Chapter 2: Questions About You

Written by

in

Reading settings

The SUV smelled of leather and cold air and something faintly metallic, like a gun safe. I sat in the back seat between two men who did not introduce themselves, my hands folded in my lap, my waitress apron still tied around my waist because no one had given me time to take it off. The city slid past the tinted windows in gray and gold, and I tried to count the blocks to keep my breathing steady, the way my mother used to count my breaths when I was small and afraid of thunderstorms.

One. In. Two. Out.

It didn't work. My heart was hammering against my ribs so hard I was sure the men could hear it.

"Where are you taking me?" I asked, and was proud of how steady my voice sounded.

The man on my left — the younger one, with a scar through his left eyebrow — glanced at me. "Mr. Moretti wants to talk to you. That's all."

"Talk about what?"

"He'll tell you himself."

The other man said nothing at all. He stared out the window with the stillness I was beginning to recognize as the particular stillness of men who had been trained to wait for orders and to carry them out without questions. It frightened me more than any threat would have.

We drove to a glass tower on the Upper East Side, the kind of building with a doorman who did not ask questions and an elevator that opened directly into a private floor. The men walked on either side of me through a marble lobby, and I was acutely aware of my cheap black shoes squeaking on the polished floor and the apron strings dangling at my waist and the fact that I had not had time to wash the smell of the kitchen out of my hair.

The elevator doors opened onto a penthouse that looked like a photograph from a magazine — floor-to-ceiling windows, a fireplace that was lit even though it was barely autumn, dark wood and cream leather and a view of Central Park turning gold in the morning light. And there, standing by the window with his back to us, was Dante Moretti.

He turned slowly. He was wearing a dark suit now, no coat, and without the coat he looked even bigger, his shoulders filling the doorway of the window light. His gray eyes found mine and held them, and I had the strange feeling of being looked at by someone who already knew things about me that I didn't know myself.

"Miss Marshall," he said. His voice was low and even, the voice of a man who never needed to raise it. "Thank you for coming. Please, sit."

There was a chair. I sat. The two men took up positions by the door, and I tried not to look at them.

"You had my people ask questions about me," I said, because fear had always made me bold in exactly the wrong moments. "Your manager said you discovered something impossible in my background. I don't know what that means, but I didn't do anything wrong. I petted your dog. That's all I did."

"That's all you did," he repeated, and something moved in his face — not quite a smile. "Do you know what Orion did to the last man who touched him without permission?"

I shook my head.

"He put him in the hospital for three weeks. The man was a bodyguard. He had worked for me for two years. He reached for Orion's collar during a walk, and Orion decided he was a threat." Dante took a step closer, and I had to fight the urge to lean back. "Orion has never — not once, in seven years — allowed a stranger to touch him. He does not like people. He tolerates me. He tolerates two of my men. Everyone else, he watches like they might be a problem."

"Then why did he let me?" The question came out before I could stop it.

"That," Dante said quietly, "is what I intend to find out."

He moved to a desk and picked up a thin folder. He opened it and laid it on the low table between us, turning it so I could see. Inside were pages of printouts — my name, my address, my employment history, my bank balance, which was forty-one dollars and seventeen cents. There was a copy of my birth certificate. A copy of my mother's death certificate. And a copy of my father's death certificate, which I had not looked at in years.

"Olivia Marshall," Dante read, "born March 14th, in Queens. Mother: Sofia Marshall, nurse, deceased. Father: Thomas Marshall, dockworker, deceased." He looked up at me. "Your father died on October 3rd, nineteen years ago. Do you know how he died?"

"The official story was an accident at the docks," I said. My throat was dry. "A crate fell. My mother never wanted to talk about it."

"There was no accident, Miss Marshall."

The room seemed to tilt. I gripped the arms of the chair.

"Your father pulled me out of the Hudson River on the night of October 3rd," Dante said. His voice had changed — quieter, rougher, as though the words were being dragged out of him. "I was nineteen years old. Men had shot me twice and thrown me off a pier because my father refused to give up a shipping contract to the Castellano family. I should have drowned. Your father was working the night shift. He heard the splash. He pulled me out, hid me in his apartment for three days while I bled, and called a doctor he trusted instead of an ambulance, because an ambulance would have meant questions. He saved my life."

I stared at him. "That's not possible."

"Three days later, the men who shot me found out where I was. They came to your father's apartment. He got me out through the back, and he stayed behind to slow them down." Dante's jaw tightened. "They killed him, Miss Marshall. There was no falling crate. He died because he chose to save a nineteen-year-old boy he didn't know. And I have spent nineteen years trying to find his family to repay that debt. Your mother took you and disappeared the week after the funeral. My people searched for years. We never found you."

"Why are you telling me this?" My voice sounded far away, like it belonged to someone else.

"Because last night," Dante said, "my dog — a dog that has never trusted a stranger in his life — pressed his head into your hand like he had been waiting for you. And this morning, my investigator found your father's name in my own file, and I understood that the girl my dog chose is the daughter of the only man who ever saved my life without asking for anything in return."

I looked down at the folder. At my father's name. Thomas Marshall. I had carried that name my whole life and never known what it meant.

"That's the impossible thing," Dante said. "I have been looking for you for nineteen years. And you walked into my restaurant and put your hand on my dog."

For a long moment, neither of us spoke. Somewhere in the penthouse, a clock ticked.

Then Dante reached into the folder and took out a photograph, and he slid it across the table toward me. It was old and creased, the colors faded to a soft yellow. It showed a man standing on a pier at sunset, his arm around a woman with dark hair, and a little girl perched on his shoulders, laughing, her hands in his hair. The man was broad and strong, with a face I almost recognized. The woman was beautiful in a tired, ordinary way. The little girl was me.

"Where did you get this?" I whispered. My hands were shaking so hard the photograph trembled.

"It was in my father's file," Dante said. "He kept a file on your family for nineteen years. Photographs, addresses, names of schools. He never stopped looking. When he died, the file came to me, and I kept looking. But after your mother moved you the third time, the trail went cold. She was very good at disappearing."

I touched the photograph with one fingertip, tracing the outline of my father's face. "I don't remember this day. I don't remember the pier. I don't remember him lifting me up."

"You were four years old," Dante said gently. "You wouldn't remember."

"My mother never showed me this photograph. She never showed me any photographs of him. I thought there weren't any." I looked up at Dante, and my eyes were burning. "Why did she hide him from me? Why did she hide all of it?"

"Because she was afraid," Dante said. "Castellano's men came to your apartment the week after the funeral. They asked questions. They wanted to know where I was, and what your father had told your mother before he died. Your mother packed a bag that night and took you to a shelter in New Jersey, and then to a cousin in Brooklyn, and then to Queens, and every time she thought they had found her, she moved again. She wasn't hiding your father from you, Olivia. She was hiding you from them."

I thought about my mother — about the way she had worked night shifts at the hospital and come home with her shoes in her hand so she wouldn't wake me, about the way she had taught me to lock the door twice and never to open it for strangers, about the way she had gone quiet whenever I asked about my father. I had always thought she was just a private person. I had never understood that she was a frightened one.

"Can I call my neighbor?" I asked suddenly. "Mrs. Alvarez. She feeds my cat when I'm away. She'll be worried. She'll think something happened to me."

Dante nodded and handed me his phone. I dialed the number from memory, and Mrs. Alvarez answered on the second ring, and her voice was sharp with worry until she heard mine, and then it went soft with relief. I told her I was safe, and that I would be staying with a friend for a few days, and that Miso needed food and fresh water, and she said, "Mija, of course, of course, don't worry about the cat," and then she said, "Are you in trouble, Olivia?" and I said, "No, Mrs. Alvarez. I'm not in trouble. I'm just… I'm finally finding out who my father was." And she was quiet for a moment, and then she said, "Your mother would be glad. She always wanted you to know. She just didn't know how to tell you."

When I hung up, Dante was watching me, and his expression was unreadable. "Your mother was brave," he said. "Bravest woman I never met."

"She was," I said. "And now I know why."

For a long moment, neither of us spoke. Somewhere in the penthouse, a clock ticked. Outside the window, the city went on being the city.

Then a sound came from the hallway — a low whine, and the heavy pad of paws on marble. Orion appeared in the doorway, enormous and black and beautiful, and the moment he saw me his whole body changed. His tail began to move. He crossed the room in three strides and pressed his massive head against my knee, exactly the way he had in the restaurant, and heaved a sigh so deep and contented that something in my chest cracked open.

Dante watched us, and his face did something I had not expected. It softened. Not much — just enough that for a moment he looked like a man instead of a legend.

"He hasn't eaten since you left," Dante said quietly. "He wouldn't sleep. He sat by the door all night."

I scratched behind Orion's ear, and his eyes closed, and his tail thumped once against the polished floor.

"I don't want your money," I said. "If that's what this is — if you think you owe my father something, I don't want it. I don't want to be a debt."

"I'm not offering you money," Dante said. "I'm offering you the truth. And I'm offering you protection, because the men who killed your father are still out there, and now they will know that I found you."

"The Castellanos," I said, remembering the name.

"Vincent Castellano runs the family now. He ordered the hit on me nineteen years ago, and he ordered your father's death. If he learns that the Marshall girl is alive and that I have found her, he will try to use you against me." Dante crouched down then, so that his eyes were level with mine, and for the first time I saw something in them that was not cold at all. It was something much more dangerous. It was grief. "I will not let that happen. Not to Thomas Marshall's daughter. Not to you."

I looked at Orion, who had fallen asleep with his head on my foot. I looked at the folder with my father's name in it. I thought about my mother, who had hidden me for nineteen years and died without ever telling me why. I thought about the rent and the double shifts and the eleven hundred dollars a month and the fact that I had nothing and no one in the world except a cat named Miso and a neighbor who watered my plants when I was away.

"I don't know what to say," I whispered.

"Say you'll let me keep you safe," Dante said. "That's all I ask. For now."

And because I had no one else, and because the dog at my feet had chosen me, and because the man in front of me was looking at me like my father's ghost had walked into his restaurant, I said yes.

I didn't know then that saying yes would change everything. I didn't know that one of the men standing by the door had already sent a text message to Vincent Castellano, telling him that Dante Moretti had found the Marshall girl. I didn't know that by nightfall, my address would be in the hands of men who wanted me dead or taken, and that the only thing standing between me and them would be a mafia boss, his guards, and a dog who had decided I was his.

I only knew that for the first time in my life, someone was looking at me like I mattered. And that terrified me more than anything else in that room.

More posts