Chapter 3: THE SIGNATURE THAT SHOULD NEVER HAVE BEEN THERE

Written by

in

Reading settings

Dominic Bellini had worked for the Costello organization for twelve years.

He was forty-five, with closely cropped dark hair, a broad build, and a habit of speaking only when necessary.

He had managed the security department through two major reorganizations.

He had protected Victor's father.

He had stood beside Victor during difficult negotiations.

And now his name appeared on the authorization that had allowed Trevor Davis to enter Penelope Hayes's apartment.

At 9:15 a.m., Victor called his security office.

"Where is Dominic?"

His assistant answered.

"He hasn't arrived."

"Did he report an absence?"

"No."

Victor looked toward Carmine.

"Check his residence."

Carmine nodded.

Victor ended the call.

"He's either avoiding us or he knows something."

Carmine folded his arms.

"Could he have approved it without understanding what it was?"

"Possibly."

"Do you believe that?"

Victor looked at the tablet.

"No."

***

Penelope spent the morning reviewing her digital records.

She had saved the original invoices in an encrypted folder.

She also had several emails from Davis Strategic.

One contained a reference to a private security contract.

Another listed the dates on which Trevor had requested building access.

She printed the documents.

Victor entered her temporary workspace.

"How are you doing?"

"Better."

"Did you find anything?"

She turned the laptop toward him.

"This email was sent five months ago."

Victor read it.

The message showed that Davis Strategic had requested access to several Costello properties.

One attachment contained a list of employee names and home addresses.

Penelope's name appeared halfway down the page.

Victor's expression changed.

"Where did you get this?"

"It was attached to the vendor correspondence."

"Who sent it?"

"Trevor's company."

Victor looked at the sender.

"Who received it?"

"An assistant in Salvatore's finance office."

Victor closed the laptop.

"Save a copy."

"Already done."

He looked at her.

"You're very thorough."

"I've learned that people sometimes pretend not to remember things."

He nodded.

***

At eleven, Martin Shaw arrived.

He was fifty-eight, with silver hair, a precise manner, and decades of experience handling complicated corporate disputes.

He reviewed the access logs.

"Dominic's account was used to renew the contractor credential."

Victor asked, "Could someone else have used it?"

"Yes. But we need to establish whether the account was compromised or deliberately used."

Penelope showed him the email.

Martin read it carefully.

"This is significant."

"Why?" Victor asked.

"Because the access request was not limited to the apartment building. It included several employees' personal addresses."

Victor frowned.

"Who else?"

Martin examined the list.

"Three former employees and one current employee."

Penelope leaned forward.

"Who?"

Martin read the names.

One belonged to a finance assistant.

Another to a former property manager.

The third belonged to a contractor who had resigned six months earlier.

The fourth was Penelope.

"Why were they selected?" Victor asked.

Martin shook his head.

"We don't know yet."

***

That evening, Penelope received a call from Evelyn Carter.

Evelyn was thirty-six and worked in the finance department.

They had spoken occasionally about invoices, but they were not close friends.

"Penelope?"

"Yes."

"I need to tell you something."

Penelope looked toward Victor.

He was reviewing documents nearby.

"Go ahead."

"I saw Dominic requesting information about your working hours."

Penelope sat upright.

"When?"

"Two weeks ago."

"What did he say?"

"He described it as a routine security review."

"Did you provide the information?"

"No."

"Why?"

"Because it didn't make sense. He already had access to the building schedule."

Penelope took a breath.

"Do you still have the request?"

"Yes."

"Can you preserve it?"

"I can."

"Would you be willing to speak with Martin?"

Evelyn hesitated.

"I'm nervous."

Penelope understood.

"So am I."

There was a pause.

Then Evelyn said, "All right."

***

The following morning, Evelyn arrived at Costello Tower.

She carried a laptop and a small encrypted drive.

Martin met her in a private conference room.

Penelope sat beside him.

Victor remained in the adjoining office, allowing the employees to speak freely.

Evelyn opened the records.

"This is the original request."

The screen showed Dominic's account asking for Penelope's working schedule.

It also showed the date and time.

Martin examined the metadata.

"Can you verify that this came from the security server?"

"Yes."

"Can you provide an export?"

"I already did."

She handed him the drive.

Penelope looked at the screen.

"Is there anything else?"

Evelyn hesitated.

"Yes."

She opened another document.

It was a report on Penelope's previous employment application.

The original application had been rejected.

Three months later, it had been reconsidered.

Penelope stared at the dates.

"I don't understand."

Evelyn looked at her.

"Dominic asked for the original file."

"Why?"

"I don't know."

Penelope read the note attached to it.

The wording was brief.

*Applicant may have access to records relevant to the closed financial review.*

Her stomach tightened.

"Someone knew I might find these payments before I started working here."

Martin looked up.

"That is one possible interpretation."

Penelope stared at the document.

"Who made the decision to reject me?"

Martin turned the page.

The approval belonged to Salvatore Costello's office.

***

Victor entered the conference room.

"What's happened?"

Penelope showed him the record.

He read it.

Then he looked at Martin.

"Find the original recruitment correspondence."

Martin nodded.

"I'll request the archived files."

Victor turned toward Penelope.

"Are you all right?"

She nodded slowly.

"I think so."

But her expression suggested otherwise.

***

By early afternoon, Martin had arranged a temporary audit room on a secure floor of Costello Tower.

The room had no windows, but it had a long table, a wall display, and enough space for the original records to be laid out without being mixed together.

Penelope arrived with her laptop.

Evelyn was already there, carrying a slim binder.

Martin stood beside the display.

"I want to separate what we know from what we suspect," he said. "That distinction will matter when the investigators ask for a statement."

Penelope nodded.

"Known facts first."

Evelyn connected her drive.

"The three Davis Strategic payments were processed under different descriptions. But the vendor reference is the same."

She enlarged the entries.

Penelope leaned forward.

"Those aren't three separate service requests. They're three parts of one billing sequence."

Martin examined the dates.

"Explain."

"The invoice numbers are consecutive, but the descriptions were changed. One says emergency administration, one says security support, and one says property access coordination. The original vendor code is identical."

"Could that be a normal accounting practice?" Martin asked.

"Not with these approval dates," Penelope replied. "The first two were entered before the contract was active. The third was entered after it expired."

Evelyn opened another screen.

"And the approval threshold was avoided by splitting the amount."

Martin looked at her.

"Can you demonstrate that?"

Evelyn brought up the finance policy.

"Any single payment above the threshold required a second approval. These were divided into smaller amounts and submitted on separate days."

Penelope checked the supporting documents.

"Someone wanted the payments to look routine."

"That is a reasonable inference," Martin said. "We'll label it as an inference until the records establish who did it."

Penelope nodded.

She began building a timeline.

The first payment had been made nine months earlier. The second followed three months later. The third appeared shortly before Trevor began sending messages again.

"There's another connection," Evelyn said.

She opened the archived vendor profile.

The contact address belonged to a mailbox used by Davis Strategic, but the telephone number was registered to a different company.

Penelope read the number.

"That's the same number listed on the security-access request."

Martin wrote it down.

"Now we have a link between the payment records and the credential request."

Penelope leaned back.

"Not proof that the same person handled both."

"Correct," Martin said. "But enough to justify a formal records request."

Evelyn looked uneasy.

"Do you think this reaches Salvatore?"

Victor had entered quietly and heard the question.

"We don't decide that in this room," he said. "We follow the approvals."

Penelope turned toward him.

"That's what we're doing."

"I know."

He looked at the display.

"Keep going."

***

A little later, Carmine brought in a separate box from the company's archived accounts-payable files.

The box had been sealed for years.

A printed inventory sheet was attached to the top.

"These were stored off-site," Carmine said. "Martin asked for the original vendor setup forms."

Penelope put on a pair of disposable gloves and opened the box.

The first documents were routine.

There were tax forms, vendor questionnaires, and old approval sheets.

Then she found a form for Davis Strategic Consulting.

The vendor had been created under an abbreviated name.

The contact person was Trevor Davis.

But the internal sponsor field contained a different name.

"Who is D.B.?" Penelope asked.

Carmine leaned closer.

"Could be Dominic Bellini."

Martin compared the signature on the form with the security authorization.

"They appear consistent, but we'll need a handwriting comparison before treating that as established."

Penelope turned the page.

A note had been stapled behind the form.

*Keep this vendor active until the records review is complete.*

There was no signature.

Victor read it.

"Who wrote that?"

"We don't know," Martin said.

Penelope looked at the date.

"It was entered two days after the first suspicious payment."

She pointed to another detail.

"And this vendor was never included in the regular annual review."

Evelyn frowned.

"That should have triggered an exception."

"It did," Penelope said. "Look at the audit note."

The exception had been marked as resolved.

The resolution code led back to the same security administration account.

Carmine looked at Victor.

"Dominic again."

Victor remained still.

"Preserve the original. Don't let anyone remove it."

Martin sealed the page in an evidence sleeve.

***

That evening, Penelope met Melissa at a small café near the river.

Melissa arrived with a scarf wrapped around her neck and two takeaway cups.

"I ordered tea for you."

Penelope smiled.

"Thank you."

They sat by the window.

Melissa looked at the folder beside Penelope's chair.

"Are you working?"

"Not exactly. I'm trying to understand what happened."

"That's still work."

Penelope stirred her tea.

"We found that the payments were split to avoid a second approval. The same security account was used to keep the vendor active."

Melissa's expression tightened.

"Does Victor know?"

"He was there when we found it."

"How is he handling it?"

"Quietly."

"That sounds like him."

Penelope looked through the window.

"I keep thinking about how easy it would have been to stay silent. I could have ignored the invoices. I could have told myself it wasn't my job."

"But you didn't."

"No."

Melissa reached across the table.

"That's not a mistake."

Penelope smiled faintly.

"I know. I just wish the consequences hadn't followed me home."

"I wish that too."

They sat quietly for a moment.

Then Melissa asked, "What do you want after this is over?"

Penelope looked at her.

"I don't know yet. I want to work. I want to feel safe in my own apartment. I want to stop planning every day around whether Trevor might appear."

"Those are good places to start."

"And I want whatever happens with Victor to be my choice. Not a reward for surviving something terrible."

Melissa nodded.

"Then keep saying that out loud. To him, to yourself, to anyone who needs to hear it."

Penelope smiled.

"I will."

When she returned to the penthouse later, she carried the audit folder herself.

She was tired, but she no longer felt as though the investigation was happening around her.

She was part of it.

***

Later that evening, after Penelope had returned to the penthouse, Martin called her back to the audit room. Before the room closed, he asked Evelyn to check whether the original Davis Strategic contract had ever been entered into the central contract register.

Evelyn searched the archive.

"There is a reference number," she said, "but no signed master copy."

Penelope looked over her shoulder.

"Could it have been stored under another vendor name?"

"I checked the alternate names. Nothing."

Martin leaned against the table.

"Then we need the records custodian to certify that the search was completed."

Victor studied the empty line on the display.

"Would a missing contract prove the payments were unauthorized?"

"Not by itself," Martin replied. "It would establish that the approval trail is incomplete. The payment records, the access request, and the missing agreement have to be considered together."

Penelope pointed to the screen.

"The first invoice says the work was covered by a master agreement. If no master agreement exists, someone used that phrase to make the invoice look approved."

Evelyn nodded.

"That's what the record suggests."

"Then preserve the invoice exactly as it is," Martin said. "No annotations on the original. We'll make working copies for analysis."

Penelope closed her notebook.

"That's how my mother would have done it."

Victor looked at her.

"Carefully?"

"Carefully, and with three copies."

For the first time that day, Evelyn laughed.

"Then we'd better make three."

They did.

***

At six that evening, Victor returned to the command room.

Carmine was waiting beside the table.

"We found Dominic's vehicle."

"Where?"

"Near the river."

"Is he there?"

"No. The vehicle was abandoned."

Victor studied the security footage.

"Anything else?"

"His assistant says he collected several personal files."

Victor looked toward the city map.

"He's running."

Carmine nodded.

"That's what it looks like."

Victor picked up his phone.

A message appeared.

It was from Dominic.

*I know what you're looking at. Don't trust the records.*

Victor read it twice.

Then another message arrived.

*Your uncle isn't the only one who knows what happened.*

More posts