The car ride home from the mall was the longest silence of my life, and I had lived through six months of them.
Julian sat beside me in the back of the black sedan, his jaw set, his hands flat on his knees, staring out the window at the city he owned. Daniel had followed us in his rental car, because Julian had insisted — not asked, insisted — that my brother come to the house for dinner. Not because Julian wanted to meet him. Because Julian wanted to look at him across a table and decide whether the man was a threat.
"Say something," I said, when we had been driving for ten minutes without a word.
"There is nothing to say," Julian said.
"There is everything to say. You nearly killed my brother in a food court."
"I did not nearly kill anyone."
"You threw a man across the room at a gala for staring at me. You knocked out two millionaires. What were you planning to do to Daniel?"
Julian turned his head then, slowly, and looked at me. His dark eyes were flat and unreadable, the way they always were when he was deciding something.
"I was planning," he said, "to find out who he was."
"And now you know."
"Now I know that my wife has a brother I have never heard of. Now I know that in six months of marriage, you never once mentioned him. Now I know that I am the only man in Chicago who did not know."
The words landed like stones. I wanted to tell him that he had never asked. I wanted to tell him that in six months he had never once asked me a single question about my life, my family, my past, my anything. I wanted to tell him that the reason he did not know about Daniel was that he had told me, on our wedding night, that he did not expect conversation.
But I did not say any of that. I was twenty-six years old, and I had learned, in six months of marriage to a dangerous man, that there were moments to speak and moments to survive. So I folded my hands in my lap and watched the city go past the window, and I thought about the last time I had seen Daniel in person.
It had been two years ago, at O'Hare, the morning he left for London. He had hugged me so hard my ribs hurt, and he had said, "Write to me, Audrey. Every week. I mean it. If he is a monster, write the word 'seagull' in your letter and I will come home and break his legs."
I had laughed then, because Daniel always made me laugh, and because I had not yet understood what I was walking into. I had written to him every week for the first six months of my marriage. I had never once written the word "seagull." Not because Julian was kind. Because I did not know what Daniel could do against a man who owned half of Chicago, and because I did not want my brother to die trying to rescue me from a marriage my own father had arranged.
The house on Lake Shore Drive had eleven bedrooms, a library I was not allowed to rearrange, a garden I was not allowed to plant in, and a dining room with a table that could seat twenty-four people. That night, three of us sat at it: Julian at the head, Daniel on his right, me on his left. Mrs. Okafor, the housekeeper, served roast chicken and potatoes and said nothing, but her eyes kept flicking toward me, and I knew she was thinking the same thing I was thinking — that this was the strangest dinner this house had ever seen.
Daniel, to his credit, behaved like a gentleman. He told Julian about the fellowship. He told him about the hospital in London, about the twelve-hour shifts, about the old woman who had baked him a cake when he saved her husband. He told him about our father, about the shipping company, about the summer Daniel was sixteen and nearly sank one of the company's smallest boats by trying to sail it himself.
Julian listened. He did not eat much. He asked exactly two questions all evening.
"Why did you miss the wedding?"
"The fellowship would not release me," Daniel said. "I asked. Twice. They said a wedding was not a medical emergency."
"And why did you come home now?"
Daniel glanced at me. "Because my sister stopped writing to me three weeks ago. And Audrey has written to me every week since she was nineteen years old. So I got on a plane."
The silence after that was worse than the silence in the car. Julian put down his fork. He looked at Daniel. He looked at me. And for the first time in six months of marriage, I saw something in my husband's face that I had never seen before. It was not anger. It was not suspicion. It was something much more dangerous.
It was shame.
"I did not know you had stopped writing," Julian said quietly, to me, not to Daniel.
"You did not know I wrote at all," I said.
He did not argue. He could not. It was true, and we both knew it was true.
After dinner, Daniel went to the guest room — the first guest the house had ever had, as far as I knew — and Julian and I went to our bedroom, and Julian stood by the window for a long time looking out at the lake, and I sat on the edge of the bed and waited, because I had learned that when Julian stood by a window, it meant he was deciding something, and it was better to let him finish deciding.
"What is your favorite color?" he asked, without turning around.
I stared at his back. "What?"
"Your favorite color. What is it?"
"Blue," I said. "The blue of the lake just before a storm."
He nodded, slowly, as if he were writing it down in his head. "Your favorite food?"
"My mother's chicken soup. Daniel makes it now, badly."
"Your best friend?"
"Her name is Priya. She lives in Evanston. We have not spoken in four months because your men told her it would be better if she did not call so often."
Julian turned around then. His face was very still.
"Did they?" he said. "Did my men tell your friend not to call?"
"Marcus Hale told her," I said. "He said it would be better for everyone if my old life stayed old."
Julian was quiet for a long moment. Then he said, "Go to sleep, Audrey. We will talk in the morning."
I went to sleep. Or rather, I lay awake in the dark, listening to a stranger breathe on the other side of a bed the size of a small boat, and I thought about the fact that my husband had just asked me my favorite color for the first time in six months of marriage, and that he had learned the answer the same night he learned that I had a brother.
The next morning, I found a note on the kitchen table, in Julian's handwriting. It said: "Daniel stays as long as he wants. Priya may call whenever she wants. — J."
It was the first note he had ever left me. It was also the first time he had ever signed anything with just the letter J, as if he were a boy writing to a girl, and not a mafia boss writing to his wife.
I stood in the kitchen holding that note for a long time, and Mrs. Okafor came in and looked at it over my shoulder, and she said, "Well. That is new."
"Yes," I said. "That is new."
But new did not mean safe. Because by the time Daniel and I sat down to breakfast that morning, the rumor had already traveled further than any of us understood. The video — the one Marcus Hale had filmed in the food court, the one that showed Julian Sterling grabbing his wife in front of two hundred people and announcing to the world that he did not know her brother — was already on three phones that did not belong to us. And by noon, it would be on thirty. And by evening, it would be in the hands of a man named Vincent Castellano, who had been waiting six months for a weapon exactly like this one.
I did not know that yet. I was still holding a note that said "Daniel stays as long as he wants," and I was still thinking, for the first time in six months, that maybe my husband was not a monster after all. Maybe he was just a man who had never been taught how to know a wife.
It would take me another week to learn how wrong — and how right — I was.
I remembered my first gala as Julian's wife, three weeks after the wedding. I had worn a dress my father's tailor had chosen — dark green, too tight across the shoulders, too long at the hem — and I had stood beside Julian for four hours while men I did not know shook his hand and looked at me the way men look at a painting they are deciding whether to buy. One of them, a man with a diamond ring the size of a marble, had leaned too close and said, "Your wife is beautiful, Sterling. Where did you find her?" And Julian had said, "She was an arrangement," and the man had laughed, and I had stood there smiling, because that was what wives did at galas, and I had thought, I am not a wife. I am an arrangement. I am a signature on a page.
Priya called me the next morning. She had seen the photographs in the newspaper — me in the green dress, standing beside Julian like a vase — and she had said, "Audrey, are you all right? You look like someone took a photograph of a woman and forgot to include the woman." I had laughed, because Priya always made me laugh, and I had said, "I am fine. I am a married woman now. I am fine." And she had said, "You are lying. I have known you since we were fourteen. You are lying." And I had said, "I know. I will call you next week." And I had not called her next week, because Marcus Hale had come to the house that afternoon, smiling his pleasant smile, and he had said, "Mrs. Sterling, it would be better for everyone if your old life stayed old. Your husband has enemies. It is safer if your friends do not call so often." And I had believed him, because I was twenty-six years old and frightened and alone in a house with eleven bedrooms, and I did not know that Marcus Hale was a traitor, and I did not know that his advice was not protection but isolation — the first step in cutting a woman off from everyone who loved her, so that when the time came, there would be no one left to notice what was happening to her.
I thought about that afternoon for a long time, lying awake in the dark after the mall, after the dinner, after the note that said "Priya may call whenever she wants." I thought about the library, the one room I was not allowed to rearrange, with its shelves of books that belonged to Julian's father and his father before him, and the single shelf I had been permitted to fill with my own books — my sketchbooks, my art books, a battered copy of a novel my mother had loved. I thought about the garden I was not allowed to plant, and the kitchen I was not allowed to cook in, and the bedroom I shared with a stranger, and the house that had eleven bedrooms and not one room that felt like mine.
And then I thought about Daniel, asleep in the guest room down the hall — the first guest the house had ever had, as far as I knew — and about the fact that tomorrow morning, I would make him breakfast, and he would tell me about London, and for one morning, the house would feel less like a museum and more like a home. And I thought about Julian, standing by the window in our bedroom, asking me my favorite color, and I thought about the fact that he had asked — finally, after six months, he had asked — and that asking was a kind of beginning, even if it was a small one, even if it was only a note on a kitchen table that said "Daniel stays as long as he wants."
It was not enough. It was not nearly enough. But it was something. And after six months of nothing, something felt like a great deal.
The house had rules, and I learned them the way a person learns the rules of a foreign country — by breaking them, quietly, and watching what happened. The first rule was that the library was Julian's father's library, and it was not to be rearranged. I broke it on my third day, moving three books from a high shelf to a lower one so I could reach them, and Mrs. Okafor found me and said, very gently, "Mrs. Sterling, Mr. Sterling's father was a particular man." I put the books back. The second rule was that the garden was tended by a gardener who came twice a week, and I was not to interfere. I broke it by planting a single pot of basil on the kitchen windowsill, and the gardener, a kind man named Tomas, looked at it and said nothing, but he watered it when I forgot, and I knew he was on my side. The third rule was that dinner was served at seven, in the dining room, and that I was to be dressed for it. I broke it once, coming down in jeans and a sweater, and Julian looked at me across the table and said, "You look comfortable," in a voice that was not a compliment, and I never did it again. Not because he forbade it. Because the look on his face told me that comfort was not something wives were supposed to show at his table, and I was too tired to fight about it.
There were other rules, smaller ones, the kind that accumulate like dust. Do not answer the front door. Do not take calls from numbers you do not recognize. Do not go to the mall alone — although I broke that one the day I met Daniel, because I had wanted, just once, to do something ordinary without six men writing it down. Do not ask about the business. Do not ask about the men. Do not ask where Julian goes at night, or who he meets, or why he sometimes comes home with blood on his cuff and does not explain it.
I followed most of the rules. I followed them because I was afraid, and because I was lonely, and because following rules was easier than fighting a man who owned half of Chicago. But every rule I followed made the house a little colder, and every cold day made me a little smaller, until one Tuesday afternoon in October, I went to the mall to buy a birthday present for a little girl I barely knew, and I laughed for the first time in six weeks, and everything changed.
