Chapter 2: The Rules of Revenge

Written by

in

Reading settings

Luca chose the restaurant. Of course he did. It was the kind of place with no sign on the door and a host who knew his name, a long room with dark wood and low light, where the tables were far enough apart that no one could hear you unless you wanted them to.

He was already there when I arrived, sitting at the same booth as the day before, a cup of black coffee in front of him, untouched. He stood when he saw me. I had not expected that. Men like Luca Moretti were not supposed to stand for anyone.

"You came," he said.

"I said I would." I slid into the booth across from him. I had chosen my dress carefully that morning, a dark navy sheath, simple and sharp, the kind of dress that said I was not a woman to be pitied. My hair was down. My lipstick was red. If I was going to sit across from a mafia boss and negotiate revenge, I was going to look like a woman who could hold her own.

The waiter appeared, and Luca ordered for both of us without asking me, which should have annoyed me and somehow did not. "She'll have the salmon," he said. "And bring the good bread."

"You don't know what I like," I said when the waiter left.

"I know you haven't eaten a real meal in two days," he said. "I know you drink your coffee black when you're stressed and with cream when you're not. I know you straighten your hair when you have a presentation and leave it down when you don't. Your hair is down today."

I stared at him. "Have you been watching me?"

"I have known who you are for years, Claire. Your husband and my wife have been best friends with each other for a decade. I notice things. It is my business to notice things."

"That is either the most romantic thing anyone has ever said to me or the most terrifying."

"Both," he said, and for the second time, amusement crossed his face. "Probably both."

The bread arrived. I tore off a piece because my hands needed something to do.

"Rules," I said. "You said rules."

Luca leaned back. "Six weeks. We are seen together in public, often enough that word gets back to Ryan and Vanessa. Dinners. A charity event. The kind of places where people talk. We are warm with each other. We are happy. We are, in every way that matters to an audience, a couple."

"And in private?"

"In private, we are two people who were betrayed, having dinner. Nothing more. No pretending between us. That is the first rule: no lies between us. We have both had enough of those."

I nodded slowly. That, at least, made sense.

"Second rule," he said. "You can end this at any time. One word, and it stops. No questions, no arguments. The same goes for me."

"Third rule?"

"Your father and your job come first. I will not ask you to miss a hospital visit or a meeting for this. And I will not involve your family. Your parents never meet my world unless you decide otherwise."

"Fourth rule," I said, surprising myself. "No violence. I don't want anyone hurt because my husband is a coward."

Luca was quiet for a moment. "I can promise you that no one will be hurt on your account," he said carefully. "That is a promise I can keep."

"And what do you get out of this?" I asked. "Besides the satisfaction?"

"Vanessa left me for a man who sells software and plays golf on Sundays," he said, and his voice went flat in a way that told me this was the wound. "She told me I was married to my family and my name, and that she was lonely. She was right about the lonely part. I was never home. I was building an empire and I thought providing was the same as being present. It is not. I know that now."

He looked down at his coffee. "I want her to see what she threw away. And I want to feel, for once, like a man a woman actually chooses. Even if it is pretend. Even if it is only for six weeks."

Something in my chest shifted. I had come here expecting a cold man with a cold plan. I had not expected honesty.

"Six weeks," I said. "And then we walk away, and we never speak of it again."

"Six weeks," he agreed. "And then we walk away."

We shook on it, across the white tablecloth, like two people signing a contract. His hand was warm and steady, and it swallowed mine completely.

The salmon arrived, and for the first time in two days, I ate. Really ate. Luca watched me with something that might have been approval.

"Tell me about your father," he said.

So I told him. About Robert Bennett, sixty-one years old, a high school history teacher for thirty-five years, a man who still graded papers at the kitchen table and called his students "young citizens." About the heart attack, and the hospital, and my father's stubborn promise to live long enough to meet his grandchildren.

"He sounds like a good man," Luca said.

"He is the best man I know," I said. "Which is probably why I married the worst one."

"Ryan is not the worst man," Luca said, and I looked up, surprised. "He is a weak man. There is a difference. Weak men do the most damage because they never mean to, and so they never stop."

I thought about that all the way home.

That afternoon, my phone rang. Maya Chen, finally getting through.

"Claire Bennett, you are going to tell me everything right now or I am coming to your apartment with ice cream and a crowbar."

I laughed, and then I told her. All of it. The texts. The photo. The coat. The pearls. The letter. My father. And Luca Moretti, sitting in my parking garage with three black SUVs and an offer.

There was a long silence on the other end.

"Okay," Maya said at last. "Okay. First of all, Ryan is dead to me. Second of all, Vanessa is dead to me. Third of all, your father is going to be fine, because he is Robert Bennett and he does not quit. And fourth of all… Claire, are you sure about this Luca thing? He is a mafia boss. An actual mafia boss. People whisper his name."

"I know what he is," I said. "But Maya, he was the only person yesterday who looked at me like I mattered."

"Then be careful," she said. "Promise me you'll be careful."

"I promise."

That evening, Luca sent a car for me. Not one of the black SUVs — a simple dark sedan, with a driver who opened my door and did not speak unless spoken to. The car took me to a house on the edge of the city, behind high walls and a gate that opened without anyone visible.

Luca's house was not what I expected. I had imagined something cold and grand, marble and chandeliers. Instead, it was warm. Wood floors. Bookshelves full of actual books, worn at the spines. A kitchen that smelled faintly of garlic and coffee. A photograph on the mantel of a woman with Luca's eyes, smiling in a garden.

"My mother," Luca said, following my gaze. "She died when I was twenty-four. She was the only person in this family who ever told me no."

"And your father?"

"Gone longer. The family was his life, and it killed him the way it kills everyone who gives it everything."

He poured two glasses of wine and led me out to a terrace overlooking the desert, where the sun was going down in bands of orange and purple.

"Tomorrow night," he said, "there is a charity gala at the Bellagio. The Moretti Foundation hosts it every year. Ryan and Vanessa will be there. Vanessa never misses it. She likes being photographed."

My stomach tightened. "Tomorrow?"

"You don't have to," he said. "Rule two. One word."

I thought about Vanessa in my coat, smiling at the airport. I thought about Ryan's letter, about being too successful, too confident, too capable. I thought about my father in his hospital bed, telling me to find someone better.

"No," I said. "I want to go. What do I wear?"

Luca looked at me, and something in his expression changed, just slightly, like a door opening a crack.

"Something red," he said. "Vanessa always wears cream. Let her look washed out next to you."

He walked me back through the house, and on the way I met Enzo Vitale, Luca's right hand, a broad man in his fifties with gray at his temples and kind eyes that did not match the rest of him. He was carrying a stack of files, and when he saw me, he stopped dead.

"Enzo," Luca said, "this is Claire Bennett."

Enzo set the files down slowly, like a man handling something fragile. "Mrs. Bennett," he said, and his voice was respectful in a way that made me stand up straighter. "I have heard a great deal about you. All of it good."

"Thank you," I said, and I meant it, because no one had said anything good about me in days.

"Enzo has been with my family since before I was born," Luca said as we walked to the door. "He taught me to drive. He also taught me that a man who cannot admit he is wrong will die wrong."

"Is that why you keep him around?"

"That is one of the reasons."

At the door, Luca stopped. "Claire. One more thing. Tomorrow night, Vanessa will try to get to you. She will say something designed to make you feel small. She has done it before, to other women. She is very good at it."

"And what do I do?"

"You do nothing," he said. "You smile. You hold my arm. You let her watch you be happy. That is the whole revenge. You do not have to say a single cruel word. Happiness is crueler than any insult, because she cannot argue with it."

I nodded, and then, before I could think better of it, I said, "Why are you being so kind to me? You don't owe me anything."

Luca was quiet for a moment, looking out at the desert dark beyond the gate.

"Because yesterday morning," he said, "I stood in a restaurant and watched a woman I had just met laugh for the first time in a day, and it was the first honest thing I had seen in weeks. My world is full of people who want something from me. You wanted nothing. You just wanted to stop hurting. That is worth being kind to."

The car took me home through the bright, indifferent city. My mother called while I was in the elevator.

"Your father sat up today," she said. "He ate half a bowl of soup. The doctor says he is doing better than expected."

"That's wonderful, Mom."

"Claire." Her voice dropped. "Are you all right? Really?"

I thought about lying. I thought about saying I was fine. But my mother had held my father's hand through a heart attack without crying, and she deserved the truth.

"No," I said. "I'm not all right. But I'm doing something about it. I'll tell you everything when Dad is stronger. I promise."

"Okay, baby," she said softly. "Okay. Just remember who you are. You are Claire Bennett. You built your whole life with your own two hands. No man gets to take that from you. Not Ryan. Not anyone."

"I know, Mom. I love you."

"I love you too."

The next morning, before the gala, I went to the hospital. My father was sitting up in bed, eating toast with the slow concentration of a man who had been told to take it easy and resented every minute of it.

"Well, look at you," he said, eyeing my work clothes. "You look like you're going to close a deal."

"I'm going to a gala tonight," I said, and I sat on the edge of his bed the way I had when I was small. "A charity gala. The Moretti Foundation."

My father went very still. "The Moretti Foundation," he repeated. "Claire. That's Luca Moretti's family."

"I know, Dad."

"And you're going with him."

It wasn't a question. I nodded anyway.

My father was quiet for a long moment, looking at his hands. "Your mother told me about the card. About the offer." He looked up at me. "I want you to be careful, baby girl. Men like Luca Moretti don't live in our world. Their world has rules I don't understand."

"I know that," I said. "But Dad, he's been kinder to me in two days than Ryan was in five years. And it's just a gala. It's just one night."

My father studied my face the way he used to study my report cards, looking for the truth underneath the grades.

"Then go," he said at last. "And wear something that makes you feel like yourself. Not like someone trying to impress anyone. Yourself."

"I will, Dad."

"And Claire?" He caught my hand as I stood to leave. "Whatever happens tonight, remember: you are not the woman Ryan left. You are the woman he was lucky to have. Don't you ever let him forget it."

I kissed his forehead and left, and all the way to the office, his words sat in my chest like a warm stone.

I went home that night and stood in front of my closet for a long time. Then I pulled out the red dress I had bought for a work awards dinner and never worn, because Ryan had said it was "a bit much."

It was, I decided, exactly enough.

When the car came for me the next evening, I was ready. Red dress. Hair up. The pearl necklace — no. Not the pearls. Ryan's mother had given me those, and Vanessa was wearing them in the airport photo. I wore nothing around my neck at all, and my collarbones caught the light like something sharp.

Luca was waiting at the bottom of the steps in a black tuxedo, and when he saw me, he stopped walking.

"Claire," he said quietly.

"Is it too much?" I asked.

"It is perfect," he said, and he offered me his arm. "Shall we go make them regret everything?"

"Yes," I said, and I took his arm. "Let's."

More posts