Chapter 2: TWO DAUGHTERS, ONE IMPOSSIBLE TRUTH

Written by

in

Reading settings

Earlier that morning, several miles from Michigan Avenue, Mara Elise Carter had been trying to make breakfast feel like a celebration.

Their apartment was small, with a narrow kitchen and a window that looked onto the brick wall of the neighboring building. The radiator clicked even though the room was warm. A grocery bag sat beside the sink, holding the last of their bread and two apples.

Ruby sat at the table in her faded dark-red floral dress. Her chestnut-brown hair had been gathered into a loose bun, and the burgundy ribbon kept slipping sideways.

"Mommy, Mr. Buttons wants pancakes."

Mara looked at the beige stuffed rabbit. One ear had been repaired with thread, and a faint stain marked its belly.

"Mr. Buttons can have a pretend pancake," she said, setting a small real one in front of Ruby. "You need the real one."

Ruby pushed a tiny piece toward the rabbit anyway. "He can smell it."

Mara smiled, but her thoughts were elsewhere. A letter had arrived the previous evening from the landlord. The rent was overdue, and she had spent most of the night calculating what she could sell without depriving Ruby of something she loved.

Ruby noticed her expression. "Are you sad?"

"No, sweetheart."

"Your eyes look sad."

Mara sat beside her. "Sometimes grown-ups worry about things. It doesn't mean you did anything wrong."

Ruby leaned against her. The silver blackbird necklace rested against the child's chest, its tiny wings catching the weak morning light.

"Can I wear my bird today?"

"You always wear your bird."

"Because it protects me?"

Mara brushed a loose curl from her daughter's forehead. "Because it reminds us that we're never as alone as we think."

Ruby touched the pendant gently. "Who gave it to me?"

"Someone who wanted you to be safe."

"Can we find her?"

Mara's throat tightened. "Maybe one day."

After breakfast, Mara checked the little purse in her coat. She had enough money for bread, milk, and a bus ride. She planned to walk part of the way and look for a place that might need a cleaner for a few hours.

Ruby insisted on bringing Mr. Buttons.

"He gets scared if I leave him."

"Then he can come."

Mara buttoned Ruby's thin blue coat. She wished she could replace it, but the wind had turned colder and the child needed something between her and the weather.

Before they left, Mara looked at the old photograph tucked into the mirror frame. It showed her and Adrian on their wedding day. She had not taken it down, even though looking at it sometimes hurt more than she could bear.

"Come on, sweetheart," she whispered.

Ruby took her hand.

They had no idea that the walk toward Michigan Avenue would lead them back to the man Mara had spent five years believing was dead.

Adrian didn't remember the walk to his car.

He remembered Mara's frightened expression. He remembered the blackbird pendant. He remembered two little girls standing together as though someone had taken one child and placed her reflection in another body.

Most of all, he remembered the question he had been unable to ask.

Was Ruby his daughter?

"Mara," he said carefully, "we need to talk."

"No."

"Five years."

"I know how long it's been."

"I thought you were dead."

"And I thought you were dead too!"

Her voice cracked.

Ruby pressed her face against Mara's coat.

"Mommy?"

Mara immediately lowered herself.

"I'm here, sweetheart."

"Are we going home?"

"Yes."

Adrian looked at Ruby's worn shoes.

"Where are you living?"

Mara's expression became guarded.

"That's none of your business."

"It became my business when I saw my daughter."

Mara went still.

Adrian looked at Ruby.

"Is she my daughter?"

Mara didn't answer.

Sophie stepped forward.

"Can Ruby come with us?"

Adrian looked at his little girl.

"Sweetheart, we need to let Mommy and Ruby talk first."

"But she's exactly like me."

Ruby studied Sophie.

"You're wearing a pretty dress."

Sophie smiled.

"Thank you. Your rabbit is pretty too."

Ruby looked down at Mr. Buttons.

"He's dirty."

"I don't mind."

"He's my best friend."

Sophie considered that.

"I have one too."

The two girls exchanged shy smiles.

Mara watched them, tears gathering in her eyes.

For five years, she had imagined this moment in a thousand different ways.

In none of them had she been prepared for the sight of Adrian standing beside Sophie.

He looked older.

Harder.

But his eyes were still the same.

"Did you know?" he asked.

Mara shook her head.

"Know what?"

"That we had twins."

She closed her eyes.

"I was told one baby survived."

Adrian's face tightened.

"Which one?"

"Sophie."

He looked toward his daughter.

Mara continued.

"Then I was told Sophie died."

Adrian stared at her.

"What?"

"And that you died in a car accident."

The world seemed to tilt.

"Who told you that?"

"Your uncle."

"Stefano?"

She nodded.

Adrian looked toward Luca.

"Get the car."

Mara immediately stepped back.

"I'm not going anywhere with you."

"Then tell me where you want to go."

"Somewhere you can't find us."

"Why?"

"Because the last time I trusted your family, I lost five years of my life."

Adrian lowered his voice.

"Your father was my family's accountant. Thomas Carter was murdered before you disappeared. I never received an explanation."

Mara's eyes widened.

"You know about my father?"

"I know he died."

"Then you know nothing."

She looked toward Ruby.

"Your uncle told me my father had stolen money. He said Thomas was responsible for everything that happened."

Adrian's jaw tightened.

"My father-in-law was an honest man."

"Then why was he dead?"

Adrian had no answer.

***

After nearly twenty minutes, Mara agreed to accompany Adrian to a private medical clinic.

She insisted that Ruby remain with her.

Adrian agreed without argument.

Sophie sat beside Ruby in the back of the car.

"Do you like strawberries?" Sophie asked.

Ruby nodded.

"Sometimes."

"I like them with chocolate."

Ruby looked impressed.

"Chocolate is my favorite."

Sophie smiled.

"Then we're friends."

Adrian watched them through the rearview mirror.

His heart hurt.

Two little girls.

Two daughters.

He had spent five years celebrating Sophie's birthdays without knowing another child was waiting somewhere in Chicago.

At the clinic, Dr. Hannah Lewis arranged private DNA testing.

Adrian and Mara provided samples. The girls were tested separately.

"Mr. Moretti," the doctor explained, "we can establish parentage and determine whether the children are biological twins."

"How long?"

"We can provide an expedited result this afternoon."

Mara sat beside Ruby.

The child was drawing on a sheet of paper.

She had drawn two little girls holding hands.

One wore a crown.

The other held a rabbit.

Sophie leaned over.

"That's us!"

Ruby nodded.

"I think so."

Adrian turned away.

He couldn't bear it.

The waiting room seemed too bright. A television played silently above the reception desk, and a wall clock made each second sound louder than it should have.

Mara sat with Ruby pressed against her side. Adrian remained standing near the window, his hands clasped behind his back.

Dr. Lewis came out once to explain that the laboratory was checking the parentage markers and comparing the girls' profiles. She assured them that the expedited process was reliable, but she could not promise an exact minute.

"How can two children be separated like that?" Mara asked when the doctor had gone.

Adrian turned. "I don't know."

"You keep saying that."

"Because it's the truth."

Mara looked at him. "I spent five years wondering whether I had imagined the second heartbeat. I remembered the doctor saying there were two babies, but when I woke up, everyone told me I was confused."

Adrian pulled a chair closer. "You weren't confused."

"I know that now. But for years I had nothing except a necklace, a rabbit, and a nurse who told me to run."

Ruby looked up. "I have Mr. Buttons too."

Mara kissed her hair. "Yes, you do."

Sophie approached with her drawing. "Ruby, do you want to color with me?"

Ruby glanced at Mara for permission.

"Go ahead, sweetheart."

The girls sat together at a small table. Sophie offered Ruby a pink crayon, then remembered that Ruby liked blue and exchanged it without being asked.

Adrian watched them. "They've been apart their whole lives."

Mara's voice softened. "And somehow they found each other."

"Do you think they understand what this means?"

"Not yet. They understand that they like each other. That's enough for today."

Adrian sat opposite her. "I don't expect you to forgive me because a test says they're mine."

Mara looked down at her hands. "I don't know what I expect."

"Then we don't have to decide anything today."

She studied his face, searching for the man she remembered beneath the years of grief and anger. "You really didn't know about Ruby?"

"No. If I had known, I would have searched every hospital, every town, every street."

"Would you?"

"Yes."

Mara's eyes filled, but she looked away before the tears fell.

When the receptionist finally called Adrian's name, he stood so quickly that his chair scraped the floor. Mara took Ruby's hand. Sophie reached for the other one.

For a moment, the four of them walked toward the doctor's office together.

***

While they waited, Mrs. Whitmore arrived at the clinic.

She had insisted on coming when Adrian called.

The moment she saw Mara, she dropped the handbag she was carrying.

"Oh, my goodness."

Mara looked up.

"Mrs. Whitmore?"

The older woman covered her mouth.

"Miss Mara."

For a moment, neither moved.

Then Mrs. Whitmore hurried forward and embraced her.

"I thought we had lost you."

Mara began crying.

"I thought so too."

Mrs. Whitmore looked toward Ruby.

"And this must be…"

"Ruby."

The housekeeper's eyes filled.

"Another little angel."

Adrian watched them.

"Mrs. Whitmore, did you know?"

She looked uncomfortable.

"Know what, sir?"

"That Mara might have survived."

"No."

"Did my mother ever mention a second child?"

Mrs. Whitmore hesitated.

"Your mother once told me that she had failed to protect someone."

Adrian frowned.

"Who?"

"She wouldn't say."

Before he could ask more, Dr. Lewis entered.

She held a folder.

"Mr. Moretti. Mrs. Carter."

Adrian stood.

"Tell us."

The doctor opened the report.

"The results confirm that both children are biological daughters of Mr. Moretti and Mrs. Carter. They are monozygotic twins."

Mara began to cry.

Adrian closed his eyes.

The doctor continued.

"The genetic profiles are consistent with identical twin sisters."

Sophie looked up.

"Does that mean Ruby is really my sister?"

Adrian knelt.

"Yes, sweetheart."

Sophie smiled.

"Then I have a sister!"

Ruby looked at Mara.

"Mommy, does that mean I have a daddy?"

Mara couldn't speak.

Adrian moved slowly toward her.

"If you'll let me."

Mara looked at him.

Five years of pain stood between them.

But so did two little girls.

She finally nodded.

***

That evening, Adrian brought everyone to the Moretti estate.

Mara didn't trust the house.

She had once lived there as Adrian's wife. Now every hallway reminded her of the life she had lost.

Sophie took Ruby upstairs to show her the playroom.

"These are my dolls," Sophie explained.

Ruby placed Mr. Buttons carefully on the sofa.

"He's not allowed on the floor because he gets dirty."

Sophie giggled.

"That's funny. My daddy says the same thing about my shoes."

Mrs. Whitmore announced that supper would be served in the smaller dining room rather than the formal one. She had arranged chicken soup, warm rolls, sliced fruit, and a little chocolate cake because Sophie had told her that Ruby liked chocolate.

Ruby sat carefully in her chair, keeping Mr. Buttons on her lap.

"Does he need a plate?" Sophie asked.

Mrs. Whitmore produced a tiny saucer. "Every guest deserves a place at the table."

Ruby's face brightened. "Thank you."

Adrian watched the girls compare their favorite foods. Sophie liked strawberries cut into little hearts. Ruby liked apples without the skin. Sophie drank milk from a glass with a blue flower painted on it; Ruby asked for the same one.

"You're copying me," Sophie said, pretending to be offended.

Ruby smiled shyly. "I just like your cup."

"You can have it."

Adrian exchanged a look with Mrs. Whitmore. The housekeeper's eyes were wet, but she kept busy arranging the napkins.

After supper, Sophie insisted on showing Ruby the family photograph wall. She pointed out Adrian as a little boy, Lucia in a garden, and Mara in her wedding dress.

"That's Mommy," Sophie said. "Daddy says she liked wild flowers."

Ruby stared at the photograph for a long time. "She looks like my mommy."

"She is your mommy," Sophie replied simply.

Ruby looked at Mara, who stood in the doorway. "I have two pictures of you. One is in my bag, but this one is bigger."

Mara crossed the room and knelt beside her. "You can look at it whenever you want."

Sophie took Ruby's hand. "Tomorrow I'll show you the playroom again. We can make a house for Mr. Buttons."

"With a bed?"

"And a kitchen."

"And a garden?"

Sophie nodded. "A very big one."

Later, when the girls were ready for bed, Adrian stood outside the guest room while Mara tucked them in. Ruby insisted on placing Mr. Buttons between the pillows. Sophie moved her own stuffed bear closer so the rabbit would have company.

"Good night, Ruby," Sophie whispered.

"Good night, Sophie."

Mara kissed each girl's forehead. Ruby touched the blackbird pendant through her nightdress before closing her eyes.

Adrian waited until Mara stepped into the hallway.

"They're already making plans," he said.

"Children know how to begin again faster than adults."

He looked through the open doorway at the two small figures. "I don't want them to pay for what we couldn't protect."

"Then we protect them now," Mara answered.

For a few quiet minutes, the estate felt less like a fortress and more like a home.

Downstairs, Adrian faced Mara.

"Tell me everything."

She sat opposite him.

"Five years ago, I woke up in a private hospital. I was weak. My father had been killed, and I couldn't remember everything that happened during the delivery."

Adrian listened without interrupting.

"A doctor told me that you had died in a burning car. Another told me Sophie hadn't survived."

"Who?"

"Dr. Elias Bell."

Adrian's expression changed.

He knew the name.

Bell had been the family's private physician.

Mara continued.

"Then a nurse named Margaret told me something different. She said there had been two babies. She said your mother had arranged for one of them to be transferred."

"Ruby."

Mara nodded.

"I didn't understand why. But Margaret told me that if I wanted to keep my daughter alive, I had to leave before Stefano found out."

Adrian leaned forward.

"Where was my mother?"

"She came to see me once. She looked terrified."

"What did she say?"

"She told me that the blackbird would protect Ruby."

Adrian looked toward the stairs.

"And the necklace?"

"Margaret placed it around Ruby's neck before we left."

Adrian stood.

His mother's envelope suddenly felt heavy inside his jacket.

He opened it.

Inside was a photograph of Lucia holding a tiny silver bird.

Beneath it was a handwritten message.

*My son, if you ever see the blackbird again, trust no one who tells you the family secret is finished.*

Adrian turned the photograph over.

There were three words written on the back.

ASK ABOUT 417.

Before he could show Mara, his phone vibrated.

An unknown number.

He answered.

A man's distorted voice spoke.

"Congratulations, Adrian. You've found one of the children."

Adrian's expression hardened.

"Who is this?"

The voice laughed softly.

"Ask your uncle what happened to Thomas Carter."

The call ended.

More posts