Chapter 1: Daddy, Am I Looking in a Mirror?

Written by

in

Reading settings

"Daddy… am I looking in a mirror?"

Those seven words stopped Dominic Moretti in the middle of Michigan Avenue, and for the first time in his thirty-five years, the most feared man in Chicago forgot how to breathe.

His five-year-old daughter, Sophie, had suddenly pulled his hand so hard that he stumbled half a step.

Dominic had been watching the reflection of a black sedan in a department store window. It was an old habit, the kind a man developed when he had spent half his life living among people who smiled across dinner tables while planning murders behind closed doors.

He had not been paying attention to the little girl sitting near the flower arrangements outside an expensive boutique.

But Sophie had noticed her.

And Sophie had seen something that made absolutely no sense.

The little girl wore a faded red dress decorated with tiny flowers. Her chestnut-brown hair had been twisted into a messy bun and secured with a red elastic band. She held a battered stuffed rabbit against her chest, its once-white fur turned beige from years of being loved.

Her shoes were scuffed. A thin blue coat lay beside a crumpled paper bag near her feet.

She looked as though she belonged to a completely different world from Sophie Moretti, whose ivory lace dress had been handmade in Italy and whose cream-colored hair bow probably cost more than the little girl's entire wardrobe.

But their faces…

Their faces were identical.

The same delicate nose.

The same soft mouth.

The same wide gray eyes.

Even the tiny freckle beside the left side of their noses was in precisely the same place.

Dominic stared.

His mind tried to offer explanations.

Coincidence.

A resemblance.

Perhaps exhaustion had finally caught up with him after three sleepless nights negotiating with men who could not understand the meaning of loyalty.

Then Sophie stepped forward and gently touched the stranger's cheek.

The little girl in red recoiled.

"Sorry," Sophie whispered. "I just wanted to see if you were real."

The stranger studied her, astonished.

"You're real too?"

Sophie nodded.

The girl slowly raised her own hand and touched her cheek.

Dominic dropped into a crouch behind them, bracing himself against the pavement with one hand.

A pedestrian brushed against his shoulder.

Normally, Dominic's security detail would have intercepted anyone who came within three feet of him without permission.

But today he barely noticed.

He was staring into a face he had spent the last five years kissing goodnight.

And that face was staring back at him from another child.

"You have my face," Sophie whispered.

The girl in red tilted her head.

"No," she answered seriously. "You have mine."

For one strange moment, the noise of Chicago seemed to disappear.

There were still taxis honking.

Still footsteps striking concrete.

Still people laughing outside restaurants and tourists carrying shopping bags beneath the afternoon sun.

But Dominic heard none of it.

His attention was fixed on two little girls who looked like mirror images of each other.

He swallowed.

"Sweetheart," he said to the stranger, making his voice as gentle as possible, "what's your name?"

The little girl hesitated.

She tightened her grip on her stuffed rabbit.

"My mommy says I shouldn't talk to strangers."

"Your mommy is right."

Dominic offered a small smile.

"My name is Dominic. This is Sophie."

The little girl looked at Sophie again.

"I'm Ruby."

"Ruby what?" Sophie asked.

"Ruby Carter."

The name hit Dominic like a bullet.

Carter.

Five years had passed since he had last heard that name spoken by someone who did not know his history.

Five years since the funeral.

Five years since he had stood in the rain beside an empty coffin, listening to a priest speak about a woman who had made him believe that even a man like him deserved happiness.

Ava Carter.

Before she had become Ava Moretti.

Before the fire.

Before everything had been taken from him.

Dominic's fingers curled against the pavement.

"Ruby Carter," he repeated.

Ruby nodded.

"That's my name."

"How old are you?"

"Five."

Sophie's eyes widened.

"I'm five too!"

Ruby looked impressed.

"My birthday's November twelfth."

Sophie gasped.

"Mine too!"

Dominic felt the ground shift beneath him.

It was impossible.

Not merely unlikely.

Impossible.

He remembered the emergency delivery room at a private medical center outside Chicago.

The doctors rushing through double doors.

His uncle Victor holding his shoulders and telling him to remain calm.

The smell of antiseptic.

The call that sent him racing across the city.

And later, the devastating news that his wife and one of their newborn daughters had died.

One child survived.

Sophie.

The only bright thing left in a world that had turned black.

Dominic looked from Sophie to Ruby.

Two identical faces.

Two identical birthdays.

One dead daughter.

And suddenly the story he had accepted for five years began tearing itself apart.

"Where's your mommy, Ruby?" he asked.

Ruby's expression changed.

She glanced toward the sidewalk behind him.

"She's coming back."

"From where?"

"She went to get something."

"Does she know you're sitting here by yourself?"

Ruby's small chin lifted defensively.

"I'm not by myself. Mr. Bunny is with me."

Sophie nodded in complete agreement.

"Stuffed animals count."

Under any other circumstances, Dominic would have smiled.

Instead, he felt a coldness spreading through his chest.

His security chief, Gabriel Torres, stood near the parked black vehicle at the curb. Dominic caught his eye and gave the smallest possible signal.

Stay back.

Watch the crowd.

Gabriel understood.

Dominic had brought only two men today, despite objections from his entire security team. Sophie had begged him to take her shopping without "a hundred scary uncles" following them.

So he had compromised.

A quiet afternoon.

A bookstore.

Hot chocolate afterward.

For three hours, he wanted to be a father rather than the man who controlled half the criminal interests stretching from Chicago's South Side to the northern suburbs.

He had promised Sophie that nothing would interrupt their afternoon.

Now his heart was pounding for reasons no enemy had ever managed to create.

Sophie sat down beside Ruby.

"Do you like princess stories?"

Ruby shrugged.

"I like stories where the princess saves herself."

Sophie considered this.

"That's better. But sometimes the princess can have a dragon."

Ruby smiled for the first time.

"A nice dragon?"

"Of course."

The two girls began talking with an ease that made Dominic's throat tighten.

It was not simply their faces.

Sophie tilted her head when she was curious.

Ruby tilted hers in exactly the same way.

Sophie tucked loose hair behind her ear with her left hand.

Ruby did the same.

They even laughed with the same quick, musical sound.

Dominic had spent years studying people.

He could recognize a lie from the movement of a jaw.

He could tell when a man was about to reach for a weapon by the shift in his shoulders.

He could read fear, ambition, greed, and betrayal.

But he could not understand what he was seeing now.

Then a woman's voice pierced the afternoon air.

"RUBY!"

Ruby flinched violently.

Her shoulders jumped.

She hugged her rabbit so tightly that one of its floppy ears bent beneath her fingers.

"Mommy," she whispered.

Sophie looked toward the crowd.

Dominic stood.

A woman in a beige coat was moving quickly between pedestrians.

Her face was partially hidden behind a man carrying coffee.

Dark hair spilled over one shoulder.

She was carrying a small paper bag.

"Ruby! I told you to stay beside the flowers!"

"I'm here, Mommy!"

Ruby scrambled to her feet.

As she turned, the neckline of her red dress shifted.

Something silver slipped into the sunlight.

A necklace.

A delicate chain.

And hanging from it was a tiny blackbird with its wings spread wide.

Dominic stopped moving.

He knew that necklace.

He knew the shape of those wings.

He knew the tiny imperfection on the bird's left side, where the silversmith had accidentally left a barely visible groove.

He knew because he had commissioned it himself.

Seven years earlier, on a rainy December evening, he had placed that necklace around Ava Carter's neck while they stood beneath the Christmas lights outside a small restaurant.

She had laughed at the unusual design.

"A blackbird? Most women get diamonds, Dominic."

He had taken her hands.

"Blackbirds survive winter. They find their way home. You once told me you wanted a life where nobody could put you in a cage."

Ava had touched the pendant.

"And?"

"And I want you to be free."

She had kissed him.

"Then promise me something."

"Anything."

"Never become the kind of man who makes me afraid to come home."

He had promised.

At the time, he had believed himself.

Now that same blackbird was resting against the chest of a little girl who looked exactly like his daughter.

A little girl who shared Sophie's birthday.

A little girl named Carter.

Dominic reached toward the pendant, then stopped himself before touching it.

"Ruby," he said, his voice barely recognizable, "where did you get that necklace?"

Ruby covered it with her hand.

"It's my mommy's."

"Did she give it to you?"

"She says it keeps us brave."

Dominic could barely draw air into his lungs.

Ava had worn that necklace on the last morning he saw her alive.

He remembered kissing her forehead.

Remembered feeling the silver bird against his fingers.

Remembered telling her he would be home before dinner.

He never saw her again.

The vehicle carrying her away from the medical center had reportedly caught fire on a secluded stretch of road.

His uncle Victor had handled the aftermath.

Victor had arranged the funeral.

Victor had shown him a sealed medical report.

And Victor had told him, with tears in his eyes, that reopening the investigation would only make the pain worse.

Dominic had believed him.

He had been grieving.

He had been holding a newborn baby whose mother would never come home.

He had wanted someone to tell him what to do.

And Victor had been there.

Always there.

Ruby began moving toward her mother.

Dominic took one instinctive step after her.

"Ruby. Wait."

Sophie grabbed the back of his jacket.

"Daddy?"

He caught her hand immediately.

He would never leave Sophie standing alone on a crowded sidewalk, not even now.

But his eyes remained on the approaching woman.

She was close enough for him to see the frayed cuffs of her beige coat.

Close enough to notice that she walked with a slight limp.

Close enough to see her stop abruptly when she realized who was standing beside her daughter.

The paper bag slipped from her fingers.

An orange rolled across the pavement.

Then another.

The woman did not bend to retrieve them.

She simply stared.

At Sophie.

At Dominic.

At the two children standing side by side.

Dominic knew those eyes.

He had seen them angry.

He had seen them laughing.

He had seen them fill with tears when Ava told him she was pregnant.

He had seen them close beneath his lips on their wedding day.

But he had never seen them look at him with such absolute terror.

"Ava?"

The name came out as a broken whisper.

The woman recoiled.

Ruby hurried to her and grabbed her hand.

"Mommy, look! I found a girl who looks just like me!"

Ava's expression shattered.

Her gaze moved to Sophie.

For a second, every defensive wall on her face disappeared.

Her mouth trembled.

She looked as though someone had reached inside her chest and touched a wound that had never healed.

"Sophie," she breathed.

Dominic heard it.

Not a question.

Not a guess.

Recognition.

Ava knew his daughter.

She knew her name.

She knew exactly who she was.

Sophie looked up, confused.

"Do you know me?"

Ava made a small, strangled sound.

She raised one hand, then pulled it back before touching Sophie.

Dominic stepped closer.

"You're alive."

Ava's expression hardened instantly.

"Don't come near us."

The words struck harder than any physical blow.

Dominic stopped.

"Ava, what happened?"

"Stay away from my daughter."

"Your daughter?"

She pulled Ruby closer.

Dominic stared at her.

Then at the girls.

A realization began forming, something so terrible and so wonderful that he was afraid to give it a name.

"Ruby is…" His voice failed. "Ava, is Ruby ours?"

Ava's eyes filled.

"Don't."

"Tell me."

"Not here."

"Please."

The woman he had buried five years earlier looked straight at him.

"Your uncle said that if I ever tried to see Sophie again, he would kill her."

The crowded sidewalk seemed to fall away.

Dominic's entire body went rigid.

"What?"

Ava glanced around nervously.

"Dominic, you need to understand something. If Victor knows we've seen each other, neither child is safe."

Victor.

His father's younger brother.

The man who had helped raise him.

The man who had held Sophie at her christening.

The man who called every Sunday to ask whether she was eating enough vegetables.

Dominic felt sickness rise in his throat.

"No," he whispered.

Ava laughed once, a hollow sound without humor.

"That's what I said too."

She pulled Ruby toward her.

"We have to go."

Dominic moved to block the path, then immediately stepped aside when Ruby shrank against her mother's leg.

He would not frighten the child.

Not even to keep her from disappearing.

"Ava, listen to me. I thought you were dead."

Her expression flickered.

Only for an instant.

Then she shook her head.

"He told me you ordered it."

Dominic stared.

"Ordered what?"

"The fire."

His blood turned cold.

Ava's voice fell to a whisper.

"He told me you wanted me gone. And that you had chosen which daughter deserved to live with you."

Sophie pressed closer to Dominic.

Ruby buried her face against Ava's coat.

For five years, Dominic had believed himself a widower raising the sole surviving child of his marriage.

For five years, Ava had apparently believed her husband betrayed her and abandoned their other daughter.

And between them stood two little girls who had spent their entire lives separated by a lie.

Dominic wanted to shout.

He wanted to call Victor and demand answers.

He wanted to tear apart every document associated with the night his family had been destroyed.

Instead, he looked down at Sophie.

She was staring at Ruby.

"Does that mean…" Sophie began.

Her voice became very small.

"Daddy, does that mean she's my sister?"

Ava closed her eyes.

Dominic felt something inside him break.

He looked at the woman he had never stopped loving.

Then at the little girl holding the blackbird necklace.

And finally at Sophie, whose hand was trembling inside his.

"Yes, sweetheart," he whispered.

"I think she is."

Sophie began to cry.

Not loudly.

Not dramatically.

Just two silent tears slipping down her cheeks.

Ruby watched her with enormous gray eyes.

"Why are you sad?" Ruby asked.

Sophie shook her head.

"I don't know."

Then she reached for Ruby's hand.

Ruby looked at her mother.

Ava hesitated.

And in that tiny hesitation, Dominic saw what the years had done to her.

She was thin.

Exhausted.

Her beautiful face carried shadows that had not existed before.

She wore cheap shoes and a coat that had been carefully repaired at one elbow.

This was the woman who once laughed in the passenger seat of his car while arguing about which music to play.

The woman who insisted on helping at a homeless shelter every Christmas.

The woman who had once told him that wealth meant nothing if people were afraid of the person holding it.

And now she looked as though she had spent five years running from the very world he controlled.

Gabriel appeared discreetly near Dominic's shoulder.

"Boss," he murmured.

Dominic did not look away from Ava.

"Not now."

"Sir. You need to see something."

Gabriel's voice contained an unfamiliar tension.

Dominic turned.

His security chief held out his phone.

On the screen was a photograph taken less than a minute earlier.

It showed Sophie kneeling beside Ruby.

Dominic crouching behind them.

And Ava approaching in her beige coat.

The photograph had come from a number Gabriel recognized as belonging to Victor Moretti's private office.

Beneath it were six words.

YOU SHOULD HAVE LEFT THE DEAD BURIED.

Dominic stared at the message.

Then he slowly raised his eyes toward the crowded sidewalk.

Somewhere among the tourists, shoppers, and passing cars, someone had been watching.

Someone who knew.

Someone who had already reported what happened.

Dominic moved closer to Ava, carefully keeping his voice low.

"Take Ruby's hand."

Ava stiffened.

"Why?"

"Because my uncle knows we're here."

All the color drained from her face.

Dominic looked at the two identical little girls.

For the first time in his life, he understood a truth no enemy had ever taught him.

Losing his power did not frighten him.

Losing his money did not frighten him.

Even dying did not frighten him.

But someone had stolen five years from his daughters.

And now that someone knew the girls had found each other.

Dominic slipped his phone into his pocket and reached for Sophie's hand.

"Gabriel," he said quietly, "get the car."

Then he looked at Ava.

"I don't expect you to trust me."

Her eyes filled again.

"Good."

"But whatever you believe about me, I swear on both our daughters' lives that I never ordered that fire."

Ava stared at him.

Behind her fear, something uncertain appeared.

Something dangerously close to hope.

Dominic leaned nearer.

"And if Victor wants to separate our children again, he'll have to go through the truth he's been hiding for five years."

Across the street, a black sedan eased away from the curb.

Gabriel noticed it.

So did Dominic.

Its rear window was tinted.

Its license plate was obscured by a dirty plastic cover.

And just before it disappeared into traffic, Dominic saw a familiar figure in the passenger seat.

A man who had attended Sophie's fifth birthday party.

A man Dominic had trusted with the keys to his home.

The man turned his face away.

Too late.

Dominic recognized him.

And he understood that Victor's betrayal had already reached much closer to his daughters than he could have imagined.

More posts