Chapter 2: THE WOMAN WHO KNEW TOO MUCH

Written by

in

Reading settings

Luca Benedetti did not like unanswered questions.

He especially disliked them when they involved his family.

The ballroom had emptied considerably by the time he ordered Marco Bellini to secure the private corridor outside the hotel's executive lounge.

Marco, his security chief, had worked for the Benedetti family for sixteen years.

He understood that Luca's quietest orders were usually the most important.

"Nobody enters without your permission," Marco said.

"Nobody leaves with information they haven't been authorized to take."

Marco nodded.

"What about Miss Vance?"

"Keep her away from my grandmother."

"And Ms. Kowalic?"

Luca glanced toward the opposite side of the corridor.

Roz stood beside a marble column, speaking quietly with Arthur Whitmore.

"She stays."

Marco studied his employer.

"Understood."

Luca turned toward Carmela.

"Let's go."

His grandmother rose slowly.

Roz watched them disappear into the private lounge.

She was beginning to regret not having left with Mia.

The pies were delivered. The contract was fulfilled. Serena had received her punishment.

There was no reason for Roz to remain in a hotel full of people who appeared to know more about her family than she did.

She checked her phone.

A message from Mia appeared.

*I'm outside. Are you coming?*

Roz typed a reply.

*Five minutes.*

Arthur approached her.

"Miss Kowalic."

"Judge Whitmore?"

"Please. Arthur."

He looked toward the lounge.

"I knew your godfather."

Roz frowned.

"My what?"

"Matteo Benedetti."

The name meant something to her.

Not because she knew the man.

Because her mother had once mentioned him.

Only once.

Roz had been eighteen, and she had found an old photograph in a drawer.

A dark-haired man stood beside Aniela, holding a baby.

Her mother had taken the photograph from her hands.

"That's Matteo," she had said.

"Who is he?"

"A friend."

Then she had put the photograph away.

Roz looked at Arthur.

"I don't think I knew him."

"You were very young."

"How did you know him?"

Arthur's eyes grew distant.

"He was a good man."

Roz waited.

"He was also a man who believed that money should be used to help people who had very little."

Arthur looked at her apron.

"Your mother told him about opening the bakery. He helped her find the first premises."

Roz's chest tightened.

"Why didn't she tell me?"

Arthur hesitated.

"That is something you should ask her."

Before Roz could respond, Luca emerged from the lounge.

"Arthur."

The retired judge turned.

"Luca."

"I need a word."

Arthur nodded.

He looked at Roz once more.

"Your mother deserves to be heard, Miss Kowalic."

Then he walked away.

Luca approached.

"You're coming with us."

Roz stared at him.

"Excuse me?"

"My grandmother wants to speak with you."

"Your grandmother can call my mother."

"She doesn't want to speak to your mother over the telephone."

"Then she can arrange an appointment."

Luca studied her.

He wasn't accustomed to people refusing him.

Roz wasn't accustomed to accepting orders from men who believed their expensive suits made them kings.

"I've done what I was hired to do," she said. "I am going home."

Luca glanced toward the ballroom.

"Serena has made it clear she intends to retaliate."

"She has threatened me before."

"Tonight was different."

"Because I put a pie in her face?"

"Because she recognized your bracelet."

Roz looked down.

The silver bracelet rested against her wrist.

A tiny rose was engraved into its surface.

"My mother gave this to me."

"Then perhaps you should ask why my grandmother looked frightened when she saw it."

Roz hated that he was right.

She also hated the way he spoke as though he had already decided what was best for her.

"One conversation," she said.

"One."

***

Carmela was waiting in the private lounge.

She sat near the window, her pearl necklace clasped between her fingers.

When Roz entered, the elderly woman rose.

"I'm sorry," Carmela said.

Roz stopped.

"For what?"

"For allowing that woman to hurt you for so many years."

Roz looked confused.

"You don't know me."

Carmela's eyes filled.

"Not as well as I should."

Luca closed the door.

"Grandmother. Start explaining."

Carmela looked at him.

"Your father loved people who had nothing to offer him."

Luca's jaw tightened.

"Father died in an accident."

"That's what we told you."

"What are you saying?"

"Your father was murdered."

Silence.

The word seemed to occupy the entire room.

Luca stared at her.

"Careful."

Carmela did not flinch.

"I have been careful for twenty-five years. I am finished being careful."

Roz took a step backward.

This was no longer a family argument.

This was something dangerous.

Luca approached his grandmother.

"Who killed him?"

Carmela lowered her eyes.

"Your uncle Enzo."

Luca said nothing.

His face had gone frighteningly still.

"Enzo was with Father that night?"

"Yes."

"Then why did we bury him believing he died in an accident?"

"Because Enzo told us what happened. Because he had help. Because I was afraid."

"Of him?"

"Of what he would do to you."

"Why did you ask me to stay?"

Carmela turned toward her.

"Because your mother kept something Matteo never managed to protect."

"My what?"

"Matteo Benedetti."

Roz blinked.

"My godfather?"

"Yes."

Carmela reached for her hand.

"He held you when you were three days old. He called you the daughter of my heart."

Roz felt something shift inside her.

"Why would he say that?"

"Because he loved your mother."

The old woman swallowed.

"He planned to marry Aniela. He wanted to raise you as his own. He never pretended you were his biological child. He simply loved you."

Luca looked sharply at Carmela.

"You knew her mother?"

"Of course."

"Then why have I never heard this?"

"Because I was afraid that the truth would destroy everything."

Carmela took a breath.

"Your father discovered that Enzo and Richard Vance were stealing from the Benedetti charitable foundation. They had diverted approximately three hundred and eighty thousand dollars through false accounts."

"Richard Vance?"

"Serena's father."

Roz felt cold.

"Serena knew?"

"She was twelve when Matteo died."

Carmela closed her eyes.

"She saw something that night."

"What?" Luca demanded.

"She saw her father helping Enzo."

Roz remembered Serena's face after the pie.

The fear.

The sudden silence.

"Why would she be blackmailing you?" Roz asked.

Carmela looked at her.

"Because she inherited something from her father."

"A ledger?"

Carmela nodded.

"A coded financial ledger. It contains the names, transfers, dates, and accounts that prove the theft. It also connects Enzo and Richard to your godfather's murder."

Luca stared at her.

"And Serena has it?"

"She inherited it after Richard died."

"Why didn't you tell me?"

"Because she threatened to release it."

"Let her."

Carmela shook her head.

"She doesn't only threaten me. She threatens the foundation, the people who depend on it, and anyone who could be hurt by the scandal. She has been manipulating the foundation's accounts for years."

Luca's expression hardened.

"How much?"

"More than you know."

"How much?"

"I don't have the complete figure."

Luca turned toward Marco, who had quietly entered the room.

"Find Serena."

Marco nodded.

"Already working on it."

Carmela caught Luca's sleeve.

"Don't confront her yet."

"Why?"

"Because the ledger is not the only evidence."

She looked at Roz.

"Aniela kept a second copy."

Roz's breath caught.

"My mother?"

"Yes."

"Where?"

Carmela shook her head.

"I don't know. Matteo gave it to her before he died. She hid it somewhere no one would think to look."

Luca turned toward Roz.

"Can you call her?"

Roz nodded slowly.

She took out her phone.

But before she could dial, it rang.

ANIELA appeared on the screen.

Roz answered immediately.

"Mom?"

Her mother's voice was barely audible.

"Rose, listen to me."

"What happened?"

"Did you go to the gala?"

Roz looked at the elderly woman.

"Yes."

"Did you see Carmela?"

Roz looked at Carmela.

"Yes."

A long silence followed.

Then Aniela whispered:

"Did she tell you about Matteo?"

Roz swallowed.

"Yes."

Her mother's breathing became uneven.

"Then you must come home."

"Mom, what is happening?"

"There's something I should have told you twenty-five years ago."

"Tell me now."

Aniela began crying.

"Your godfather didn't die because of an accident."

Roz closed her eyes.

"I know."

Another silence.

Then her mother said something that made Luca turn sharply toward the phone.

"Rose, someone has been looking for the letter."

"What letter?"

"The one Matteo left beneath the floor."

Roz froze.

Aniela's voice broke.

"Someone has been looking for it."

Luca looked at Roz.

"Your mother knows where the second copy is."

Roz stared at her phone.

"And somebody is looking for it."

***

They left the Pfister under Marco's protection.

Stefano, the family driver, waited beside a black sedan.

Luca opened the rear door for Carmela.

Roz hesitated.

"I can take a cab."

"No," Luca said.

"I don't need a bodyguard."

"Tonight you do."

"You're very used to giving orders."

"And you're very used to ignoring sensible advice."

Roz almost smiled.

"That sounds like a problem for both of us."

Luca looked at her for a second.

Then he opened the door wider.

"Get in, Rose."

She climbed inside.

Carmela sat beside her.

As Stefano drove through Milwaukee, the elderly woman held Roz's hand.

"I owe you an apology."

"For what?"

"For what happened to your mother. For what happened to Matteo. For every year you spent believing that man had abandoned you."

Roz looked at her.

"My father?"

"Marek Kowalic was a good man."

Roz went still.

Carmela continued.

"He died when you were very young. Your mother couldn't bear to explain it. She let you believe he had left because she didn't know how to tell a child that her father would never come home."

Roz looked out the window.

All her life, she had imagined a father who had chosen another life.

A man who had walked away.

Now she learned that the truth was something else.

And another man, Matteo Benedetti, had loved her without being asked.

"Why did nobody tell me?" she whispered.

Carmela squeezed her hand.

"Because fear makes people do terrible things."

Luca sat opposite them.

His eyes were fixed on the city passing outside.

"Not anymore," he said.

***

At the Benedetti residence, Lucia Benedetti waited in the entrance hall.

Luca's mother wore a dark blue dress and a simple gold necklace.

She looked from her son to Carmela, then to Roz.

"What's happened?"

Luca answered.

"Father was murdered."

Lucia's hand flew to her mouth.

Carmela lowered her head.

Lucia stared at her.

"You knew?"

"I did."

"For twenty-five years?"

"Yes."

Lucia turned away.

She walked toward the window and stood there for a long time.

Then she turned back.

"Tell him everything."

Carmela nodded.

But before she could continue, Marco entered.

"Boss."

"What?"

"Serena's car is gone."

"Where?"

"Her driver says she left the hotel alone. She didn't go home."

Luca's expression hardened.

"Find her."

Marco hesitated.

"There's something else."

"What?"

"Your uncle Enzo's residence is empty."

Carmela's face drained of color.

"He's gone?"

Marco nodded.

"And his private office has been cleaned out."

Luca looked at his grandmother.

"You said he left before the speeches."

Carmela nodded.

"Yes."

"Did he know you were going to tell me?"

She looked down at her pearls.

"I believe he did."

Luca turned toward Marco.

"Find him before he finds the evidence."

Then his phone rang.

An unknown number.

He answered.

A woman's voice came through.

Serena.

"Tell your grandmother to stop talking, Luca."

His expression did not change.

"Where are you?"

"Somewhere safe."

"What do you want?"

"I want you to remember that your family has a past."

"Everyone has a past."

"Not everyone has a dead father buried under a lie."

Luca's eyes narrowed.

Serena laughed softly.

"And tell your little baker to enjoy her last peaceful night."

The call ended.

Luca looked at Roz.

The first time he had seen her, she had been holding a pie.

Now he understood that the woman who had thrown it was standing at the center of a secret that had haunted his family for twenty-five years.

And Serena Vance had just made it personal.
***

At eight the next morning, Luca drove to Arthur Whitmore's home.

The retired judge lived in a brick house on a quiet street not far from the lake. Books filled the front windows, and a brass lamp glowed beside the door even though daylight had already begun to spread across the neighborhood.

Arthur opened the door himself.

"I wondered when you would come."

"I should have come twenty-five years ago."

"You were fifteen, Luca. You were not responsible for what the adults around you concealed."

Arthur led him into a study lined with law books and old photographs. He poured two cups of coffee, then sat opposite Luca.

"You heard the recording?"

"Every word."

"Then you heard your father."

Luca looked down at the cup.

"I had forgotten his voice."

"People sometimes think memory preserves a voice exactly. It doesn't. It preserves the feeling of being safe when that voice called your name."

Luca said nothing.

Arthur opened a drawer and removed a photograph of Matteo standing outside a community center. His sleeves were rolled up, and he was holding a box of groceries.

"Your father brought food to that center every Thursday," Arthur said. "He never put his name on the donations. He would arrive in an old car, unload the boxes, and leave before anyone could thank him."

"He never told me."

"He didn't want you to confuse generosity with reputation. He said the work mattered more than the name on the building."

Luca studied the photograph.

"Was he afraid of Enzo?"

"Not at first. Matteo trusted his brother. That was what made the betrayal so difficult for him to accept."

"When did he begin to suspect?"

"About a month before he died. He came to see me with copies of foundation transfers. The amounts were small enough to escape attention individually, but together they formed a pattern. He believed Enzo and Richard were using false vendors to move money out of the charitable accounts."

"Why didn't he go to the police?"

"I asked him the same question. He said he wanted the original records and a second copy before making an accusation. He feared that if he moved too soon, Enzo would destroy the documents and blame an innocent employee."

Arthur leaned back.

"Your father was not afraid of losing his position. He was afraid of leaving the people who depended on the foundation without help."

"Did he tell you he was going to the boathouse?"

"Not the first time we spoke. The last time, he said he had arranged a meeting with Enzo and Richard. I told him not to go alone."

"And he went anyway."

"Yes."

Luca's jaw tightened.

Arthur looked at him carefully.

"Matteo asked me something that afternoon. He asked whether loyalty could become a form of cowardice."

"What did you tell him?"

"I told him loyalty without honesty was only obedience. He smiled, but he looked tired. He said he hoped the people he loved would understand why he had kept certain things from them."

Luca stared at the photograph.

"Did he mention my mother?"

Arthur's expression changed.

"Yes."

"What did he say?"

"He was worried Lucia had begun to suspect Enzo. He told me she had asked questions about the foundation accounts and the movements of Enzo's car. He wanted to keep her away from the dispute."

"Did she know about the meeting?"

"I don't know what Matteo told her. But she came to see me the morning after he died."

Luca sat forward.

"Why?"

Arthur paused before answering.

"Your mother followed Enzo down the lake road that night. She saw him return alone."

Luca went completely still.

"She saw him?"

"She did not see what happened inside the boathouse. She told me she stayed back and watched from a distance. But she was certain Enzo had gone there, and she was certain he came back without your father."

"Why didn't she tell me?"

"She was frightened. Carmela was frightened. Enzo had made it clear that you would be the price if either woman spoke."

Luca stood and walked to the window.

For twenty-five years, he had believed the silence around his father's death was grief.

Now he understood that it had also been fear.

Arthur rose and placed the photograph in Luca's hand.

"Your father did not ask me to avenge him. He asked me to make sure the foundation continued helping people. Don't let what Enzo did turn you into someone Matteo would not recognize."

Luca looked down at the photograph.

"I don't know what he would recognize anymore."

Arthur rested a hand on his shoulder.

"Then start by telling the truth. The rest will take time."

Luca turned toward him.

"There's something else you haven't told me."

Arthur's expression grew solemn.

"Your mother followed Enzo to the lake that night, Luca. And she has carried what she saw for twenty-five years."

More posts