Chapter 4: Following Her Ghost

Written by

in

Reading settings

The town was called Greyhook, which it had no business being, since it was the gentlest place I have ever been — a fishing town on the Maine coast with one inn, one diner, one pharmacy, and a harbor full of boats named after women. Emily had chosen it the way a deer chooses a thicket: water on one side, quiet on the other, and nobody in it who had ever heard the name Ethan Carter spoken in fear.

I checked into the inn under my own name. It took the town approximately one hour to know everything about me that mattered, which in Greyhook meant three things: that I was rich, that I was looking for the woman in the Halloran cottage, and that I had not come with an army. Mrs. Abernathy at the inn — seventy-nine, eyes like a customs officer — poured my coffee the first morning and said, "We've got a way of doing things here. Whatever you're owed, you're not owed it in a way that frightens her. We clear on that, Mr. Carter?"

"We're clear," I said, and meant it, and understood that I had just been given the laws of the only country that mattered.

So I learned her life the way she had once learned mine: from the outside, patiently, by what it cost her to live it. The cottage at the end of Salt Lane, cedar-shingled, with a garden she had planted herself — tomatoes staked in rows, marigolds along the path, everything tended with the ferocious competence she used to bring to my survival. She worked three mornings a week at the bakery on Harbor Street, where the owner, a widower named Tomaszek who had come from Gdansk in 1982, paid her in cash and gossip and pretended not to know she was hiding. She walked the shore path every evening at six with a shawl over her shoulders, down to the point and back, always at the pace of a woman walking with someone invisible.

She had cut her hair. That was the first thing that undid me, standing across the harbor with a fisherman's binoculars I had bought off a boy for two hundred dollars. Emily's hair had been her vanity — the one she admitted to — long and dark and heavy, and I had a hundred memories of it spread across pillows and my own chest. It was short now, above her shoulders, practical, a stranger's haircut. She looked thinner. She looked older and younger at once, the way people do when they stop performing for an audience. She looked, I wrote in the notebook I had started keeping like a penitent, like the woman she'd have been if she'd never met me.

The notebook. I should explain the notebook, because it became the second diary in this story, and Emily would one day read it and weep in a way that finished something in both of us. I had started it on the train north — a plain school notebook, bought at a station kiosk by a man who owned nineteen casinos — and in it I wrote the things I learned about my wife, in the order I learned them, which was the order of a stranger's education and not a husband's knowledge. That she took her tea with honey and never sugar. That she was afraid of deep water — had been since childhood, a lake, a cousin's hands — and walked the shore path anyway, every evening, at the edge of the thing she feared, which I wrote down and then sat looking at for a long time. That she had wanted, at seventeen, to teach. That she hummed when she gardened, unconsciously, songs from a radio station that no longer existed. That she had kept, all along, a whole woman in reserve behind the one who managed my house and my wars, and that the reserve woman was the real one, and I had been married to the understudy of my own wife for thirteen years without once asking who was waiting in the wings.

An old fisherman named Cap mended nets on the harbor wall in the mornings, and on the third day he watched me watching the point and said, without looking up from his twine, "You're the husband."

It wasn't a question. Greyhook had held its referendum.

"I'm the husband," I said.

"I had one of those marriages," Cap said. "Forty-one years. She left me once, in seventy-nine, over a boat I bought instead of a roof. Went to her sister's in Portland for four months." His hands never stopped. "Everybody I knew said go get her. Drag her home. A man's got rights, they said. My father — a harder man than you, son, and I've seen your picture in a newspaper — my father said: you don't get her back. Getting's not a thing love does. You go and you be around, where she can see what you're made of now, and you let her do the arithmetic. She might not come back. The arithmetic might not save you. But it's the only sum there is."

"Did she come back?"

"She's the one makes my lunch." He nodded toward the harbor, where a woman in yellow boots was sorting crates with the authority of a harbor master. "Four months I mended nets on her sister's street like a stray dog with a trade. Worth it. I'd do the winter twice." He squinted at me, at the coat that cost more than his boat, at the whole traveling circus of my former life folded into one man on a harbor wall. "You'll want to fix it fast. Men like you fix things fast — that's the whole talent. This don't fix fast, son. This fixes at the speed of a woman deciding, and that clock doesn't have your name on it."

I wrote that down too. Word for word, in the school notebook, while the gulls screamed over the fish guts: This fixes at the speed of a woman deciding.

Once, on the second day, I went into the bakery. I had told myself it was for bread, which was a lie of the old kind, the small administrative kind that paves the road to the big ones. She was behind the counter with her sleeves pushed up, laughing at something Tomaszek had said — laughing with her whole face, head back, unguarded, a laugh I had not heard in my own house in over a year because my house was where it went to be careful. She looked up and the laugh stopped the way a song stops when a door closes. Not fear. Just: the territory of joy reclassifying itself in her face, the border guards coming back on duty. She weighed my bread with perfect courtesy, made my change with perfect courtesy, and said, "Thank you, sir," with a courtesy so complete it was a locked gate, and I understood that Emily Carter could exile a man in a room he was standing in. I ate the bread on the harbor wall and I wrote in the notebook: She laughs there. Whatever you do here, do not make the laughing stop. It is the whole crop. Tend everything else second.

The marigolds along the cottage path were hers, by the way — not the town's, not the cottage's previous tenant's. Hers, from seed. I knew the variety because she had grown it for years along our own garden wall in the city, a gaudy orange strain she defended against our landscaper like a lawyer. She had carried seed out of our house in her exile, in a paper envelope, in the middle of the worst month of her life, between the passport and the china. A woman fleeing for her life and her child's, who stopped to take marigold seed. I sat with that fact for an entire evening. Men have built theologies on less. She had left me, and she had taken the garden. Both of those were the whole story, I think. Both of them were her, entirely.

I did not approach her. That was the discipline, and it cost me more than the war with the Blakes, more than the casinos I was neglecting, more than any night of my criminal life. Every evening at six I stood at the far end of the shore path in the tree line and I watched my wife walk out of my reach and back into it, and I rehearsed a hundred speeches and burned them all, because every one of them began with what I wanted, and I had finally understood that this was the entire crime.

On the fourth day, Mrs. Abernathy's niece — who cleaned at the clinic, and who charged me fifty dollars and a promise for the information, both of which I paid gladly — told me the thing that stopped my heart in the inn's little dining room, with the rain coming down the windows in grey ropes.

"The lady in the Halloran cottage," she said. "She's under the midwife's care. Present tense, Mr. Carter. She has appointments. Standing ones. Tuesdays."

I sat very still. "The midwife is for—"

"For women who are expecting, yes, sir. That's the whole of a midwife." She looked at me with the pity of the very young. "You didn't know that either, did you."

I went up to my room and I did the arithmetic on the inn's stationery, three times, with a hand I had to keep flattening against the paper. Eleven weeks, in the letter. Day 327. Then the weeks of preparation. Then the weeks of my search and my war and my slow education. If there had been — if the thing Dr. Patel said, about the hand that stayed flat on her stomach all night, holding something down that she didn't want the wind to take — if Madison's cruelty had been a compass after all — ask her why she cries like it's good news —

Twins. The word arrived in my mind not as a word but as a door. Twins lose one of their number in the womb more often than the world admits; it has a name like a poem, vanishing twin, and the other goes on, small and sole and fighting, and the mother goes on carrying both the grief and the life in the same body, at the same time, in the same hand's span.

Emily hadn't lost our baby. Emily had lost one of our babies — and she had carried the other out of my house and my war and my fourteen months of betrayal, alone, at 2:47 in the morning, to a town named after nothing, to keep it alive.

I want to confess one thing about that fourth day, because a record is a record. At five in the morning, before the arithmetic, before the midwife's niece and her fifty dollars' worth of thunder — I packed. The war was curdling without me; Vince had called twice; a Blake crew had been seen photographing one of my casinos; and I stood in the inn's little room with my bag in my hand telling myself the respectable lie: that staying was selfish, that she had asked not to be looked for, that a man who loved her would honor the letter of her letter. I got as far as the car. I sat in it with the engine running and the heater blowing and Greyhook asleep around me, and I understood, with the clarity that only ever visits men at the bottom of their worst decisions, that I was doing it again. I was choosing the empire's emergency over Emily's emergency, at a better hour, in nicer language, with a speech about respect. Fourteen months of beach houses had begun exactly this way: with me in a car, early, telling myself a story in which leaving her was a form of duty.

I turned the engine off. I carried the bag back upstairs. I wrote in the notebook: He almost left again on the fourth day. Remember that he almost left again on the fourth day. Let it stand next to the other facts. Let it not be edited.

That evening at six I stood in the tree line with my notebook forgotten in my pocket and my heart making a noise I could hear. She came down the path at her unhurried pace, shawl over her shoulders, one hand — I saw it now, I saw what I had been looking at for four days without seeing — one hand held low and flat against her body beneath the shawl, holding something down that she didn't want the wind to take. At the turn of the point she stopped, as she always stopped, and looked out at the water. And the wind came off the harbor and took the shawl and pressed her dress to her body for one second, two seconds —

— and my wife, my vanished wife, Emily Carter, who had lost a baby in a hospital while I laughed in another woman's house, stood in profile against the evening light seven months pregnant, and the whole world narrowed to the curve of her and the hand that had never once, in all those months, let go.

More posts