Chapter 2: The Man in the Empty House

Written by

in

Reading settings

Alexander Hayes had not slept in his own bed for five years.

He slept, when he slept at all, in the chair in his study, with a glass of whiskey on the desk and the lamp burning low, because the bedroom upstairs was where Elena had braided her hair in the mornings, and where the small white crib had stood in the corner, waiting for a baby who never came home.

The house knew it. The whole mansion knew it. The marble floors were cold. The chandeliers hung like ice. The tall columns held up a roof that sheltered one man, one housekeeper, and a great many ghosts.

He had been twenty-eight when he married Elena Marchetti, a schoolteacher with dark curls and a laugh that could fill a room. She had known exactly who he was — the son of a dock boss, the heir to a family that settled its arguments in back rooms — and she had married him anyway, on one condition: that he never bring his work home. For six years, he kept that promise. The house on the hill was her place. The garden was hers. The kitchen, where she baked bread on Sundays and sang old Italian songs while the dough rose, was hers.

And then, on a rainy night in October, almost exactly five years before the night the girls came, a car had followed Elena home from her sister's house. The men in it had not meant to kill her. They had meant to kill him. They had mistaken her small blue car for his, in the rain and the dark, and they had driven her off the road and into the river.

She had been seven months pregnant.

Alexander had buried his wife and his unborn daughter on the same grey afternoon, in the same grave, under a stone that said only their names. And then he had gone back to the house on the hill, and he had become what the city said he was: the most feared man in Chicago. He ran his family's business with a coldness that frightened even his own men. He stopped going to church. He stopped smiling. He kept his promise to Elena in the only way he still could — he never brought his work home — but home had become an empty place, and he was its only ghost.

Rosa Delgado had been the housekeeper for thirty years, since before Elena, since before Alexander was a man. She was sixty-two now, with grey hair pulled back in a knot and hands that had cooked ten thousand meals in the mansion's kitchen. She was the only person alive who spoke to Alexander Hayes as if he were still a human being.

"You eat like a man who is already dead," she told him on the morning the trouble began, setting a plate of eggs in front of him at the kitchen table. "And you sleep in that chair like a dog. Your mother would be ashamed."

"My mother is dead, Rosa."

"And your wife is dead, and still you punish yourself as if that will bring them back." Rosa poured his coffee, black, the way he always took it. "A house is not a tomb, Alexander. You are forty-one years old. You have a life. Or you could, if you would let yourself have one."

He did not answer. He never answered when she spoke like that. He ate his eggs, drank his coffee, and went out to his car, where his driver was waiting.

His days were made of meetings in rooms with no windows, phone calls in low voices, and decisions that other men were afraid to make. He settled a dispute between two of his captains over a warehouse on the river. He refused, flatly, a proposal to move into the casino business on the South Side — "We do not take children's homes," he said, and his men looked at each other, because it was a strange thing to say, and none of them knew why he said it. He visited the docks, where his father had worked, and stood for a while looking at the water.

And in the evenings, he went to the Meridian Grand.

He had started going there the winter after Elena died, when the silence of the mansion had grown too loud to bear. The dining room was warm, and it was full of people, and nobody asked him for anything. He always took the same corner table by the window, at seven o'clock, and he always ordered the same thing — a plate he rarely finished, and a pot of tea he drank slowly, one cup at a time, until the dining room began to empty and the pianist began to play the last songs of the night. The waiters knew him. The pianist knew him. Nobody bothered him. That was the whole point.

It was the only hour of the day when he did not feel entirely alone — and the loneliest hour of the day, too, because Elena had loved that room, and every chandelier in it reminded him of her.

He came home late, as he always did. Rosa had left his dinner covered on the stove and gone to bed. He ate standing up in the kitchen, the way he always did, and then he went into his study to work through the papers on his desk, because work was the only thing that kept the quiet from closing over him.

That was his life. It had been his life for five years. He expected it to be his life for the rest of it.

He did not know that, on the other side of the city, four small girls in party dresses and tiaras were sitting in a garden, listening to a man in a brown suit threaten the only home they had ever known.

St. Agnes Home for Girls had been founded in 1911 by a nun with a stubborn streak, and it had survived the Depression, the war, and three mayors who wanted its land. Sister Agnes, who had run it for twenty-two years, had survived all of them too, and she had no intention of letting a man in a brown suit frighten her.

But she was frightened. She would not have admitted it to anyone, but that night, after the girls were in bed, she sat in her small office and looked at the notice on her desk — the city's condemnation order, thirty days — and at the guardianship papers, and at the photograph on the wall of the home's first class of girls, and she prayed.

She prayed for the building. She prayed for the children. And she prayed, though she did not know why, for the man in the big house on the hill, whose mother she had known, and whose wife she had once taught in Sunday school.

"Lord," she whispered, "if you are listening, send us someone the bad men are afraid of."

She did not know that her prayer was about to be answered in the most unlikely way possible — by four small girls in wet party dresses, running through the rain on bare feet, carrying nothing but each other, to a hotel dining room where a lonely man ate his dinner alone.

After the girls fled, the night at St. Agnes grew worse before it grew better.

Kane's men searched the house room by room, throwing open doors, looking under beds, shouting the girls' names. Sister Agnes stood in the hallway, small and straight and unafraid, and she told them, in a voice that did not shake, that the children were gone, and that they would not find them here, and that if they laid one hand on any child in her care, she would see them in prison for it.

One of the men laughed at her. The other one raised his hand — and then he saw her face, and the way the other children were watching from the top of the stairs, ten small girls in their nightdresses, holding each other, and something in him, some last scrap of shame, made him lower it again.

They left within the hour, slamming the front door so hard that the broken window rattled in its frame. Sister Agnes locked the door behind them, and she went from room to room, counting the children — ten of them, all safe, all accounted for, all except the four who had run — and then she went to the telephone in her office, and she called the police.

She told them everything: the threats, the condemnation order, the guardianship papers, the men at the door. The officer who came was young, and tired, and he wrote it all down, and he told her, honestly, that a guardianship order signed by a judge was a difficult thing to fight in a single night, and that she should keep the children inside, and lock the doors, and call again if the men returned.

After he left, Sister Agnes sat in her office in the dark, with the telephone in her lap, and she waited. She did not know where the girls were. She did not know whether they had reached the hotel. She did not know whether Mr. Hayes had been at his table, or whether the dining room had been empty, or whether the girls were even now being dragged back to Kane's car.

She sat there until the rain stopped, and the sky began, very slowly, to lighten in the east, and then she got up, and she went into the kitchen, and she made breakfast for ten frightened little girls, and she smiled as if nothing had happened, because that was her job, and she had done it for twenty-two years.

But inside, where no one could see it, she was praying still — praying for four small girls in party dresses, and for a man in a navy suit, sitting alone at a corner table, with a pot of tea going cold beside his plate.

Kane, meanwhile, had not gone home.

He sat in his car outside the Meridian Grand, watching the golden windows, waiting for his men to report. When the telephone rang, and his man told him the girls had slipped away — run, in the rain, barefoot, in the dark — Kane was silent for a long moment. Then he said, very quietly, "Find them. They cannot have gone far. Four little girls, in party dresses, on a night like this. Someone will have seen them."

His men had heard Sister Agnes shout it, as the girls ran — "To the Meridian Grand! Go!" — and they had reported it, and Kane had driven straight to the hotel, and sat in his car outside it, watching the golden windows, thinking.

And Kane, who had built his whole life on the belief that every man had a price, began to wonder, for the first time, what the price of Alexander Hayes might be — and whether he could afford it.

He decided, sitting in his car in the rain, that he would find out. He would go into the dining room himself, with his lawyer and his papers, and he would take what the court had given him. He would walk up to the most feared man in Chicago, in front of a room full of witnesses, and he would tell him that the girls belonged to him now.

It was, Kane thought, a perfectly reasonable plan. The law was on his side. The papers were in order. And Alexander Hayes, whatever his reputation, was only one man, sitting alone at a table, with a cup of tea in his hand.

Kane did not know that Alexander Hayes had spent five years waiting, too — waiting for something he could not name, in a house that had forgotten how to be a home.

And he did not know that, at that very moment, four small girls were hiding under that man's table, holding on to his leg, and whispering the words that would change everything.

That night, in the dormitory at St. Agnes, the ten girls who had stayed behind lay awake long after the lights were out, whispering under the covers while the rain drummed on the roof.

"Do you think they'll be all right?" little Mary whispered — Mary, who had just turned five, whose birthday cake still sat on the kitchen table with five candles no one had blown out. "Gabriella and Harper and Nora and Sophie. Do you think the bad men will find them?"

"They ran to Mr. Hayes," one of the older girls whispered back. "Sister Agnes said so. She said his mother was a good woman. Good mothers raise good sons. That's what she always says."

"But everyone says he's scary," Mary whispered. "The men at the market say he makes people disappear."

"Bad men say scary things about him because they're afraid of him," the older girl said. "That's different. Being afraid of someone and someone being bad are not the same thing. Sister Agnes taught us that. Remember?"

Mary was quiet for a while. Then, in her softest voice, she whispered, "If they go to his house, will there be a fire? A warm one? And will he let them stay?"

"I think so," the older girl said. "I think he will. And I think — I think maybe, just maybe, he has been waiting for them, too."

Outside their door, in the dark hallway, Sister Agnes stood listening, her hand pressed to her heart. She had heard every word. She stood there for a long time, until the whispering stopped and the girls' breathing slowed into sleep, and then she went downstairs to her little office, and she opened her Bible, and she read by lamplight until the rain stopped.

She did not know whether the girls had reached the hotel. She did not know whether Mr. Hayes had been at his table, or whether the dining room had been empty, or whether the girls were even now being dragged back to Kane's car. She knew only that she had sent them to the one man the bad men feared — and that her prayer, whispered over a photograph of a long-ago class of girls, was now in the hands of four small girls in wet party dresses, and a man who had forgotten how to love, and who was about to remember.

More posts