Chapter 2: The Woman Who Was Supposed to Be Dead

Written by

in

Reading settings

Dominic Moretti had spent fifteen years learning how to escape an ambush.

He knew how to identify surveillance vehicles, which intersections offered multiple exits, and how quickly a crowded Chicago street could turn into a dangerous place.

But no training had prepared him for helping his supposedly dead wife and his two daughters into the same car.

Ava refused to move at first.

Her eyes darted between the black vehicle waiting at the curb and Gabriel Torres, who had positioned himself near its open rear door.

"I'm not getting into a car with your men."

Dominic nodded.

"Then we won't use that car."

Gabriel looked at him in surprise.

"Boss—"

"Find another way."

Ava tightened her grip on Ruby's hand.

"You're doing that thing again."

"What thing?"

"Giving orders and expecting everyone to obey."

Dominic looked at her.

She was trembling, although she clearly hated allowing him to see it.

"Then tell me what you need."

The question seemed to catch her off guard.

For several seconds, she said nothing.

Finally, she glanced toward the street.

"I need somewhere public. Somewhere with cameras. Somewhere your uncle doesn't control."

Dominic considered his options.

The restaurants he owned were unsuitable.

His hotels were worse.

Victor had access to most of the buildings connected to the Moretti organization.

Then Dominic remembered a small family-owned café in River North.

The proprietor, Mrs. Kowalski, had known him since he was nineteen. She had never accepted his offers to buy the property, and she had once threatened to chase him out with a broom if he brought trouble through her front door.

"There's a café three blocks away," Dominic said. "The owner doesn't like me."

Ava gave him a skeptical look.

"That narrows it down."

Despite everything, he almost smiled.

"She likes Sophie."

"That doesn't surprise me."

He pointed toward the street.

"We can walk. Gabriel will stay behind us. Nobody touches either child."

Ava studied him.

Then Sophie reached toward Ruby.

"Can we hold hands?"

Ruby looked up at her mother.

"Please?"

Ava's expression softened painfully.

"All right."

The two little girls clasped hands.

Dominic watched their matching fingers intertwine, and the sight made him feel as though someone had reached back through time and changed the entire meaning of his life.

Five years.

He had missed five years of Ruby's birthdays.

Five years of first words and first steps.

Five years of bedtime stories.

Had she been afraid of the dark?

Had she ever asked why other children had fathers?

Had she spent birthdays wondering about the family she did not know existed?

He wanted to ask a thousand questions.

He knew better than to ask them now.

They began walking.

Gabriel followed at a discreet distance, speaking quietly into his phone.

Dominic kept himself between the girls and the traffic.

Ava noticed.

She also noticed the way he checked reflections in storefront windows.

"Still looking for enemies everywhere?" she murmured.

"Today I have a reason."

"You always had a reason."

He did not argue.

That was one of the things he remembered about Ava.

She had never been impressed by his power.

When they first met, she had been a twenty-four-year-old social worker organizing temporary housing for women leaving dangerous relationships.

He had arrived at a charity event wearing an expensive suit and accompanied by men who frightened everyone else in the room.

Ava had approached him and asked why a millionaire could afford a watch worth forty thousand dollars but had donated only five thousand to a shelter facing closure.

Nobody had ever spoken to him that way.

He doubled the donation.

She returned the check.

"I don't want money you expect to buy my silence with," she told him.

That night, Dominic went home and could not stop thinking about her.

Six months later, he was in love.

A year afterward, they were married.

And for the first time since his childhood, he had believed there might be a way out of the life his family had built around him.

Then Sophie was born.

Or so he had believed.

Now there was Ruby.

A second daughter.

A second life.

A second chance that someone had deliberately hidden.

They reached the café without incident.

Mrs. Kowalski was wiping down a table when they entered.

She looked up and frowned.

"Dominic Moretti. If you're here to buy my building again, the answer is still no."

"Good afternoon to you too, Mrs. K."

Then she saw Sophie.

"My little princess!"

Sophie rushed forward and hugged her.

But Mrs. Kowalski stopped smiling when Ruby entered behind Ava.

She stared at one child.

Then the other.

She removed her glasses, wiped them with her apron, and put them back on.

"Well," she said slowly. "That's something you don't see every day."

Dominic glanced toward the rear dining room.

"Could we use your private table?"

The elderly woman studied Ava's pale face, Ruby's worn dress, and Gabriel's watchful posture near the entrance.

Her expression changed.

"Of course."

She led them to a quiet area behind the kitchen, where a wooden booth overlooked a small enclosed courtyard.

"Hot chocolate for the girls?"

"Yes, please," Sophie answered.

Ruby immediately whispered, "If it doesn't cost too much."

Mrs. Kowalski went still.

Dominic felt the words strike him in the chest.

Ava looked down.

"We can pay," she said quickly.

The older woman gently touched Ruby's shoulder.

"Sweetheart, in this café, hot chocolate is free for children with beautiful manners."

Ruby's entire face brightened.

"Thank you."

Mrs. Kowalski disappeared into the kitchen.

For a moment, nobody spoke.

Sophie and Ruby sat beside each other, studying their reflections in the dark glass of the window.

Dominic sat opposite Ava.

Up close, the changes in her appearance were even more painful.

There was a faint scar beneath her jaw.

A small burn mark near her wrist.

And an exhaustion in her eyes that sleep alone would never cure.

He remembered a time when she would fall asleep reading in bed, leaving the lamp on because she always insisted she was about to finish one more chapter.

He remembered carrying her shoes when her feet hurt.

He remembered her laughter when he burned pancakes trying to make breakfast on their first anniversary.

He remembered every ordinary moment he had thought was gone forever.

"Ava," he began.

"Don't look at me like that."

"Like what?"

"Like you're seeing a ghost."

He lowered his eyes.

"For five years, I thought you were one."

She looked toward the girls.

"Well, ghosts don't have to worry about rent."

Dominic felt the cruelty of the comparison.

His daughter Sophie lived in a mansion surrounded by gardens.

Ruby had been taught to worry about the price of hot chocolate.

He leaned forward.

"Tell me what happened."

Ava remained silent for a long time.

Then she reached into her handbag and took out an old photograph.

She placed it on the table.

It showed two newborn babies lying beside each other beneath pale hospital blankets.

Both wore identification bands.

One band read BABY A.

The other read BABY B.

Dominic stared.

"The doctors told me there were complications," he whispered.

"There were."

"They told me the second baby died."

"She didn't."

Ava's voice broke.

"Both our daughters were alive when I last saw them together."

Dominic picked up the photograph.

His hands were shaking.

He had not held a gun with trembling hands since he was fourteen years old.

But now he could barely keep the picture steady.

"I never saw this."

"I know."

"Why didn't you send it?"

Ava's eyes flashed.

"Where? To the husband I was told had arranged to have me killed?"

He looked up.

"Who told you that?"

"Victor."

The name settled between them like something poisonous.

Ava drew a careful breath.

"After the delivery, a nurse told me the babies needed observation. I was weak, Dominic. I'd lost blood. I couldn't stand. But I heard both girls crying."

She paused, looking toward Ruby.

"I remember that sound. Two different cries. One loud and furious. One smaller, almost like a kitten."

Sophie looked up.

"Which one was me?"

Ava's face crumpled.

"The loud one."

Ruby giggled.

"That sounds like Sophie."

For a moment, Sophie looked proud.

Then Ava continued.

"Victor came to my room after you left. He said there had been trouble at one of your businesses. He told me you were dealing with something dangerous and that he would arrange a safe transfer."

Dominic remembered the call.

An emergency at a warehouse near the river.

A false report of a security breach.

Victor had insisted that Dominic needed to handle it personally.

He had gone.

He had left his wife and daughters behind.

Ava's fingers tightened around her coffee cup.

"They put me in an ambulance. Ruby was in a transport bassinet. I kept asking about Sophie, but they told me she was going in a second vehicle."

"She never did," Dominic said.

"I know that now."

Ava swallowed.

"Twenty minutes later, the ambulance pulled off the road. There was a man waiting near an industrial lot. The driver stopped. I heard them arguing."

She looked at Dominic.

"Someone said there couldn't be witnesses."

Dominic felt a familiar, terrible coldness.

"What happened next?"

"A nurse opened the rear door and told me to get out."

"Who?"

"Cora Bell."

Dominic searched his memory.

The name meant nothing to him.

"She carried Ruby. I could barely walk. We went through a service gate and hid behind an old maintenance building."

Ava closed her eyes.

"Then I heard the explosion."

For several seconds, the only sound was the soft clinking of dishes from the kitchen.

"I thought Sophie was in that ambulance," Ava whispered. "I thought both my babies were gone until Cora told me she had Ruby."

Dominic looked at the photograph again.

"What did Victor tell you?"

"That you had discovered evidence I was collecting about his businesses. He said you knew I was planning to expose the family and that you had decided to get rid of me."

Dominic's stomach turned.

"And you believed him?"

Ava stared at him.

"I heard the ambulance explode, Dominic."

He looked away.

"And then he showed me a document with your signature."

"What document?"

"An authorization to remove me from the hospital. A statement that Sophie would remain under Moretti protection. And a handwritten note ordering that the situation be handled permanently."

Dominic shook his head.

"I never signed anything like that."

"Your signature was on it."

"Then it was forged."

"Maybe."

The uncertainty hurt more than an accusation.

Ava had once trusted him with her entire heart.

Now she could barely trust the words coming out of his mouth.

Mrs. Kowalski arrived with hot chocolate and warm cinnamon rolls.

The girls immediately became absorbed in their treats.

Ruby carefully broke her roll in half.

She placed one piece on a napkin.

Sophie watched.

"Why are you saving that?"

"For Mommy."

Ava's eyes filled.

"Ruby, you eat it."

"But you haven't had lunch."

Dominic looked at Ava.

She smiled too quickly.

"I'm fine, sweetheart."

He knew that smile.

She used to wear it when she was exhausted but did not want anybody worrying about her.

He gestured toward Mrs. Kowalski.

"Could you bring us some sandwiches?"

Ava opened her mouth.

Dominic held up one hand.

"Please. Not as an order. As a request."

Mrs. Kowalski nodded and left.

Ruby glanced between the adults.

"Mommy, is he Sophie's daddy?"

Ava went still.

"Yes, honey."

Ruby considered that.

"Does Sophie live with him?"

"Yes."

"Does he read bedtime stories?"

Dominic felt his throat tighten.

"Every night I can."

Ruby nodded thoughtfully.

"My mommy reads to me too. Even when she's tired."

He looked at Ava.

"I bet she does."

Ruby hugged her rabbit.

"Sometimes she falls asleep before the princess gets home."

Sophie leaned closer.

"My daddy falls asleep during stories too."

"I do not," Dominic said.

Sophie gave him an offended look.

"You snored during the dragon story."

Ruby burst into laughter.

It was the same laugh Sophie had.

Dominic looked down because he could not bear to see the girls without thinking about everything he had lost.

Ava watched him for a long moment.

Then she said quietly, "You really didn't know."

He lifted his head.

"No."

"About Ruby."

"No."

"And you didn't know I was alive?"

"Ava, I visited your grave every Sunday for nearly two years."

Something changed in her expression.

She looked at the table.

He continued before he could stop himself.

"I brought flowers on your birthday. I brought Sophie's drawings. On our anniversary, I sat there until midnight because I didn't know where else to go."

Ava covered her mouth.

"I thought…" she whispered.

"What?"

"I thought you had chosen her."

Dominic looked at Sophie.

Then Ruby.

A wave of fury rose inside him, directed not at Ava but at the man who had made a mother believe her husband could choose one twin over the other.

"There is no world," he said slowly, "in which I would choose one of our daughters and throw the other away."

Ava wiped her eyes.

"I wanted to believe that."

"Why didn't you come back?"

Her face hardened.

"Because Victor showed me Sophie."

Dominic stopped breathing.

"He sent photographs. Every year. Sophie at the park. Sophie going into school. Sophie on her birthday."

She leaned forward.

"And every photograph came with a warning. If I tried to contact you, if I told anyone what happened, if I approached Sophie, he would make sure I lost Ruby too."

Dominic stared at her.

"He was watching my daughter."

"He was controlling us through both girls."

She reached into her bag again.

This time she removed a folded piece of paper.

A photograph was attached.

Sophie, three years old, standing in the garden of the Moretti estate, holding a yellow balloon.

On the back, someone had written:

ONE DAUGHTER IS BETTER THAN NONE.

Dominic's vision blurred with rage.

He recognized the photograph.

It had been taken at a private family party.

Only relatives and trusted employees had attended.

Victor had been there.

He had given Sophie the balloon.

Dominic slowly placed the photograph on the table.

"We're not going to my house."

Ava frowned.

"Why?"

"Because my house isn't safe."

"That's the first sensible thing you've said."

Gabriel appeared at the doorway.

"Dominic. Victor has called four times."

"Let him call."

"He's asking why Sophie isn't home."

Dominic's jaw tightened.

"Tell him she's spending the afternoon with her father."

Gabriel hesitated.

"There's something else."

He showed Dominic a security-camera image.

The black sedan from Michigan Avenue had stopped outside the café.

Its occupants were sitting inside.

Waiting.

Ava saw the picture.

Her face went white.

"That's him."

"Who?"

She pointed at the passenger.

"He came to our apartment last winter."

Dominic recognized the man.

Ethan Doyle.

One of his own security officers.

The same man he had seen disappearing into traffic.

"He told me he was from the housing department," Ava whispered. "He asked about Ruby. He knew her birthday."

Dominic felt his stomach sink.

Ethan had spent three years guarding the Moretti residence.

He knew Sophie's school schedule.

He knew which doors were alarmed.

He knew where Dominic kept the emergency keys.

And until ten minutes ago, Dominic had considered him trustworthy.

Gabriel looked grim.

"I can have our people intercept them."

"No."

Dominic surprised himself with the answer.

Violence was the language his world had always used to solve problems.

Ava had spent five years suffering because of that world.

He would not make the girls witness another moment of it.

"Call Detective Hannah Brooks," Dominic said. "The one who helped with the school threat last year. Tell her we have reason to believe two children are being followed."

Gabriel nodded.

Ava stared at Dominic.

"You're calling the police?"

"Yes."

"Your family hates the police."

"My family has become a problem."

He looked at her.

"I need to start doing things differently."

For the first time, Ava did not immediately look away.

Mrs. Kowalski brought the sandwiches.

She had noticed the tension but asked no questions.

Instead, she placed a little paper crown beside each girl's plate.

"Two princesses," she said.

Sophie immediately put hers on.

Ruby hesitated.

"Can I keep it?"

"Of course."

"Even if it gets wrinkled?"

"Especially then."

Ruby carefully placed the crown on her head.

Sophie reached across the table and adjusted it.

"There. Now we match."

Dominic watched them.

Two little girls.

One in ivory lace.

One in faded red cotton.

One who had never worried about being safe at home.

One who had learned to measure every word she spoke around strangers.

And yet when they smiled, they were impossible to tell apart.

He made himself a promise.

If it took every dollar, every connection, and every ounce of power he possessed, they would never be separated again.

But he would not buy their safety with more lies.

He would find the truth.

Even if it destroyed him.

An hour later, Gabriel arranged for them to leave through the café's rear courtyard.

Detective Brooks had confirmed that officers could check the suspicious vehicle. The sedan drove away before they arrived, but its registration and surveillance images were preserved.

Dominic offered Ava the use of a small townhouse belonging to his attorney, Claire Bennett.

Claire had represented his legitimate businesses for years and had no ties to Victor.

Ava initially refused.

Then Ruby yawned.

Sophie leaned against her sister.

Both girls were exhausted.

Ava looked at them and finally nodded.

"One night," she said.

"One night," Dominic agreed.

The townhouse stood on a quiet, tree-lined street.

Claire met them personally.

She was a practical woman in her forties with sharp eyes and a habit of asking uncomfortable questions.

When Dominic explained that Ava was alive and Ruby might be Sophie's twin, Claire did not react with disbelief.

Instead, she asked for the photograph of the newborns.

She studied the hospital bands.

Then she looked at Dominic.

"I need every medical document you received after the delivery."

Dominic called Gabriel.

Within an hour, a sealed archive box arrived from his private office.

Dominic had not opened it in years.

Inside were hospital reports, insurance papers, death certificates, and the documents Victor had handed him after the fire.

Claire spread them across the dining table.

Ava watched from across the room.

The girls had fallen asleep on the couch, sharing a blanket.

Their matching faces rested inches apart.

For a while, Claire worked silently.

Then she stopped.

She held one document beneath the lamp.

"Dominic."

He looked up.

"What?"

"This is Sophie's original neonatal discharge summary."

"I know."

"According to this, Ava delivered one baby."

Dominic frowned.

"They told me the second child died."

"That's the problem."

Claire pointed to the report.

"There is no reference to a second birth. No neonatal death certificate. No delivery notes for another infant. No mention of twins."

Ava moved closer.

"But I delivered two babies."

"We have your photograph," Claire said. "And we'll pursue the original records."

She turned another page.

"There's something worse."

Dominic felt cold.

"What?"

Claire held up the final discharge authorization.

"This form lists Ava Moretti as the person who personally signed Sophie into your custody."

Dominic looked at the date.

It was six weeks after the ambulance explosion.

Six weeks after the day Ava was officially declared dead.

"That's impossible."

Claire nodded.

"Exactly."

Ava stared at the signature.

Then she began shaking.

"That's not my handwriting."

Claire studied the page.

"I believe you."

Dominic looked at the medical center's official seal.

Then the physician's name.

Then the signature.

Someone had not simply lied about what happened.

Someone had fabricated the paper trail of his daughters' lives.

And the documents had passed through multiple professional offices without a single person raising an objection.

Claire opened her laptop.

"I want to check who submitted this form."

A few minutes later, she found the name of the legal representative who had filed the paperwork.

She stopped typing.

Dominic watched her expression.

"Claire?"

She slowly turned the screen toward him.

The documents had been submitted by an attorney working for Moretti Family Holdings.

The authorization listed one supervising director.

Victor Moretti.

But beneath Victor's name was a second signature.

A witness.

Someone Dominic knew.

Someone who had been present in the delivery room on the morning the twins were born.

A woman who had held Sophie in her arms while he cried with relief.

Dominic stared at the name.

"That can't be right."

Claire looked at him.

"Do you know her?"

He swallowed.

"She was our family doctor."

Ava approached the table.

When she saw the signature, the color drained from her face.

"No," she whispered.

Dominic looked at her.

"Ava?"

She covered her mouth.

"That's the woman who told me Sophie was dead."

And in that moment, Dominic understood that Victor had not worked alone.

The conspiracy had reached into the room where his daughters had taken their first breaths.

Worse, the doctor who had supposedly cared for his family was still practicing medicine.

And Sophie had an appointment with her the following morning.

More posts