wouldn't ask that.”

“You might not mean to. But if we're going to examine this together, I need the truth even when it's uncomfortable.”

Marco nodded slowly. “Then ask me again whenever you think I'm holding something back.”

“That's not quite the same as volunteering it.”

“No,” he admitted. “It isn't.”

For the first time that night, Samantha saw the uncertainty beneath his composure. He had spent years learning how to command a room, but he seemed less certain how to speak about the brother he had lost.

She closed the tablet cover.

“Get some rest, Marco.”

“I could say the same to you.”

“I doubt either of us will listen.”

A faint, tired smile crossed his face. “You're probably right.”

They returned to their separate thoughts, with the unanswered questions still between them, but no longer entirely unspoken.

But neither of them would sleep.

Because at 2:03 a.m., Gianni entered the room carrying a printed report.

“Boss.”

Marco looked up.

“What is it?”

Gianni placed the report on the table.

“We found the second authorization.”

Samantha read the name.

It wasn't Ethan's.

It wasn't Victor's.

It was Marco Bellini's.

And the document showed that he had personally authorized a payment to Meridian Recovery Holdings four years earlier.

More posts