Chapter 4: The Truth Behind the Lie

Written by

in

Reading settings

Alexander arrived twelve minutes later and stopped outside Claire’s apartment instead of walking in. That small act almost hurt more than if he had stormed through the door. The man she married had owned every room the moment he entered it. This Alexander waited in the hallway until she opened the door. “Ethan’s asleep,” Claire whispered. “I won’t wake him.” He stepped inside only after she moved aside. His security chief took the photograph to examine it while Alexander remained near the entryway. He looked around at the modest apartment, the folded blanket on the couch, Ethan’s backpack near the chair, Claire’s shoes beside the door. “You can sit,” Claire said. “I’m fine.” “Alexander, if you stand there like a guard dog all night, you’ll make me nervous.” He sat immediately. Claire almost smiled. Almost. She handed him a mug of coffee because making coffee for someone was easier than talking about the wreckage of seven years. Alexander accepted it without the old expectation that she would automatically know how he wanted it. “Thank you.” “Don’t make this strange.” “I’m trying not to make anything worse.” “That’s new.” He took the blow without reacting. Claire sat across from him. “Tell me what you know.” “The sedan belonged to people connected to a rival crew. We don’t know whether the photograph came from them or someone trying to frighten us.” “Sophia?” “Possible. But I won’t accuse her without proof.” Claire stared at him. “You used to accuse first and investigate afterward.” “With enemies.” “And your wife?” He looked down at the coffee. “Apparently I treated you worse than enemies. At least I listened when they warned me.” Claire looked away. “Don’t do that.” “Do what?” “Say the right thing because you think I need to hear it.” “I’m saying it because it’s true.” “Truth would’ve been useful four years ago.” “I know.” His refusal to defend himself irritated her because it left nowhere for the anger to go. “Did you sleep with her?” The question had lived between them from the moment Sophia answered the phone. Alexander met her eyes. “No.” “Ever?” “No.” “Did you want to?” “No.” “Then why were you always there?” Alexander leaned back slowly. “Because Sophia asked nothing from me.” Claire laughed once, bitterly. “There it is.” “Listen to the rest.” “That sentence tells me everything.” “Claire.” His voice remained quiet. “Sophia asked nothing from me because she didn’t share a life with me. She didn’t need me to show up for Ethan’s school meetings. She didn’t need me beside her mother’s hospital bed. She didn’t ask when I would be home. She didn’t care whether I was becoming a stranger to my son. Being around her was easy because there were no real responsibilities.” Claire stared at him. “And that made it better?” “No. It made me a coward.” Silence filled the room. Alexander continued. “I told myself I was working. I told myself everything I did was for you and Ethan. Money. Security. Influence. But eventually I used business as an excuse not to face the places where I was failing.” Claire’s eyes stung. “I begged you to come to family therapy two years ago.” “I remember.” “You sent flowers.” “I remember that too.” “You sent twelve thousand dollars’ worth of flowers and skipped the appointment.” “I know.” She stood and walked toward the window. “My mother laughed for ten minutes when they arrived. Then she told me to return them.” Alexander almost smiled. “Did you?” “No. I donated them to three nursing homes because I wanted somebody to get something useful out of my marriage.” That actually made him smile, but it vanished when Claire turned. “She saw this before I did.” “Helen never liked me.” “She liked you when you showed up.” Alexander looked toward the hallway where Ethan slept. “Then she had fewer reasons over time.” Claire sat again. “Why did Sophia delete the calls?” “She says she was protecting my sleep.” “You believe that?” “No.” “What do you believe?” “She wanted you to leave.” Claire’s face hardened. “And you made that easy.” “Yes.” His answer came without hesitation. The security chief returned. “Boss.” Alexander stood. “We traced the photograph.” Claire rose too. “Tell me.” The chief glanced at Alexander. “Tell her,” Alexander said. “It concerns her son.” The man nodded. “The cemetery image originated with a freelance photographer who received the location from the same columnist Sophia contacted. The threatening message was added later by somebody connected to the rival crew following the information trail.” Claire felt sick. “So Sophia didn’t write it?” “No evidence she did.” “But she leaked where we were.” “Yes.” Alexander’s expression turned lethal. Claire saw the Mafia boss the rest of Chicago feared emerge behind his eyes. Then he looked at her and deliberately lowered his voice. “I’ll handle the security threat.” “What does that mean?” “It means nobody gets near you or Ethan.” “Alexander.” “It does not mean I’m going to start a war outside your apartment.” “Good.” His chief almost looked amused. Alexander ignored him. The following week became a blur of lawyers, security briefings, and grief. Claire returned to Helen’s townhouse once investigators cleared it. She chose to stay there. Alexander had new cameras installed only after sending Claire three options and asking which company she preferred. He did not enter the house without permission. He picked Ethan up twice for supervised afternoons because Ethan still refused overnight visits. Both times Alexander returned him exactly when promised. The third time, Ethan brought home a model car they had built together. “Dad let me use glue,” Ethan announced. Claire looked at Alexander. “You let him use industrial adhesive?” “Craft glue.” “I’m shocked by your growth.” Ethan giggled. Alexander’s mouth twitched. The moment lasted less than five seconds, but Claire felt it afterward. That frightened her. She did not want warmth yet. Warmth was how people started forgetting why they had left. Two days later, Alexander asked Claire to meet him in the study at the mansion. She almost refused, then he said, “There’s something you need to hear.” Claire arrived with Rachel. Sophia’s attorney was already present. Sophia sat rigidly near the fireplace. Alexander stood behind his desk. He had arranged for a forensic technician to play recovered audio snippets from his phone. Sophia’s voice appeared first. “Stop calling him.” Then Claire’s voice: “My mother is dying.” Then Sophia: “He needs rest.” Another recovered snippet followed, recorded accidentally when the phone activated voice control. Sophia muttered, “She always finds a reason to pull him back.” Claire’s stomach turned. The technician played another fragment. A message notification sounded. Sophia whispered, “Not tonight.” Then a series of taps. Deleted. Deleted. Deleted. Alexander did not look at Sophia. He watched Claire. “There’s more,” he said. Sophia stood. “This is humiliating.” Alexander’s eyes shifted to her. “Sit down.” “I’m not one of your employees.” “Then leave. But your attorney will receive the full report.” Sophia’s attorney touched her elbow. She sat. Alexander continued. “We recovered the original message you sent to the columnist. You provided Claire’s temporary address and funeral information.” “I was angry.” “You endangered a child.” “I didn’t know criminals were watching your family.” “You knew who I was when you decided to interfere with my family.” Sophia’s composure cracked. She turned toward Claire. “You think he’s suddenly a good husband because he’s sorry?” Claire answered before Alexander could. “No.” Sophia blinked. Claire stepped closer. “That’s the difference between us. I’m not blaming you for everything Alexander did. He chose not to come home. He chose to ignore how much I needed him for years. He chose your house that night. You deleted my calls, and I will never forgive you for that. But you didn’t ruin my marriage alone. Alexander helped.” Alexander lowered his eyes. Sophia looked almost disappointed that Claire would not compete for him. “Then why are you here?” she demanded. “Because I wanted to hear the truth.” Claire looked at Alexander. “And now I have.” She turned to leave. “Claire.” Alexander’s voice stopped her. He slid an envelope across the desk. “What is that?” “The deed to Helen’s townhouse, cleared of the lien she took out years ago for medical bills. It’s in your name.” Claire stared at him. “You paid her debt?” “Yes.” “Why?” “Because I found the notice among the documents after the funeral.” “You don’t get to buy forgiveness.” “I know.” “Then take it back.” “No.” Her eyes flashed. “Alexander.” “It isn’t for forgiveness. It’s something I should’ve done when she was alive. I knew she was struggling and assumed you would tell me if she needed help. You never did because you knew I would make it feel like charity.” Claire said nothing. He was right. “So consider it repayment,” he said. “For all the years Helen fed me when I was young enough to think your family’s kitchen was the only peaceful place in Chicago.” Claire’s anger faltered. Alexander had known Helen before he became powerful. Before the suits, guards, and whispered reputation. She remembered him at twenty-six, sitting at her mother’s table eating pasta directly from the pot while Helen complained about his manners. Claire picked up the envelope. “This changes nothing.” “I know.” That evening, Ethan asked Alexander to stay for dinner at Helen’s townhouse. Claire expected him to look at her for permission. He did. She gave a small nod. They ate pancakes because Ethan insisted his grandmother would approve. Alexander burned the first three. Ethan laughed until milk came out of his nose. Claire found herself laughing too. Then guilt struck so suddenly she had to look away. Later, Alexander stood on the porch preparing to leave. Ethan followed him outside. “Dad?” “Yeah?” “Are you going to disappear again?” Alexander crouched. “No.” “You said work was important.” “You’re more important.” Ethan studied his face. “Grandma was important too.” Alexander swallowed. “Yes.” “But you didn’t come.” “I know.” Ethan’s voice became small. “So how do I know?” Alexander looked at his son for a long moment. “You don’t.” Claire watched from inside. “I have to show you.” Ethan nodded slowly. “Okay.” He hugged his father. Alexander closed his eyes. Over Ethan’s shoulder, he saw Claire standing behind the screen door. For the first time, she did not look away.

More posts