Chapter 4: The Man Who Poured the Wine

Written by

in

Reading settings

The estate at Chestnut Hill had belonged to Dominic's grandfather, and it showed its pedigree the way old soldiers show scars — the walls were thick, the windows were narrow for a rich man's house, and every door in it could be locked from the inside and barred from the outside. Dominic put me in a suite two doors from his own, with Petra in the room across the hall and men I never saw rotate through the garden below my window in the rain. I slept nine hours the first night, the sleep of the wrung-out, with my mother's letters in their shoebox beside the bed, and woke to the smell of coffee and the discovery that an organization hunting a traitor runs on a schedule like a war.

Petra ran the estate the way Frank ran security — invisibly and completely — and on the first morning she walked me around the grounds herself, because, she said, a guest who doesn't know where the paths go is a prisoner with better furniture. She was sixty-one, ramrod-straight, and had served the Romanos for thirty-one years. She had ironed Dominic's first suit. She had laid out his father's body clothes in this house twenty years ago, a fact she mentioned with the same tone she used for the linen inventory, and which told me more about the Romano family than any newspaper: the people inside the walls stayed, for decades, through everything, which meant the walls themselves were not the problem. One person inside them was.

"The old man built them thick," she said, knocking a knuckle against the garden wall as we passed, "the grandfather. He used to say a Romano should be able to hear trouble coming." She glanced at me sidelong. "This week, Miss Henderson, the whole house is listening."

They found Eddie Voss on the second day.

Not dead — that was the surprise, and I watched Frank deliver the news from a wheelchair he was already trying to escape, his leg propped and his face still gray. Eddie had run to a cousin in Providence and then thought better of running, the way small men do when the money in the envelope starts to feel like it has teeth. Dominic's people had picked him up coming out of a liquor store, and Eddie had begun talking in the car before anyone had asked him anything, terrified that the silence of the men around him meant the Callahans had found him first.

That afternoon, before they brought Eddie in, Vic Santoro took lunch with us on the terrace — his idea, announced as a morale operation. He arrived with a bottle from the estate cellar and poured for all three of us himself, turning each glass as he filled it, the heavy gold ring with its flat black stone flashing in the autumn light like a signal I didn't yet know how to read.

"Your father and I drank this vintage the night you were born, Dom," he said. "He stood on this terrace and said the boy would either save this family or bury it." He raised his glass. "Still deciding, eh?"

Dominic drank without hesitation — of course he did; it was Vic — and Vic turned to me with that uncle's warmth and said, "And you, kid. I keep thinking about it. Whoever did this picked the wrong girl in Boston to make a witness of. Most people would've run from that table. My own captains would've checked with me first." He shook his head, admiring. "You just ran at it."

"She does that," Dominic said quietly. "It's becoming a theme."

I laughed with them. I want that remembered too — that four hours before Eddie Voss described a gold ring with a black stone in a parking garage, I sat in the sun and laughed with the man who wore it, and felt, for the first time since the restaurant, almost safe. That was the worst of Vic, in the end. Not the poison. The weather he made around himself, that you grew up trusting before you ever thought to check the sky.

He was brought to the estate that evening. I asked to be there. Dominic looked at me for a long moment and then nodded at Frank, who wheeled himself aside to make a place for me at the long table in the study — not because I had a right to the room, but because I was the price this was all being paid in, and Dominic had decided I would never again be the last to know the cost.

Eddie Voss was thirty, thin, with the beautiful ruined hands of a man who had once genuinely been good with wine. He shook in his chair. He did not look at Dominic at all. He looked at me, and something in his face cracked.

"I didn't know," he said. "I want that said first, to her. I didn't know it was poison."

"Tell it in order," Frank said, not unkindly.

The order was this: Eddie had been a real sommelier once, in Providence, until a gambling debt ate his career. Three weeks before the Friday at Harborlight, a man had bought his debt — all of it, thirty-one thousand dollars — and offered him a job-shaped way out. A placement agency that didn't exist. References that wrote themselves. And one instruction, delivered the day before Dominic's reservation, in the parking garage where Eddie's fake life had been built: a small sealed vial, and a voice on a phone, and a man standing far enough away in the shadows of the concrete pillars that Eddie saw only a hand and part of a coat when the vial changed hands.

"It wasn't in the food," Eddie said. "It went in the decanter while I had my back to the room — the way I was told. 'In the wine, before it reaches the table. He drinks alone. Nobody interferes.' They said—" He swallowed. "They said if anything went wrong, if he started to die in the room, the staff had orders to keep everyone back, and it would look like his heart. They had the manager. They had the whole room. It was supposed to be quiet."

"It nearly was," Dominic said.

Eddie flinched. "The hand," he whispered. "That's all I saw of the man in the garage, and I've seen it every night since. A big hand. Gold ring — heavy, like a knuckle of gold — with a black stone in it, flat black, like a piece of night." He was looking at his own hands as he said it, miming the exchange. "And his cuff. There was a cufflink. A little silver anchor."

The study went silent in a particular way.

I stopped breathing, because I had seen that ring before — pouring my tea, turning the cup toward me with a laugh like gravel, the flat black stone catching the light — and I understood with a sick, descending clarity that the memory had been sitting in me since the first night at the penthouse, filed under kindness, while its owner called me kid and asked about my mother.

I did not say it in that room. God forgive me, I checked first — I looked at Dominic's face, at the twenty years of trust in it, and I held my tongue for three whole minutes while Frank finished with Eddie and the man was led out weeping with relief at being merely arrested. Then I asked, in a voice that sounded calm to everyone but me, whether I could speak to Dominic alone.

I told him in the corridor, in one breath, and I watched the most dangerous man in Boston refuse me.

"No," he said.

"Dominic—"

"No." He said it quietly, without heat, which was worse. "Vic Santoro carried me out of a burning warehouse in 2009 with his own back on fire. He has held my organization together through two wars and a federal investigation. He has a ring like a thousand men in this city have rings. I am not hanging twenty years on a tea cup."

"I'm not asking you to hang him. I'm asking you to look."

"I am looking," he said, and for the first time since I'd met him, Dominic Romano raised his voice — not at me, but through me, at the intolerable shape of the thing. "I am looking at the fact that the only way this works is if it is him, Chloe. The table. The wine. The staff orders — Richard takes orders from money, and the money came through Harborline, and do you know how many men can authorize a Harborline payment?" He held up three fingers, one at a time. "Me. Vic. And my accountant, Peter Lang." His hand dropped. "And Peter Lang has not been seen in nine days."

It came out over the next day, in pieces Frank assembled with the grim patience of a man building a gallows he didn't want to finish. Richard had been picked up by Boston police on an unrelated warrant and was talking to anyone who would listen; his twenty thousand had come with instructions by phone, voice disguised, and the promise of more if the waitress stayed ruined. Peter Lang's car had been found at a rest stop on I-95 with his phone in the glove box — wiped, staged, a disappearance arranged to look voluntary. And Vic Santoro, in every meeting, had been the loudest voice for the simplest theory: Lang took Callahan money, Lang ran Harborline, Lang ran, and when they found Lang the whole thing would tie off in a bow. Find Lang. Everything was Lang. Vic mentioned Lang the way a drummer keeps time.

That night I found Dominic in the study at the long table, alone with two glasses and a bottle he wasn't drinking from, and I sat down across from him and said the thing I'd been rehearsing since the corridor.

"Test him."

He looked up.

"You told me the leak knew Frank's route an hour after Frank set it. So feed the house a route. One piece of information, given to Vic and nobody else — a place I'll be moved to, a time, a reason. If the Callahans hit it, you'll have your answer. If nothing happens, I'll apologize to him myself, on my knees, and never say the word ring again." I held his stare. "You said whoever sells us again will have to look you in the eye. Give him something to sell, Dominic. And watch his hands."

The silence lasted a long time. Then Dominic reached across the table and turned my empty glass upright, and poured me two fingers of the wine he hadn't been drinking, and his voice, when it came, was the saddest I had ever heard it.

"Eleven minutes," he said. "That's what you cost them. Do you know that's why I trust you with this? Every other person in my life wants something from me. You are the only one who ever gave me something and refused the receipt." He raised his glass a fraction. "Tomorrow morning, in front of Frank, I will tell Vic Santoro — and only Vic Santoro — that you are being moved on Thursday to a house in Gloucester. And then, Chloe, we will see what the Callahans do with a lie."

They hit the Gloucester house on Thursday at dawn. Six men, two vehicles, anchor tattoo on the point man's wrist, and Frank's ambush waiting in the fog with the state police on a joint task force Dominic had quietly fed for a year. It was over in four minutes, and not one person in Chestnut Hill celebrated, because the trap had worked — and a trap like that only works when the traitor is real.

Dominic stood at the study window watching the rain come back over the garden, and I stood behind him and said nothing, because there is nothing useful to say to a man watching twenty years burn. It was Vic who spoke first, at the door, hours later — summoned, unhurried, smiling his uncle's smile, asking if there was news. And Dominic turned from the window and looked at his oldest friend and said, with terrible gentleness:

"There is. On Saturday, I am holding a dinner in this house. Every captain. Every lieutenant. Full table, full service." His eyes never left Vic's face. "And Chloe will be there. Because she has remembered something about the night I was poisoned, Vic — something she hasn't told anyone yet. On Saturday, in front of the whole family, she's going to say what it is."

Vic's smile didn't move. But I was watching his right hand — the hand with the heavy gold ring and its flat black stone — and I saw it close, slowly, into a fist.

"Saturday," Vic said warmly. "I'll bring the wine."

More posts