Chapter 4: The Man Nobody Marries

Written by

in

Reading settings

Pinehaven was not a town. Pinehaven was a house, a port, a forest, and a small army of people who all worked for one man, and the first thing I learned about Nathaniel Mercer was that he owned all of it, and the second thing I learned was that he had built all of it himself, from nothing, in fifteen years.

The plane landed on a private airstrip carved out of the trees, and a black car took us up a long gravel road through pine forest so thick that the sunlight came down in green shafts, and then the trees opened, and there was the house. It was not a mansion. It was a long, low house of dark wood and glass, built into the side of a hill, looking out over the water, and it had the kind of quiet dignity that money cannot buy and only patience can build. A woman was waiting on the steps. She was in her sixties, with gray hair pulled back in a braid, and she wore a plain blue dress and an apron, and she looked at me with open curiosity.

"This is Agnes," Nathaniel said. "She runs the house. Agnes, this is Miss Calloway. She'll be staying with us."

"For how long?" Agnes asked, wiping her hands on her apron.

"For a year," Nathaniel said. "Possibly longer."

Agnes looked at me for a long moment, and then she smiled, and the smile transformed her whole face. "Well. It's about time he brought someone home. Come inside, dear. You look frozen."

The inside of the house was warm and smelled of cedar and fresh bread, and there were books everywhere — on shelves, on tables, stacked on the floor beside the fireplace. I had expected a mafia boss's house to look like a fortress, all leather and dark wood and locked doors. Instead, it looked like the home of a man who liked to read. There was a piano in the corner of the living room, covered in dust, and a photograph on the mantel of a young man with Nathaniel's eyes, standing beside a fishing boat.

"My brother," Nathaniel said, following my gaze. "Thomas. He died twelve years ago. He was twenty-four."

"I'm sorry," I said.

"He was the one who taught me to dance," Nathaniel said, and there was a strange softness in his voice. "He was the one who told me that a man who can't dance can't be trusted, because dancing is the only time a man has to lead without force. I never forgot that."

I thought about the waltz at the gala, about the way his hand had been steady on my waist, about the way he had guided me without ever pushing me, and I understood, suddenly, that the dance had not been a performance. It had been a promise. A man who had learned to dance from his dead brother was not a man who used women as messages. He was a man who had once been a boy who loved his brother, and who had lost him, and who had built an empire out of grief.

On my third afternoon in the house, I found Agnes in the kitchen, kneading bread dough with strong, practiced hands, flour dusting her forearms like snow. "Sit," she said, without looking up. "You're too thin. Eat something." She cut me a thick slice of bread, still warm, and spread it with butter and honey, and she watched me eat it with the satisfaction of a woman who believes that most problems can be solved with food.

"Tell me about him," I said. "About Nathaniel. When he was young."

Agnes was quiet for a moment, her hands still in the dough. "He was a sweet boy," she said finally. "Quieter than his brother. Thomas was the loud one — always laughing, always getting into trouble, always dragging Nathaniel along behind him. Nathaniel was the one who read books. He used to sit in that library for hours, reading about history, about ships, about the law. He wanted to be a lawyer, did you know that? Before his father died, before everything fell apart. He wanted to go to university and study law and argue in courtrooms. Then his father died, and the business needed someone, and Thomas — Thomas was never going to run a business. Thomas was a dreamer. So Nathaniel took it on. He was twenty-one years old, and he took on a trucking company, and a port, and a forest, and he built it into what it is now, because someone had to."

"What happened to Thomas?" I asked.

Agnes's hands stilled. "A boating accident. Twelve years ago. He was twenty-four. Nathaniel was supposed to be on that boat with him, but he stayed behind to finish some paperwork, and Thomas went out alone, and the weather turned, and he never came back." She wiped her hands on her apron. "Nathaniel never forgave himself. He still hasn't. That's why he works so hard. That's why he never rests. He thinks if he stops, he'll have to feel it."

"And Catherine?" I asked. "The fiancée?"

Agnes sighed. "She was a lovely girl. But she wanted a husband who would take her to parties and buy her things, and Nathaniel was grieving, and he was building an empire, and he didn't have time for parties. She left him at the altar, in front of four hundred people. He stood there for ten minutes, waiting, before someone finally told him she wasn't coming. He never spoke about it. Not once. But after that day, he stopped letting anyone close. You're the first person he's brought to this house in twelve years, Nora. The first. I want you to understand what that means."

I sat there in the warm kitchen, with the smell of fresh bread around me, and I thought about a twenty-one-year-old boy who had wanted to be a lawyer, and who had lost his brother, and his father, and his fiancée, and who had built an empire out of grief, and I thought about how little I had understood about Nathaniel Mercer. He was not a monster. He was a man who had been broken, and who had rebuilt himself, piece by piece, into something hard and cold, because hard and cold was the only way he knew how to survive.

"Thank you for telling me," I said.

Agnes patted my hand. "He's a good man, Nora. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise. And don't break his heart. He's only got the one, and it's been broken enough already."

That night, after dinner, he showed me the contract. It was a simple document, written in plain language, and it said exactly what he had told me at the gala: one year, a ceremony for appearances, two hundred thousand dollars, freedom at the end. There was also a clause I had not expected. It said that I could leave at any time, for any reason, with fifty thousand dollars and a plane ticket to anywhere in the world, and that Nathaniel Mercer would not stop me, would not follow me, and would not hold it against me.

"Why would you put that in there?" I asked.

"Because a contract is only fair if both sides can walk away," he said. "I learned that from my brother, too. He used to say that a deal you can't leave is not a deal. It's a cage."

I signed the contract. My hand shook as I wrote my name, and Nathaniel watched me without speaking, and when I was finished, he took the pen from me, and he signed his own name below mine, and he folded the document and put it in a drawer, and he said, "Thank you, Miss Calloway. I won't forget this."

"Call me Nora," I said. "If we're going to be married, even a pretend one, you should probably call me Nora."

"Nora," he said, trying the name out, and it sounded different in his voice — slower, more careful, like he was handling something fragile. "Then you should call me Nathaniel. Not Mr. Mercer. Not sir. Nathaniel."

"Nathaniel," I said, and it felt strange and new in my mouth, like a word in a language I was just beginning to learn.

The days that followed were the strangest of my life. I had a bedroom of my own, with a window that looked out over the water, and a bathroom with hot water that never ran out, and a closet full of clothes that Agnes had bought for me without asking, in my size, in colors I liked. I had breakfast every morning with a man who read the newspaper in silence and who always, without fail, poured my coffee before his own. I had afternoons to myself, and evenings in the library, and a whole house full of books, and for the first time since my mother died, I felt safe.

But I also felt watched. Not by Nathaniel — he was careful to give me space, and he never entered my room, and he never touched me, not once. He was watched by his own people. Elias Ward, his lieutenant, a broad man in his forties with a shaved head and a scar on his chin, followed me with his eyes whenever I was in the house, and I could tell he did not approve of me. He thought I was a gold digger. He thought I was a Blackridge spy. He thought I was a liability, and he was not entirely wrong. I was all of those things, in a way. I was a woman who had signed a contract to marry a man she barely knew, for money, and I had brought a folder full of evidence into his house, and I did not know whose side I was on.

On the fifth day, Elias cornered me in the hallway. "What are you really doing here?" he asked, his voice low and hard.

"I'm marrying your boss," I said, and I was proud of how steady my voice sounded.

"You're using him," Elias said. "I've seen women like you before. You think you can walk in here with your pretty face and your sad story and take what he's built."

"I have a sad story," I said. "But I'm not using him. He came to me. He offered me a contract. I signed it. If you have a problem with that, take it up with him."

Elias stared at me for a long moment, and then, to my surprise, he laughed. It was a short, rough laugh, but it was genuine. "You've got spine," he said. "I'll give you that. Most people in this house are afraid of him. You're not."

"I'm terrified of him," I said honestly. "I'm just more terrified of going back to Blackridge."

Elias nodded slowly, and something in his face changed. "Fair enough," he said. "But if you hurt him, Miss Calloway — if you betray him the way the last woman did — I will know. And I will not be as polite as he is."

"The last woman?" I asked.

Elias hesitated, and then he said, "His fiancée. Twelve years ago. Her name was Catherine, and she was supposed to marry him, and then his brother died, and she decided that a grieving man with a scar was not the husband she wanted. She left him at the altar, in front of four hundred people. He has not trusted a woman since."

I stood in the hallway long after Elias had walked away, thinking about that. Nathaniel Mercer, the most feared man in the Pacific Northwest, had been left at the altar. He had been humiliated in front of four hundred people, the same way I had been humiliated in front of three hundred. And he had carried that humiliation for twelve years, and it had made him cold, and careful, and impossible, and every powerful family that had tried to marry a daughter into his empire had failed, because he had already learned what it felt like to be discarded.

That night, at dinner, I looked at him differently. I saw the scar across his temple — a pale line, old, from a fight he never talked about. I saw the way he held his fork, precise and controlled. I saw the way he never touched anyone, not even to shake hands, unless he had to. And I understood, suddenly, that Nathaniel Mercer was not a man who was afraid of being touched. He was a man who was afraid of being left.

"Nathaniel," I said, when dinner was over, "can I ask you something?"

"Yes," he said.

"Why did you really come to my table that night? At the gala. You could have sent a message to Grant any other way. Why me?"

He was quiet for a long time. He looked at his hands, and then he looked at me, and his gray eyes were tired in a way I had not seen before.

"Because I saw your face," he said, "when Daniel walked past you. And I knew that face. I wore that face twelve years ago, standing at an altar, watching a woman I loved walk away. And I thought — if someone had crossed that room for me that day, if someone had draped a coat over my shoulders and told me to stand up, maybe I wouldn't have spent twelve years building walls around myself. So I crossed the room for you. That is the whole truth."

I did not know what to say to that. So I did something I had never done before. I reached across the table, and I took his hand, and I held it, and I did not let go. His hand was warm, and rough, and it trembled, just slightly, under mine. He stared at our joined hands like he had never seen anything like it.

"Nora," he said, very quietly.

"I know," I said. "I know."

We sat like that for a long time, in the warm kitchen, with the books and the piano and the photograph of his brother on the mantel, and for the first time since the gala, I did not feel like a woman who had been discarded. I felt like a woman who had been chosen — not by a family, not by a ritual, not by a bracelet, but by a man who knew what it felt like to be left, and who had decided, anyway, to reach across a table and take my hand.

It was the first time anyone had ever held my hand like that. It was the first time I had ever let anyone.

More posts