Chapter 2: Ten Years at the Whitfield

Written by

in

Reading settings

The Whitfield Diner had been on the corner of Halsted and 18th Street for forty-one years, and I had worked there for ten of them. The building was old brick, the windows were big and streaked, the counter was long and scratched, and the coffee machine hissed like an angry cat every morning at six. The regulars called it the Whitfield, and the owner, Mr. Whitfield, called it his life, and both of them were right.

Mr. Whitfield was seventy-four years old, with white hair and hands that shook a little when he poured coffee, and he had run the diner since before I was born. He had hired me when I was seventeen, after my father died in a warehouse accident and my mother needed me to bring in money. He didn't ask me about school. He didn't ask me about my grades. He just handed me an apron and said, "You watch people's hands, girl. Hands tell you everything."

He was right. In ten years, I learned to read a room by its hands. The truck drivers drummed their fingers when they were impatient. The old ladies folded their napkins into perfect squares when they were lonely. The teenagers texted under the table when they were bored. And the men who came in alone, the ones in the good suits who sat in the corner booth and never looked at the menu, they kept their hands flat on the table, very still, like men who were used to being watched and had learned not to give anything away.

After that first day, Salvatore Marquetti came every day at eleven forty in the morning. He always sat at table twelve, the corner booth by the window, where he could see the whole room and the door at the same time. He always ordered the same thing: black coffee, toast, and two eggs, scrambled. He always tipped exactly twenty dollars, folded neatly under the coffee cup. And he always waited for me.

The first week, he didn't say much. He would sign, "Good morning," and I would sign, "Good morning," and he would eat his eggs slowly, watching the room, watching the street, watching my hands when I passed his table. Sometimes he would catch my eye and sign, "Busy today," and I would sign, "Always busy," and he would nod, like that was a real conversation, like that was enough.

The second week, he started asking questions. "How long have you worked here?" he signed. "Ten years," I signed back. His eyebrows went up. "You started young," he signed. "I needed the money," I signed. "My father died. My mother needed help. My brother needed help." He nodded slowly, and he didn't ask any more questions that day, but the next day he signed, "Your brother. Chris. He is deaf like me?" And I signed, "Yes. Born deaf. He is nineteen. He just finished school." And Salvatore nodded again, and for a long moment he just looked at his coffee, and I wondered what he was thinking.

The third week, Gabby cornered me in the kitchen during the afternoon lull. "Okay," she said, her voice low, her eyes wide. "What is going on with you and the mafia boss? Because everybody is talking about it, and I need to know before I hear it from someone else."

"Nothing is going on," I said, which was true, and also not true, because something was going on, I just didn't have a name for it yet.

"He comes every day," Gabby said. "He sits at your table. He talks to you with his hands. He tips twenty dollars. Val, men like that do not tip twenty dollars for eggs. Men like that do not come to diners. What does he want?"

"I don't know," I said honestly. "He wants someone to talk to, I think. In his language. I think nobody has ever talked to him in his language before. Not in a place like this."

Gabby stared at me. "You are not scared of him?"

I thought about it. Was I scared of Salvatore Marquetti? The newspapers called him Chicago's most dangerous man. The whispers in the diner said he had men killed, that he ran the docks and the trucks and the unions, that his father's killers had never been found because Salvatore had found them first. I had heard all of it. And I had also watched him sit in my booth for three weeks, eating scrambled eggs, signing politely, tipping twenty dollars, and looking at my hands the way a thirsty man looks at water.

"No," I said. "I'm not scared of him. He has never once raised his voice to me. He has never once been rude. He signs please and thank you. He asks about my brother. The men I am scared of are the ones who shout. He doesn't shout. He doesn't even speak."

Gabby shook her head. "You're crazy, Val. You're absolutely crazy. But also," she added, grudgingly, "he is very handsome."

"He is," I agreed, and we both laughed, and for a moment it felt like a normal day in a normal diner with a normal crush on a normal man, instead of what it really was.

Because the truth was, I was starting to look forward to eleven forty. I was starting to check the clock at eleven thirty, and fix my ponytail, and make sure my apron was straight. I was starting to think about what I would sign to him, what I would ask him, what his hands would say back to me. I was starting to feel something I hadn't felt in years, something warm and frightening and completely impractical, and I was doing my best to ignore it, because waitresses at the Whitfield Diner did not fall in love with mafia bosses. That was not a thing that happened in real life. That was a thing that happened in movies.

But Salvatore Marquetti was not a movie. He was a man who came to my diner every day, and sat in my booth, and spoke my brother's language, and looked at me like I was the first person in years who had actually seen him.

One afternoon, near the end of the third week, he was finishing his coffee when a man in a gray suit came into the diner and slid into the booth across from him without being invited. The man was younger than Salvatore, with slicked-back hair and a gold watch and a smile that didn't reach his eyes. He talked fast, with his mouth, not his hands, and he kept glancing at the door, like he was afraid someone might be listening.

I was wiping down the next table, and I couldn't help overhearing. The man in the gray suit said, "The Collection wants the whole block, Sal. The gallery needs the space. The diner is the last holdout. Whitfield won't sell, but he's old, and he's sick, and his daughter in Florida keeps calling him. We can push him. We can make him an offer he can't refuse."

Salvatore didn't answer. He just looked at the man, very still, his hands flat on the table.

"The boss wants it done by Christmas," the man said. "Sixty days. That's the timeline. The lawyers are ready. You just have to say the word."

Salvatore lifted one hand, slowly, and made a single sign. I didn't know the sign. It was fast and sharp, and the man in the gray suit flinched, and then he slid out of the booth and left the diner without looking back.

I stood there with my rag in my hand, frozen. The Collection. The whole block. Sixty days. The diner is the last holdout.

I knew what the Central Illinois Collection was. Everybody in Chicago knew. It was Salvatore Marquetti's legitimate company, a private art collection and gallery business, the clean face of his empire. And if the Collection wanted the whole block, and the diner was the last holdout, then the man who had been coming to my table every day, the man who signed "Stay. Talk to me," was the man who was going to buy my diner and close it down.

That night, I went home and I didn't tell my mother. I didn't tell Chris. I sat at our kitchen table and I looked at the bills stacked by the phone, and the tip jar on the counter, and the calendar on the wall where I had marked Chris's job interviews in red pen, and I thought about what would happen to us if the Whitfield closed. Where would I work? Who would hire a twenty-seven-year-old waitress who had spent ten years in one diner? How would I pay for Chris's bus pass, and my mother's medicine, and the rent on our little apartment?

And I thought about Salvatore Marquetti, sitting in my booth, signing "Good morning" with his beautiful, careful hands, and I thought about how I had spent three weeks thinking he was the first person who had ever really seen me, when all along he might have just been looking at the building.

That evening, after my shift, I came home to find Chris sitting at our kitchen table with a stack of job applications spread out in front of him, his face tight with concentration. He looked up when I came in, and he signed, "How was work?"

"Busy," I signed back, which was true, and also the biggest lie I had told all day.

He nodded toward the applications. "I applied to four more places today," he signed. "A warehouse. A grocery store. A print shop. The man at the print shop said they would call me. He said it very slowly, like I was a child. I wanted to tell him I can read lips faster than he can talk, but I just smiled."

My heart ached for him. Chris was nineteen, smart, fast with his hands, good with machines, and the world kept looking at his deafness first and him second. I sat down across from him and I signed, "You will find something. You are the smartest person I know. Any place would be lucky to have you."

He smiled, a small, brave smile, and he signed, "You always say that."

"Because it is always true," I signed, and I reached across the table and squeezed his hand, and I made myself a promise, right there in that kitchen, with the bills on the counter and the applications on the table. Whatever happened with the diner, whatever happened with Salvatore Marquetti, I would not let my brother's future depend on the kindness of strangers. I would build it myself, the way I had built everything else in my life, one day at a time, one shift at a time, one pair of hands at a time.

The next morning, Mr. Whitfield called me into his office before my shift. His office was a tiny room behind the kitchen, with a desk covered in papers and a window that looked out onto the alley. He sat down heavily in his chair, and he looked older than I had ever seen him look.

"Val," he said, "I need to tell you something, and I need you to hear it from me before you hear it from someone else."

My heart sank. "Is it about the Collection?" I asked.

He blinked. "You already know."

"I overheard something yesterday," I said. "A man in a gray suit. He said the Collection wants the whole block. He said the diner is the last holdout. He said sixty days."

Mr. Whitfield nodded slowly. "It's true. They've made me an offer. A good offer. More money than this diner has made in five years. My daughter wants me to take it. My doctor wants me to take it. My knees want me to take it." He rubbed his hands together, and I saw that they were shaking more than usual. "I'm seventy-four years old, Val. I can't run this place forever. And the roof needs fixing, and the grill needs replacing, and the health inspector was here last month, and I just… I don't know if I can keep going."

"But the diner is your life," I said.

"It is," he said. "And it has been a good life. But lives end, Val. Places end. And I need to know that when I go, the people I love will be all right. You, and Gabby, and the cooks, and the regulars. I need to know you'll be all right."

"Will we?" I asked. "If the diner closes, where do we go?"

He didn't answer that. He just looked at me, and I saw something in his eyes that I had never seen before. Guilt. And something else. Something that looked almost like hope.

"There's one more thing," he said quietly. "The man who comes every day. The man in the charcoal suit. His name is Salvatore Marquetti, and he is the one buying the block. And Val, I think you should know… he asked me about you. The first day he came in, after you served him, he came to my office and he asked me who you were. He asked me how long you'd worked here. He asked me if you had family. And I told him."

I stared at him. "You told him about Chris?"

"I told him you were the best waitress I ever had," Mr. Whitfield said. "And I told him your brother is deaf, and that you learned sign language for him. And do you know what he did? He sat in that chair right there, and he cried. Just for a second. Just one tear, running down his face, before he wiped it away and pretended it never happened. A man like that doesn't cry, Val. Not in front of strangers. Not ever. But he cried in my office, because of you."

I didn't know what to say to that. I stood in Mr. Whitfield's little office, with the papers on the desk and the window looking out on the alley, and I felt like the floor had tilted under my feet.

"He's coming back today," Mr. Whitfield said. "At eleven forty, like always. And Val, whatever you decide to do about him, about any of this, I want you to know that you have a job here for as long as I own this diner. And if I sell it, I'll make sure you get a recommendation that will get you hired anywhere in this city. That's a promise."

I thanked him, and I went out to start my shift, and I tried to focus on the coffee and the orders and the regulars, but all I could think about was eleven forty, and the man in the charcoal suit, and the tear running down his face in Mr. Whitfield's office, and the sixty days until the diner closed, and the fact that the man I was starting to fall for might be the same man who was going to take everything from me.

More posts