Chapter 3: The Doctor Who Stole Their Childhood

Written by

in

Reading settings

At six o'clock the following morning, Dominic Moretti canceled every meeting on his calendar.

At six fifteen, he removed Victor Moretti's access to the family residence.

At six thirty, he instructed Gabriel Torres to replace every member of Sophie's security detail whose loyalty could not be independently verified.

And at seven, he made the most difficult phone call of his life.

He called the doctor who had delivered his daughters.

"Good morning, Dominic," Dr. Miriam Sloan answered pleasantly. "I was just reviewing Sophie's records for her appointment."

Dominic stood beside the townhouse kitchen window.

Across the room, Ava was helping Ruby tie her shoes.

Sophie was still asleep upstairs.

"That appointment is canceled."

A brief silence followed.

"Oh? Is Sophie unwell?"

"She's fine."

"Then perhaps we can reschedule."

"We'll let you know."

Dr. Sloan hesitated.

"Dominic, is everything all right?"

He watched Ava kneel beside Ruby.

The little girl was showing her mother a ribbon Sophie had given her.

Dominic remembered Dr. Sloan's calm voice after the birth.

He remembered the way she placed Sophie in his arms.

He remembered asking about Ava.

And he remembered her looking away before explaining that his wife had not survived.

"You tell me, Doctor."

Silence.

Then a nervous laugh.

"I'm afraid I don't understand."

"Neither do I."

He ended the call.

He had wanted to accuse her.

To demand answers.

To drive directly to her office and force her to explain how two living children had become one surviving infant and one nonexistent birth.

But Claire Bennett had warned him the previous night.

"Right now, we have evidence of serious inconsistencies. We do not have the complete truth. If you confront people before we preserve the records, they may destroy what we need."

Dominic hated waiting.

He hated uncertainty.

Most of all, he hated that for years he had accepted explanations simply because they came from people he trusted.

He had never questioned the paperwork concerning Sophie's birth.

He had never demanded the original medical records.

He had never investigated the medical examiner's report with the suspicion he applied to every business transaction.

His grief had made him vulnerable.

Victor had known exactly how to use it.

A small voice interrupted his thoughts.

"Mr. Dominic?"

Ruby stood beside him.

Her stuffed rabbit dangled from one hand.

She was wearing a borrowed pair of Sophie's pajamas, pink cotton with tiny stars.

Dominic crouched.

"Good morning, Ruby."

"Can I ask you something?"

"Anything."

"Are you a bad man?"

The question struck him harder than any accusation Ava could have made.

He glanced toward her.

She was standing near the kitchen doorway, perfectly still.

Dominic looked back at Ruby.

"Why do you ask?"

Ruby twisted the rabbit's ear.

"Mommy used to say we had to hide from bad people. And yesterday she was scared when she saw you."

Dominic considered giving her the easy answer.

No, sweetheart.

I'm a good man.

You don't have to worry.

But he had told enough convenient lies in his lifetime.

And this little girl deserved something better.

"I've made some bad choices," he said carefully. "Choices I regret."

Ruby watched him.

"Did you make Mommy cry?"

His throat tightened.

"I think I did, a long time ago."

"On purpose?"

"Not on purpose."

Ruby thought about that.

"Then you should say sorry."

Dominic's eyes burned.

"You're right."

She nodded approvingly.

"When I broke Mommy's blue cup, I said sorry. She said cups can be replaced, but telling the truth is important."

Dominic glanced at Ava.

She looked away, wiping her cheek.

He turned back to Ruby.

"Your mother is a very smart woman."

"I know."

Ruby leaned closer.

"She also makes the best grilled cheese sandwiches."

Dominic smiled faintly.

"She always did."

Ruby's eyes widened.

"You know her sandwiches?"

"I used to eat them all the time."

"Then you must know her a lot."

He swallowed.

"I did."

Ruby studied his face.

"Maybe you could know her again."

Dominic could not answer.

The little girl placed her hand on his shoulder.

Then she wandered toward the breakfast table, apparently satisfied that she had settled a complicated adult problem.

Ava remained in the doorway.

"She asks difficult questions," Dominic said.

"She always has."

"Just like you."

Ava looked at the floor.

"Don't do that."

"What?"

"Talk like five years didn't happen."

He nodded slowly.

"You're right."

She studied him.

"Dominic, I need you to understand something."

"I'm listening."

"Ruby doesn't know the whole story. She knows we had to move sometimes. She knows I got scared when unfamiliar people asked questions. But I never told her that her father abandoned us."

Dominic's chest tightened.

"Thank you."

"I didn't do it for you."

"I know."

"I did it because I couldn't make myself teach her to hate someone she had never met."

He moved toward her, then stopped before entering her personal space.

"Ava, what you went through—"

"You don't know what I went through."

He lowered his head.

"No. I don't."

She looked toward Ruby.

"There were nights I put her to bed hungry because I had just enough money for one meal. I told her I wasn't hungry. She believed me."

Dominic shut his eyes.

"There were apartments where the heating didn't work. Jobs I couldn't keep because Victor's people kept finding me. Once, when Ruby was three, we slept in a bus station because I was afraid someone had followed us home."

"Ava…"

"And every time I wanted to call you, I remembered that photograph of Sophie. I remembered Victor telling me he could get to both girls."

Her voice broke.

"I wasn't trying to punish you. I was trying to keep them alive."

Dominic felt tears gathering.

"I know."

"No, you don't."

She looked straight at him.

"But maybe someday you will."

The sound of hurried footsteps interrupted them.

Sophie appeared on the staircase.

Her hair was tangled.

She wore a nightgown decorated with lavender butterflies.

And when she saw Ava, she stopped.

For several seconds, the little girl simply stared.

Dominic knew why.

Sophie had grown up with photographs of her mother.

There was one beside her bed.

Another in the library.

A framed wedding portrait hung in the upstairs hallway of the Moretti residence.

Dominic had always told Sophie that her mother loved her more than all the stars in the sky.

He had also told her that her mother was in heaven.

Now heaven was standing in the kitchen wearing an old beige sweater.

Sophie descended the stairs slowly.

"Are you really my mommy?"

Ava pressed a hand against her mouth.

"Yes, sweetheart."

Sophie stopped several feet away.

"Daddy said you died."

"I know."

"Did you go to heaven?"

"No, baby."

"Then where did you go?"

Ava dropped to her knees.

Her voice trembled.

"I was somewhere far away. And I couldn't get back to you."

Sophie frowned.

"Why?"

Ava's tears began falling.

"Because somebody told me you were gone, and later somebody frightened me into staying away."

Sophie considered this with the terrible seriousness only a young child could possess.

"Did you want to come back?"

"Every day."

"Did you miss me?"

"Every single day."

Sophie took another step.

"Even when I was a baby?"

"Especially then."

Her lower lip trembled.

"I waited for you on my birthdays."

Dominic turned away.

Ava made a broken sound.

"Oh, Sophie."

The little girl suddenly ran forward.

Ava caught her.

They collapsed into an embrace on the kitchen floor.

Ava buried her face in Sophie's hair.

Sophie wrapped both arms around her neck.

Dominic had witnessed men receive sentences that would keep them in prison for the rest of their lives without showing a flicker of emotion.

He had watched businesses collapse.

He had stood at funerals where nobody dared to cry.

But nothing in his life had prepared him for the sound his wife made while holding the daughter she had been forbidden to touch for five years.

It was not a normal sob.

It was grief escaping after being trapped for too long.

Ruby approached quietly.

"Mommy?"

Ava reached for her.

Ruby climbed into her lap beside Sophie.

And for the first time since the day of their birth, Ava Carter held both of her daughters at once.

Dominic stepped out into the courtyard.

He closed the door behind him.

Then he leaned against the brick wall and cried.

He did not care whether Gabriel saw.

He did not care whether anyone heard.

Some moments were too enormous for pride.

Ten minutes later, Claire arrived with news.

She had contacted an independent medical laboratory capable of performing a properly documented family DNA comparison.

Both parents had agreed to testing.

The results would take time, but Claire was arranging for the necessary samples to be collected through a qualified professional.

"There's no question in your minds?" Claire asked.

Dominic glanced through the glass door.

Ava was brushing Sophie's hair while Ruby carefully selected matching ribbons.

"No question at all."

Claire nodded.

"Then we still do this correctly. The girls deserve records that can't be challenged."

She placed several folders on the table.

"The next issue is Dr. Sloan."

Dominic's expression darkened.

"What did you find?"

"She resigned from the private medical center seven months after the fire. Then she opened a new practice with financial backing from a medical investment company."

"Owned by Victor?"

"Indirectly."

Claire opened a document.

"The investment company's parent entity is connected to Moretti Family Holdings."

Dominic studied the page.

"Victor controlled those accounts."

"Did you know that?"

"I knew he managed investments. I didn't review every transaction."

Claire looked at him sharply.

"That's going to become a problem."

"I understand."

"You can't claim ignorance about everything because you delegated authority."

Dominic met her gaze.

"I'm not asking you to protect me from what I actually did."

Claire seemed surprised.

He continued.

"I'm asking you to help me find out what happened to my wife and daughters. After that, I'll answer for whatever belongs to me."

Ava heard him.

She said nothing, but Dominic noticed that she stopped brushing Sophie's hair for a moment.

Claire turned to another folder.

"I also checked the nurse your wife mentioned. Cora Bell."

Ava approached immediately.

"Did you find her?"

"Possibly. A woman with that name renewed a nursing license in Wisconsin three years ago. She now works at a small rehabilitation clinic."

Ava grabbed the edge of the table.

"Cora saved us."

"Then she's an important witness," Claire said.

"I tried to contact her after we escaped. She sent me a message saying it wasn't safe."

"Have you spoken since?"

"Not directly."

Claire considered this.

"Would she recognize your handwriting?"

"Yes."

"Then write her a letter. Something personal. Something Victor wouldn't know."

Ava sat down.

She thought for several minutes.

Then she wrote:

Cora, you told me that if I ever saw the northern lights, I should remember there was still beauty in the world. I kept that promise. Now I need you to help me keep another one.

She folded the note.

Claire took it.

"I'll arrange secure delivery."

Dominic looked at the girls.

They were making a castle out of couch cushions.

Ruby had appointed her rabbit the royal guard.

Sophie was insisting that royal guards should have swords.

Ruby argued that he needed a pillow instead because "hitting people isn't how you solve everything."

Dominic nearly laughed.

Then he realized Ruby had probably learned that lesson because her mother had spent years trying to keep violence away from her.

He wondered what Sophie would have learned if Ava had been allowed to raise both girls.

He wondered how many things his own world had taught Sophie without him noticing.

He had always believed money could protect her from danger.

Now he understood that money had merely surrounded her with people he had never learned to question.

That afternoon, Detective Hannah Brooks arrived.

She was a seasoned Chicago investigator with a calm voice and very little patience for evasive answers.

Dominic had known her professionally after a security threat involving Sophie's school.

She had never liked his family connections.

But she liked Sophie.

That was enough for now.

After listening to the account, she looked at Dominic.

"If half of this is accurate, we're dealing with forged medical documents, coercive threats, possible attempted murder, and a conspiracy that crosses multiple jurisdictions."

"Then investigate it."

"I intend to."

She turned toward Ava.

"Mrs. Carter, are you prepared to make a formal statement?"

Ava hesitated.

Dominic said nothing.

It had to be her decision.

Finally, Ava nodded.

"Yes."

Detective Brooks studied her.

"Are you afraid of retaliation?"

"Terrified."

"Then we'll discuss protective measures before anything becomes public."

Ava clasped her hands.

"My daughters are all I have."

Dominic looked down.

Brooks noticed.

She turned toward him.

"And Mr. Moretti, you need to understand something. Your connections may help us identify people, but they also create concerns. You don't get to investigate this by intimidating witnesses or sending armed employees to demand evidence."

Dominic nodded.

"Understood."

"Good."

Brooks leaned forward.

"Because whoever falsified a dead woman's signature was confident enough to believe nobody would challenge it."

"Victor has people everywhere," Dominic said.

"Nobody has people everywhere."

She paused.

"But powerful men often convince victims that they do."

Ava looked at her.

For the first time that day, something like relief crossed her face.

After the detective left, Dominic found Ava sitting alone in the courtyard.

The afternoon sun had warmed the brick walls.

She held the silver blackbird necklace in her palm.

Ruby had allowed her mother to take it off temporarily so the laboratory could photograph its distinctive marks.

Dominic sat on the bench opposite her.

"I remember buying that."

Ava smiled faintly.

"You were so proud of yourself."

"It took me three weeks to find someone who could make it the way I wanted."

"You told the jeweler the bird had to look like it was flying away."

"I remember."

She turned it over.

The back carried two tiny engraved letters.

D and A.

"For a long time, I hated it," she said.

Dominic looked at her.

"Why?"

"Because every time I saw it, I remembered the promise you made."

"That I'd never make you afraid to come home."

She nodded.

"Victor told me you'd broken it."

Dominic stared at the little silver bird.

"Maybe I broke part of it before Victor ever touched our lives."

Ava looked up.

He continued.

"I knew my family's businesses were dirty. I told myself I was keeping the worst people under control. I told myself that if I stepped away, someone worse would take over."

"That's what you always said."

"I know."

"And I told you that being less cruel than the other men didn't make the cruelty disappear."

He nodded.

"You were right."

Ava looked genuinely startled.

Dominic allowed a bitter smile.

"I should have said that years ago."

For a while, they sat in silence.

Then Ava asked the question he had been expecting.

"If proving what Victor did means exposing your organization, will you still do it?"

Dominic thought of his father.

His uncle.

The businesses.

The wealth.

The reputation that made people lower their voices when he entered a room.

Then he thought of Ruby saving half a cinnamon roll for her mother.

"Yes."

"Even if you lose everything?"

He looked through the glass door.

Sophie and Ruby were lying on the carpet, coloring two halves of the same picture.

"I already lost everything once," he said.

"I'm not going to let it happen again."

That evening, Claire received a call from Wisconsin.

Cora Bell had received Ava's message.

She wanted to speak.

Claire arranged a secure video conversation with Detective Brooks present.

Cora appeared on the screen shortly after eight.

She was a silver-haired woman in her sixties, with tired eyes and a face that seemed permanently shaped by worry.

When she saw Ava, she began to cry.

"Oh, sweetheart."

Ava covered her mouth.

"Cora."

"I've been afraid every day that they'd find you."

"We're safe for now."

Cora shook her head.

"No, Ava. Not until you know the whole truth."

Dominic leaned forward.

"I'm Dominic Moretti."

Cora's expression changed.

"I know who you are."

"Then you know I didn't order that fire."

Cora hesitated.

"I know something about that night. But I don't know everything."

Detective Brooks spoke.

"Ms. Bell, can you tell us why you helped Ava escape?"

Cora folded her hands.

"Because I overheard Dr. Sloan and Victor Moretti discussing the transfer. They thought nobody was listening."

"What did they say?"

Cora's voice trembled.

"Victor said the mother could never be allowed to testify. And he said the babies had to be separated."

Dominic felt his chest tighten.

"Why?"

Cora looked at him.

"Because Ava had found something."

Ava frowned.

"I was collecting records about the housing projects. I knew Victor was stealing public funds."

Cora nodded.

"But it wasn't just money."

The room went silent.

Cora drew a trembling breath.

"Mr. Moretti, your wife discovered that Victor was using the family businesses to hide payments connected to city contracts. He thought she had copied a ledger that would expose everyone involved."

Dominic looked at Ava.

"Did you?"

She shook her head.

"Not everything. I knew there was a secret account, but I hadn't gotten the original records."

Cora leaned closer to the camera.

"Victor believed you had."

Detective Brooks opened her notebook.

"Ms. Bell, are you willing to provide a statement about what you witnessed?"

"Yes. But there's something I need to show you first."

Cora lifted an old envelope.

Inside were two newborn identification bracelets.

One read:

MORETTI, SOPHIA — BABY A.

The other read:

MORETTI, RUBY — BABY B.

Ava began crying.

Cora held them closer to the camera.

"I kept them because I knew somebody would eventually try to erase that second baby."

Dominic stared at the bracelets.

Evidence.

Real evidence.

Not merely his instinct.

Not simply two identical faces.

The first surviving piece of the life someone had stolen.

Then Cora removed a small notebook from the envelope.

"I kept notes from that night," she said. "The transport time, the doctor on duty, the staff names. I was afraid to take the official records, but I wrote down what I heard."

Detective Brooks leaned forward.

"Could you read the entry for the ambulance transfer?"

Cora adjusted her glasses.

Her expression slowly changed.

"Oh, my God."

"What is it?" Ava asked.

Cora stared at the page.

"I forgot this."

Dominic gripped the edge of the table.

"Forgot what?"

Cora looked directly into the camera.

"The second ambulance."

Silence.

"There were two vehicles scheduled. One for Ava and Ruby. Another for Sophie."

Dominic nodded.

"We know Sophie never left the hospital."

"Yes," Cora whispered. "But the second ambulance did."

Detective Brooks stopped writing.

"What was inside it?"

Cora's eyes filled.

"A woman. I didn't know her name. She was unconscious. They brought her in after midnight, and Victor ordered the transfer himself."

Dominic felt his blood turn cold.

Cora wiped her cheeks.

"I heard later that the burned vehicle had been identified as the one carrying Ava."

She looked toward Ava.

"But Ava wasn't inside."

The silence became unbearable.

Cora's voice shook.

"Someone else was."

Dominic slowly turned toward Claire.

The fraudulent death report.

The missing medical records.

The sealed funeral.

The coffin he had never been allowed to open.

For five years, he had mourned a woman who was still alive.

Now he understood that the deception might have required another woman to die in her place.

Detective Brooks spoke quietly.

"We need to reopen the death investigation."

Dominic looked toward the living room.

His daughters were sleeping peacefully beside each other.

Neither had any idea how many lives had been destroyed to keep them apart.

Then he looked back at Cora.

"Tell us everything you remember."

Cora swallowed.

"I will."

She paused.

"But there's one more thing you need to know."

Dominic waited.

Cora's next words made his heart stop.

"The unidentified woman was wearing Ava's wedding ring."

More posts