Chapter 3: The Engagement Dinner

Written by

in

Reading settings

The private dining room at Callahan's had been dressed for the occasion like a bride — candles, cream roses, silver that caught the light and threw it back in coins. Fourteen chairs around a table built for twelve, because families always invite two more people than furniture. And at the far end, holding a glass of wine he hadn't touched, stood Ryan Mercer.

He was better-looking than I'd expected and worse-dressed than I'd hoped — Dallas money spent carelessly, a suit with the confidence of a man who believed the room was a negotiation he was winning. He saw Jenna first. I watched his whole face rearrange itself around her: pleasure, possession, the beginnings of a performance for an audience of relatives. Then he saw whose hand she was holding, and the performance stalled.

"Jenna," he said, warm as a fireplace in a house he didn't own. "You came."

"Hello, Ryan." Her voice was steady. Her hand in mine was not, quite, and I tightened my fingers around hers once — a sentence in a language of one syllable — and felt her steady in answer. "This is Evan."

Ryan's smile did the arithmetic of a man deciding how to play a card he hadn't expected to need this early. "The boyfriend," he said. "The famous boyfriend. Three weeks, is it? We were all starting to think Jenna had invented you to win an argument with her mother."

"Three weeks," I said. "And I assure you, Mr. Mercer, I'm extremely difficult to invent."

Something flickered across his face at the sound of his name in my mouth. He hadn't given it. Jenna hadn't given it, here, tonight. It was a small thing — a name, offered casually, the way you offer a man his own coat — and I watched it land exactly where I'd aimed it: in the half-second of his uncertainty about what else Jenna had told me, and what else I might know.

"Diane," I said, turning to the head of the table's nearer end, where Jenna's mother sat in silver-gray like a queen in a country she'd invented. "Thank you for including me. I know a seat at this table, on this night, isn't a small thing to give a stranger."

Diane Hart looked at me the way a jeweler looks at a stone she suspects is glass. "You're not a stranger, apparently. You're three weeks." She smiled with her mouth only. "Jenna keeps her cards so close. We know nothing about you. Where you're from. What you do. It isn't how this family usually—" she glanced at Ryan, "—does things."

"Mom," Matt said, from somewhere down the table, with the tone of a man who had said that word in that tone many times this month.

Matt Hart had his sister's jaw and none of her interest in fighting at tables. He stood and came around to shake my hand with both of his, like a man greeting weather he'd prayed for. "Evan. Matt. Jenna's told me— actually, she's told me nothing, she's a vault, but Natalie's thrilled, I'm thrilled. Welcome." He lowered his voice, in the vicinity of my ear, with the ease of a brother who had been waiting two years to say it to somebody: "He's been here since seven. Drinking my future in-laws' wine and telling my father about Dallas real estate. Please feel free to be exactly as impressive as she says you are."

"I wasn't aware she'd said."

"She hasn't. That's how I know." Matt grinned and moved on, and I found I liked him, which was inconvenient, because I had come here to work.

Natalie Brooks came to claim us next — lovely, quick, with her mother's warmth and her father's eyes, the kind that read a room like a ledger. She kissed Jenna's cheek and took both my hands. "So you're the reason she's been floating. Three weeks of my future sister-in-law checking her phone and smiling at it like a teenager — Matt said it was a man or a lottery win."

"I'm offended by the comparison," I said, "and I'm keeping it anyway."

She laughed, delighted, and something in the room's chemistry shifted a degree — the first of the Brooks weight landing on my side of the scale. Her father crossed to us then, a big silver-templed man in his sixties who had built restaurants the way I'd built other things, and stopped a full pace short of me with the particular stillness of recognition.

"Evan Blackwood," Richard Brooks said.

"Richard."

"You two know each other?" Diane said, too quickly.

"Know him?" Richard took my hand, and then, to the visible recalculation of the entire table, my shoulder. "Diane, Evan's group moved every crate of wine in this building for nine years. When the port strikes shut down half the city's supply chain, his people kept my restaurants fed. Half of Denver's dining rooms would have gone dark that winter." He beamed — genuinely, a man who loved an old debt repaid in company. "I tried to buy this man dinner four separate times. He never lets anyone buy him dinner."

"I'm letting you tonight," I said. "Jenna's orders."

Richard laughed and steered us to the table like a host reclaiming his favorite guests, and I did not look at Ryan Mercer. I didn't need to. I could feel the shape of his evening collapsing from the other side of the room — because his whole performance depended on me being a rumor, a fiction, a nobody Jenna had dressed up for one night; and instead I was a man the host owed his business to, being seated at the table's right hand.

The seating, as promised, had been a battle plan. Jenna was placed at her mother's right. I was placed beside Natalie — strategically harmless, Diane clearly believed: the fiancée would charm the stranger into trivia. And Ryan had been seated directly across from Jenna, close enough to perform intimacy for the whole table, close enough that every time Jenna lifted her glass she'd have to look past him.

He began before the appetizers.

"So. Evan." Ryan leaned in, all casual warmth, pitching his voice for an audience. "Jenna and I were together almost three years. Engaged." He let the word sit. "I suppose she's told you I left."

"She told me the engagement ended," I said. "By mutual decision."

"Mutual." He smiled at Jenna with the tenderness of a man closing his hand. "Jenna's being generous. She begged me to stay, you know. Cried. Said she'd reconsider Dallas, reconsider all of it, if I just gave her time." He shook his head fondly at the table. "I said no. I was proud. Biggest mistake of my life, coming here tonight to—"

"Ryan," Jenna said, and her voice was quiet, which in Jenna meant the opposite of weak. "That isn't what happened."

"Sweetheart—"

"Don't," she said. "Don't use that word at my brother's table. I asked you for six months. You told me a wife who needs six months to obey isn't a wife. I remember it exactly, because I wrote it down afterward, because I knew — I knew — that one day you'd tell it differently, with me cast as the girl who begged."

The table went very still. Down its length, Robert Hart — Jenna's father, a quiet man I'd been watching all evening hoard his words like a poor man hoards coins — set his glass down with great care and looked at Ryan Mercer the way a man looks at a debt he's finally decided to stop paying.

"The girl didn't beg, Ryan," Robert said, mildly. "She called her mother from our kitchen at 1 a.m. so she wouldn't be alone when she took the ring off. I made the tea. I watched her do it. She didn't cry until the ring was in the envelope." He turned his glass a quarter-turn on the linen. "Funny, the things a father remembers."

I said nothing. There are moments a man earns by standing close and moments he ruins by speaking; this one belonged to Jenna and the quiet man who'd made her tea. Across from her, Ryan's smile had gone the way of a candle in a doorway, and Diane — Diane was staring at her husband like a woman whose seating chart had just been read back to her as evidence.

Natalie, who would run this family one day and everyone at the table but Diane already knew it, rescued the wreckage with the grace of her trade. "Well," she said brightly, lifting her glass. "To accurate memories, then. And to Matt, who has never once made me tea at 1 a.m., but who I am marrying anyway, because he dances at weddings and he always, always checks that I got home."

The table laughed — really laughed — and the dinner lurched back onto its rails, and course followed course in candlelight, and I did the work I'd come to do. I kept Jenna close. Not possessively — that was Ryan's grammar, and I refused to speak it. I kept her close the way you keep a promise in view. My hand found hers under the table when her mother's voice sharpened. I laughed at Uncle Frank's stories and asked Elaine Brooks about the restaurant's early years and learned, correctly, that no one at any table had ever suffered from being asked about the years they'd survived. Twice, Jenna looked at me with an expression I hadn't seen in two years of office Thursdays — unguarded, a little astonished — and twice I had to look away, because my condition, my one stupid condition, was becoming truer than was safe for either of us.

It was Diane, predictably, who made the last attempt of the dinner's first half. Over the main course she leaned toward me with the polished brightness of a woman opening an interview she'd written in the car. "Jenna tells us so little, Evan. Three weeks. And what are your intentions, exactly? A man of your — standing. With a secretary."

"A secretary," Jenna said, "Mom—"

"My intentions," I said, before she could spend herself on it, "are to be precisely as serious as your daughter permits me to be, at the speed she sets, for as long as she wants me. I don't acquire people, Diane. I ask them." I turned my glass once, slowly. "Jenna said yes to three weeks. I'm aware of what an honor that is. She doesn't say yes to much."

Something unplanned crossed Diane Hart's face then — the first unscripted thing I'd seen there all night: a woman hearing, from the mouth of a stranger, the fact about her daughter she'd built a whole seating chart to deny. That Jenna was not a problem to be solved. That she was a door other people felt lucky to be allowed through.

"Well," Diane said, after a moment, and reached for her wine with a hand that wasn't quite as steady as her voice. "Well. That's… a very correct answer."

"It had the advantage of being true," I said.

And Ryan watched. Ryan drank. Ryan did the mathematics of a man whose evening is draining out of him — whose audience keeps glancing away, whose opponent never raises his voice, whose ex-fiancée keeps laughing at the wrong man's jokes with her whole face.

I knew men like him the way a doctor knows a fever's chart. There would be one more escalation. It would be big, and public, and dressed up as generosity, because men like Ryan cannot leave a room they believe they've lost; they have to burn it down and call the fire a speech.

So I wasn't surprised — I was only sorry, for Jenna's sake, that I was right — when, as the plates were being cleared, Ryan Mercer pushed back his chair, stood up with his glass in his hand and a folder — a folder, at a dinner table, black and cheap and rehearsed-looking — in the other, and cleared his throat for the room.

"If I could just have everyone's attention," he said. "There's something I think this family deserves to hear. Something special. About the man sitting at this table pretending to be one of us."

More posts