Chapter 2: THE TRUTH NO FATHER WANTED TO HEAR

Written by

in

THE FATHER SHE CHOSE · Chapter 2 of 7
Reading settings

Vincent didn't move.

Evan's accusation remained between them like something physical.

"But you wanted her."

The words had come from his son, and Vincent knew that no business negotiation, family dispute, or threat from a rival could hurt him quite as deeply.

He looked at Evan.

"Yes."

Claire closed her eyes.

Evan's expression changed.

He had expected denial. Anger. Perhaps a furious demand that he leave the room.

He hadn't expected the answer to arrive so quietly.

"How long?"

Vincent took a breath.

"That isn't a simple question."

"It is for me."

"Evan…"

"Don't use that voice."

"What voice?"

"The one you use when you're about to explain why something terrible is actually reasonable."

Claire stepped forward.

"Evan, nothing happened between us."

He looked at her.

"Nothing?"

"Nothing physical. No secret relationship. No promises. No meetings behind your back."

"Did you tell him you loved him?"

"No."

"Did he tell you?"

She hesitated.

Vincent answered.

"No."

Evan laughed once, without humor.

"Wonderful. So we're all very respectable."

He placed the velvet ring box on the edge of the desk.

"I proposed to the woman I intended to marry. She rejected me because she wanted my father. And my father admits he wanted her too."

His voice cracked slightly.

"Tell me which part I'm supposed to understand."

Vincent came around the desk.

"You're not supposed to understand everything tonight."

"Why not?"

"Because you're hurt."

"I'm hurt because you're standing there pretending this is complicated."

"It is complicated."

"No. It's actually very simple. Did you want my girlfriend while I was dating her?"

Vincent held his gaze.

"Yes."

Claire looked at him sharply.

He continued.

"But I never acted on it."

"That doesn't make it disappear."

"I know."

"Did you ever intend to tell me?"

Vincent looked down briefly.

The pause was answer enough.

Evan stepped back.

"Unbelievable."

"Evan, listen to me."

"No. You listen."

His voice grew stronger.

"You were the one person I never had to compete with. Every man in this city wanted something from our family. Every executive wanted your approval. Every person who entered this house measured their words because they were afraid of you."

He looked toward Claire.

"But I never thought I would have to wonder whether you wanted the same woman I did."

Vincent's expression softened.

"You never had to compete with me."

"Apparently I did."

"I never pursued her."

"That isn't the same as not wanting her."

"No," Vincent admitted. "It isn't."

Evan stared at him.

"Did you ever think about telling me?"

"Every time I saw you together."

"Then why didn't you?"

"Because I was hoping the feeling would disappear before it became something that could hurt you."

Evan laughed bitterly.

"So you kept it to yourself and hoped."

"Yes."

"That's your entire plan?"

"It was the only honorable choice I could see at the time."

"Did you consider asking her to leave?"

"No."

"Did you consider telling her to stay away from you?"

Vincent's eyes moved toward Claire.

"I considered telling her that I couldn't be around her as often."

"Did you?"

"I limited our meetings to the foundation work. I stopped attending several events where she would be present."

Claire looked up.

"You did?"

Vincent nodded.

"I thought distance would make it easier."

She swallowed.

"I thought you were simply busy."

"I was trying to be careful."

"Careful for whom?"

"For everyone."

Evan shook his head.

"Do you hear yourself? You're describing a secret relationship with no relationship."

"There was no relationship."

"But there were feelings."

"Yes."

Evan moved toward the door.

"Where are you going?" Claire asked.

"Somewhere I can think."

"Please don't leave like this."

He stopped with his hand on the door.

"How would you like me to leave?"

She had no answer.

Evan looked at his father.

"Don't follow me."

Vincent nodded.

Evan opened the door.

Then he stopped again.

"One question."

Vincent waited.

"If I hadn't proposed tonight, would either of you have told me?"

Claire opened her mouth.

Vincent answered first.

"I would have told you before I ever considered acting on anything."

"That's not what I asked."

Vincent's silence returned.

Evan gave a small nod.

"That's what I thought."

He left.

The door closed.

Claire remained standing.

She had imagined many versions of this evening. In some, she had told Evan privately and he had been angry. In others, Vincent had rejected her confession and she had walked away alone.

She hadn't imagined the three of them standing in the same room with nowhere to hide.

"He's devastated," she whispered.

"I know."

"I never wanted to hurt him."

"I believe you."

She looked at Vincent.

"Do you hate me?"

"No."

"Do you wish I hadn't said it?"

Vincent's eyes held hers.

"I wish you hadn't been forced to say it in a room where my son could hear it."

"That's not the same thing."

"No."

She stepped closer.

"Then answer me."

He looked at her face, at the tears she was trying to hold back.

"I don't regret knowing how you feel."

Her breath caught.

"But I regret that the knowledge arrived this way."

Claire nodded.

It wasn't the answer she had secretly hoped for.

It was the answer she needed.

She picked up her small evening bag from the chair.

"I should leave."

"Claire."

She stopped.

"You shouldn't drive while you're this upset. I'll arrange a car."

"I can manage."

"I know you can. That doesn't mean you should have to."

For a moment, she almost smiled.

Then she looked toward the door.

"Vincent?"

"Yes?"

"Did you really try to stay away from me?"

"Yes."

"Was it difficult?"

He lowered his eyes.

"More than I expected."

The honesty hurt.

It also gave her something she had never allowed herself to hope for.

She left the study without touching him.

***

Evan stood in the empty corridor outside the ballroom.

He could hear the orchestra playing again, although the music sounded strangely distant.

Guests were pretending to enjoy themselves.

Some were discussing the proposal. Others were trying not to look toward the private corridor.

He removed his cuff links and placed them in his pocket.

He didn't know whether he wanted to shout or disappear.

A staff member approached carefully.

"Mr. Marlowe, would you like the car brought around?"

"Not yet."

"Of course."

The man withdrew.

Evan leaned against the wall.

He remembered the first time he had introduced Claire to his father.

Vincent had shaken her hand and asked about her restoration project.

Nothing unusual.

Nothing suspicious.

Yet, looking backward, Evan could remember small details.

The way Vincent listened when she spoke.

The way Claire sometimes became unusually quiet when his father entered a room.

The way they could disagree without either becoming defensive.

At the time, he had considered those things signs of compatibility between two intelligent people.

Now every memory seemed to have acquired another meaning.

He took out his phone.

Claire's last message from the previous afternoon was still there.

"I really need to talk to you before tonight."

He had answered, "Later. I promise."

He had never called.

Evan stared at the screen.

Then he opened his father's contact.

His thumb hovered over the call button.

He didn't press it.

He wasn't ready to hear Vincent's voice.

Claire had almost reached the ballroom doors when she saw Evan standing near the tall windows. He had not left. He was watching the guests move around the room as if he no longer recognized any of them.

"Evan."

He turned. For a moment, neither moved.

"I won't ask you to forgive me," she said. "I only wanted you to know I never thought of you as a mistake."

"That's not what I think," he replied. "I think you wanted a life with me until you realized you wanted something else more."

Claire absorbed that without defending herself.

"I loved you," she said. "The time we shared was real. But I kept hoping the feelings I couldn't explain would disappear, and that wasn't fair to you."

"Did you ever look at me and wish I were him?"

She shook her head. "No. I looked at you and wished I could give you the future you wanted. Those are different things."

Evan looked toward the ballroom.

"I don't know what to do with that."

"You don't have to do anything tonight."

He nodded, though it didn't look like agreement.

"Go home, Claire."

"Are you sure?"

"Yes. If we keep talking, I'll ask questions I don't want the answers to yet."

She stepped back.

"I'm sorry."

"I know."

He turned toward the ballroom, and she continued down the corridor. Neither looked back.

***

Inside the study, Vincent stood alone.

He walked to the window and looked down at the illuminated gardens.

He had built his empire through decisions that required certainty. He knew when to negotiate, when to refuse, and when to walk away.

But he had no idea how to repair what had happened.

A quiet knock came from the door.

He turned.

Claire was standing there again.

"I forgot my wrap."

He picked it up from the chair and offered it to her.

She took it.

Their fingers nearly touched.

Neither moved closer.

"I don't know what happens now," she said.

"Neither do I."

"Are you going to tell Evan the truth?"

"Yes."

"All of it?"

"All of it."

She nodded.

"Then tell him why you kept your distance."

"I will."

"Don't make yourself sound noble if you were afraid."

Vincent studied her.

"You're right."

"Tell him you were afraid of losing him."

His jaw tightened.

"That is the truth."

"And tell him that you never asked me to choose you."

"I never would."

She looked at him for a long moment.

"Would you want me to?"

Vincent's expression changed.

"Want you to what?"

"Choose you."

The question seemed to take the air from the room.

He looked toward the door, then back at her.

"Not tonight."

"That's not an answer."

"It's the only answer I can give while Evan is standing somewhere in this house trying to understand why his father and the woman he loves have hurt him."

Claire nodded.

She understood.

But understanding did not make the answer painless.

She left again.

Vincent remained beside the desk until the ballroom lights dimmed for the final time.

***

Near midnight, Evan returned to the private corridor.

His jacket was draped over one arm.

He had removed his bow tie, and the small velvet box was still in his pocket.

He stopped outside the study.

The door was open.

Vincent stood behind his desk, reading a document.

He looked up.

"I thought you had gone."

"I came back."

"All right."

Evan entered.

"I want the complete truth."

"You'll have it."

"Not the careful version."

Vincent closed the folder.

"Ask me anything."

Evan looked at him.

"Then start with the night you realized you were in love with her."

Vincent's expression changed.

For several seconds, he didn't speak.

Then he said, "It was the night she stood in front of a room full of people and refused to let them decide what her work was worth."

Evan frowned.

"What night?"

Vincent opened the drawer beside his desk.

Inside was a folder containing the original plans for the Marlowe Foundation's cultural center.

He placed it on the desk.

And when Evan saw the date written across the top, his expression changed completely.

Because it was a date he remembered.

It was also the night Evan had asked his father for advice about his future with Claire.

***

Claire sat at her kitchen table long after she returned home. Her evening bag rested beside her, and the wrap she had forgotten in Vincent's study was folded over the back of a chair. She had changed into a soft sweater, but she still felt as though she were wearing the weight of the ballroom.

Her phone lit up. Evan's name appeared on the screen.

"I know you may not want to talk tonight," his message read. "I just need you to know that I'm not going to tell people you betrayed me. You were honest when it mattered."

Claire read the message twice. She began typing, stopped, and deleted the first answer. An apology seemed too small, and asking him to understand would be unfair.

At last she wrote, "Thank you for saying that. I should have found the courage to speak to you before tonight. You deserved that much."

His reply came a few minutes later.

"I believe you. I need time, but I don't want either of us pretending the last eighteen months meant nothing."

Claire felt her eyes fill.

"Neither do I," she wrote.

She put the phone down and walked to the window. The city lights blurred beyond the glass. She wondered whether Vincent was still awake, whether he was thinking about her, and whether he would ever allow himself to love her without believing that doing so made him a bad father.

She had no answer.

But she made herself a promise. She would not pursue Vincent while Evan was still trying to understand what had happened. She would not demand that Vincent choose between his son and his own happiness. And she would not return to a relationship with Evan simply because it was familiar.

She had already learned what happened when people chose comfort over truth.

Her phone remained silent. For once, she let it.

More posts