Chapter 1: The Girls Under the Table

Written by

in

Reading settings

The rain had been falling on Chicago for six hours, and it showed no sign of stopping.

Inside the dining room of the Meridian Grand hotel, the chandeliers burned warm and low over white tablecloths, and the tall windows looked out on a wet street where the traffic lights smeared themselves across the pavement in ribbons of red and gold. A pianist played softly in the corner. Waiters moved between the tables with silver trays. And at the corner table by the window, a man sat alone, as he did almost every night, with a pot of tea going cold beside his plate.

His name was Alexander Hayes, and he was the most feared man in Chicago.

He was forty-one years old, tall and powerfully built, with thick dark hair, a strong jawline, and piercing dark eyes. Tattoos covered his forearms, curling up from beneath his cuffs like dark vines. That night he wore a navy three-piece suit, a white shirt, and a paisley tie, with a pocket square folded sharp as a blade and a watch on his wrist that cost more than most men earned in a year. He held a teacup in one tattooed hand, and he was not drinking from it. He was only holding it, the way a man holds something to keep his hands from shaking.

He had not come to the Meridian Grand because he was hungry. He came because the dining room of his own house seated twenty people, and one man rattled in it like a single coin in an empty jar. He came because the hotel dining room was warm, and full of people, and nobody here asked him for anything. He came because five years ago, his wife had loved this room — she had loved the chandeliers and the piano and the smell of rain on the street outside — and sitting here, alone, was the closest he could still come to sitting beside her.

The waiter knew him. The waiter knew not to ask whether he was expecting anyone, because the answer was always no.

Alexander lifted the teacup to his lips. And that was when the revolving door at the far end of the room turned, and four small girls slipped through it, and into his life.

They were soaked to the skin. Their dresses — pink and blue and green and white, party dresses, their best dresses — were plastered to their small bodies and dark with rain. Their hair was wet and streaming. And on their heads, tilted and slipping, were four small silver tiaras, catching the chandelier light like sparks.

They were barefoot. Their shoes were gone — lost in the rain, or left behind in the hurry — and their small feet made no sound on the marble floor as they darted between the tables, past the waiters, past the staring diners, straight toward the corner table where the most feared man in Chicago sat alone with his tea.

Alexander froze, the teacup halfway to his mouth.

The smallest girl — the one in the white dress — reached his table first, and she did not stop. She ducked under the white tablecloth and vanished beneath the table, and the others followed her, one after another, quick as minnows, until all four of them were crouched under the marble table with its gold trim, pressed together in the dark space between his chair and the floor, their arms wrapped around each other, their small hands clutching at his trouser leg.

A tiny hand closed around his ankle. Another found his shoe — a brown oxford, polished to a shine — and held on to it as if it were the edge of a cliff.

Alexander looked down.

Four small faces looked up at him from beneath his table. Four pairs of eyes, wide and wet and terrified. The oldest girl, the one in the pink dress with white flowers, had long curly black hair plastered to her cheeks and hazel eyes that were full of tears, but she did not look away. She had promised her sisters she would be brave, and she meant to keep that promise even if her knees were shaking so hard she thought they might give out.

"Please," she whispered. Her voice shook, but she made herself say it. "Please, pretend you're our daddy."

Alexander Hayes, the most feared man in Chicago, stared down at the four small girls hiding under his table, and for a moment he could not speak at all.

"Who are you hiding from?" he asked at last, his voice low and rough, the voice of a man who had not spoken gently to anyone in five years.

"The bad man," the oldest girl whispered. "He came to take us away. Sister Agnes told us to run. She said — she said you eat your dinner here every night, and the bad men are afraid of you, and we should run to you."

A small voice from the dark under the table — the shy one, the blonde in the blue dress, her hands clasped so tightly together that her knuckles had gone white — whispered, "We don't want him."

"Who?" Alexander asked. "Who don't you want?"

"The man who says he owns us now," the oldest girl said. "Mr. Kane. He says the court gave us to him. He says we have to go and live in his house, and call him father. We don't want him. Please. Please don't let him take us."

Alexander set his teacup down on the saucer, very carefully, the way a man sets down something fragile. His hand was steady now. His voice, when he spoke, was quiet, and it was the quietest voice in the room — and somehow, it was the one that carried the farthest.

"Stay close to me," he said. "All of you. Stay right where you are, and do not come out until I tell you to. Do you understand?"

Four small heads nodded in the dark under the table.

"You're safe," he said. "No one is going to take you from this table. Not while I am sitting at it."

He picked up his teacup again, and he took a slow sip, and he looked out at the dining room as if nothing at all had happened — as if there were not four small girls in party dresses and tiaras hiding under his table, clinging to his leg.

But his eyes were not on the dining room. His eyes were on the revolving door.

And the revolving door turned.

A man came through it, shaking the rain from his shoulders. He was not tall, but he was broad, and he wore a brown suit that cost more than the orphanage spent on food in a month, and his smile did not reach his eyes. Behind him came a woman in a light-blue suit, with red hair pulled back and a leather folder in her hands, and she looked around the dining room the way a lawyer looks around a courtroom — measuring it, owning it, finding the exits.

The man in the brown suit crossed the dining room without hurry, past the pianist, past the waiters, past the diners who had gone very quiet, and he stopped beside Alexander's table. He looked down at the white tablecloth, and at the small bare feet just visible beneath it, and his smile widened.

"Mr. Hayes," he said, in a voice as smooth as oil. "What a pleasure. I believe you have something of mine."

Alexander did not stand up. He did not look at the man. He took another slow sip of his tea.

"Those girls belong with me," the man said. "The court has placed them in my care. They need to accept me as their father now. It is only a matter of time — and of paperwork. Hand them over, and there will be no trouble."

Under the table, four small girls pressed themselves tighter against Alexander's legs, and the smallest one, in the white dress, made a sound so soft it was almost not a sound at all.

Alexander set his teacup down on the saucer. He folded his napkin. And then, slowly, he rose to his feet, and he looked down at the man in the brown suit, and his face was the face the whole city feared.

"Then you should have asked their father," he said.

And the whole story — how four little girls in party dresses and tiaras came to be hiding under a stranger's table in a hotel dining room on a rainy October night — had begun three weeks earlier, on a morning that had seemed perfectly ordinary.

St. Agnes Home for Girls stood on a quiet street on the South Side, a worn brick building with white window frames and a small garden where the roses had mostly given up for the year. Seventy-one-year-old Sister Agnes ran it with a spine of iron and a heart that had room for every child who came through its doors. There were fourteen girls in the home that autumn, ranging from four years old to thirteen, and the four youngest of the older group — Gabriella, Harper, Nora, and Sophie — were inseparable.

They had arrived at St. Agnes at different times and for different reasons, and they had found each other the way lost things find each other: by staying close.

Gabriella was eight, nearly nine, and the oldest of the four. Her father had been a dockworker named Daniel, a big man with a bigger laugh, who had died two years earlier when a crane cable snapped at the port. Her mother had died when Gabriella was four, and Gabriella barely remembered her except for the smell of cinnamon and the sound of a lullaby. She had decided, the day she arrived at St. Agnes, that she would be the brave one. Somebody had to be. She wore a soft pink dress with white flowers, and she kept her long curly black hair tied back with a ribbon so it would not get in her way when there was something to be done.

Harper was eight, with long light blonde hair and a face so innocent that strangers stopped on the street to smile at her. She had come to St. Agnes when her parents' car went off an icy road outside Rockford. She was shy, and her hands were almost always clasped together in front of her, as if she were holding on to something invisible. She wore a light blue dress, and she was the one who always remembered everyone's birthday and saved the best piece of bread for the smallest child at the table.

Nora was eight as well, quiet as snowfall, with long brown hair and big brown eyes that seemed to take in everything and say nothing. She had been left at the door of St. Agnes as a baby, wrapped in a green blanket, with no note and no name except the one Sister Agnes gave her. She wore a soft green dress, and she hid behind the other girls whenever strangers came, but she was the first to notice when someone was sad, and the first to sit beside them without a word.

Sophie was the youngest, seven years old and small for her age, with long brown-blonde hair and bright innocent eyes. She wore a white dress with a little elephant stitched on the front, and she never went anywhere without her stuffed elephant, a grey, much-loved creature with one ear flatter than the other from years of being squeezed. Her parents had died of an illness that took them both in the same winter, and Sophie had not spoken a single word for three months after she arrived. Now she spoke, but softly, and mostly to her sisters and her elephant.

On the morning the trouble began, the four of them were in the garden, helping Sister Agnes tie up the last of the tomato plants before the frost came. The air smelled of wet leaves and wood smoke. Harper was humming. Nora was carefully winding twine. Sophie was telling her elephant, in a whisper, that winter was coming and they would need to be brave.

A black car pulled up outside the gate.

It was not a car anyone in the neighbourhood owned. It was long and low and polished, and the man who got out of it wore a brown suit that cost more than the orphanage spent on food in a month. He was not tall, but he was broad, and his smile did not reach his eyes. Two larger men stayed by the car, their arms folded, watching the street.

"Good morning, Sister," the man said, in a voice as smooth as oil. "My name is Marcus Kane. I represent a development group. We are very interested in this property."

Sister Agnes straightened up slowly, wiping her hands on her apron. She was a small woman, but she had faced down worse men than Marcus Kane in seventy-one years, and she did not step back.

"This property is a children's home, Mr. Kane," she said. "It is not for sale."

"Everything is for sale, Sister. At the right price." Kane's smile widened. "The city has questions about this building. The wiring, the plumbing, the fire safety. Old buildings like this… they can be condemned, you know. It would be a shame if the children had to be moved in the middle of winter. My group is prepared to offer you a very generous sum, and we would even help you relocate."

"We are not relocating," Sister Agnes said. "Good day, Mr. Kane."

Kane's smile did not fade, but something cold moved behind his eyes. "Think it over, Sister. I will be back. And Sister — do think carefully. Accidents happen in old buildings. Fires, for example. A home like this, full of children… it would be a terrible thing."

He got back into his car, and the car pulled away. The two large men followed in a second car.

Sister Agnes stood in the garden for a long time, her hands trembling slightly, before she turned to the girls and smiled as if nothing had happened.

"Come inside, my dears," she said. "It is nearly time for lunch. And Gabriella — would you help me with the bread?"

But Gabriella had heard every word. She had heard the word "fire," and she had seen the way Sister Agnes's hands shook. That night, after the other girls were asleep, Gabriella sat up in her bed and stared at the ceiling, thinking.

She thought about what Sister Agnes had told them once, on a winter evening when the wind was rattling the windows and the girls had asked her about the big dark house on the hill, the one with the tall gates and the black cars and the men who never smiled.

"That house belongs to Mr. Alexander Hayes," Sister Agnes had said, her voice low. "He is the most feared man in Chicago. Even the bad men are afraid of him. But I knew his mother, God rest her, and I will tell you this: a man who is feared by bad men is not always a bad man himself."

Gabriella held on to those words. She held on to them through the days that followed, as Marcus Kane's men began to appear on their street — a car parked too long at the corner, a man smoking on the opposite pavement, watching the house. She held on to them when the city's inspector came, a nervous man with a clipboard who would not meet Sister Agnes's eyes, and left a notice on the door saying the building had failed its inspection and would be condemned within thirty days. She held on to them when the lights in the home began to flicker and die, one by one, and the plumber who came to fix them shook his head and said someone had cut the wires.

And then, a week later, Kane came back — and this time he did not come to talk about the building. He came with the woman in the light-blue suit, and she carried a leather folder, and she laid papers on Sister Agnes's kitchen table with the brisk, practised air of a woman who had done this a hundred times.

"An emergency guardianship order," the woman said. She was Kane's lawyer, and her name was Diane Mercer, and her voice was as cool and smooth as the leather of her folder. "The home is condemned, Sister. The children cannot remain in a condemned building. The court has placed the children of St. Agnes Home in the temporary care of my client, Mr. Kane, pending their transfer to a private care facility. The order takes effect tonight."

Sister Agnes read the papers twice, her hands shaking, and then she set them down, very carefully, on the table.

"I will not sign these," she said.

"You do not need to sign them, Sister," Diane Mercer said, and she smiled, a thin, professional smile. "The order is already signed. By a judge. My client will send his people for the children this evening."

After they left, Sister Agnes sat in her small office for a long time, looking at the papers, and at the photograph on the wall of the home's first class of girls, and she prayed. Then she called the four girls into the kitchen, and she spoke to them plainly, because she had always believed children deserved the truth.

"There is a man who wants this house," she said. "He wants the land it stands on, and now he says the court has given him you, as well. He will send his men tonight, to take you to his house. We will not let that happen. But I want you to know something. If anything ever happens — if you ever feel unsafe here — you run to the Meridian Grand hotel, on the corner of the avenue. Mr. Alexander Hayes takes his dinner there every night at seven o'clock, alone, at the corner table by the window. Do you understand?"

"Why him, Sister?" Harper asked, her hands clasped tightly. "Everyone says he's a bad man."

"Everyone says many things," Sister Agnes said. "I knew his mother. She was a good woman, and she raised a good son, even if the world has been unkind to him since. And I will tell you this, my dears: a man who is feared by bad men is not always a bad man himself. Kane is afraid of him. That is why you run to him. Now — no more questions. Go and do your lessons."

The girls went. But Gabriella remembered. She remembered the way Sister Agnes's voice had sounded when she said it — not like a story, but like a promise.

That evening was little Mary's fifth birthday, and the home had planned a small party for her — a cake with five candles, and paper crowns, and the girls in their best party dresses, with silver tiaras in their hair. Gabriella wore her pink dress with the white flowers. Harper wore her light blue dress. Nora wore her soft green dress. Sophie wore her white dress with the elephant on it, and she had tucked her stuffed elephant into the pocket of her dress, because even at a party, Elephant went everywhere.

The cake had just been cut when the knock came at the front door.

It was not a knock. It was a hammering — a fist on wood, again and again — and then a voice, low and rough, calling for Sister Agnes, and the sound of the front door being rattled in its frame.

Gabriella sat up. Harper was already awake to the danger, her hands clasped. Nora was sitting up too, her eyes wide. Sophie was clutching her elephant, her face pale.

"Stay here," Gabriella whispered. But even as she said it, she heard the glass break downstairs — a sharp, bright sound, like ice cracking — and Sister Agnes's voice, raised and furious, and a man's voice answering, low and threatening.

Gabriella did not think. She grabbed her sisters' hands and pulled them out of bed. They did not stop for shoes. They did not stop for coats. They ran down the back stairs in their party dresses, their tiaras slipping sideways on their wet hair — for the rain had started in the afternoon and grown heavier with every hour — and out through the kitchen door into the rain.

The rain was cold, so cold it took their breath away. The garden was dark, and the wet grass sucked at their bare feet. Behind them, the house was lit up, and through the broken window they could see the shapes of men moving inside, and Sister Agnes standing in the hallway, small and straight and unafraid, facing them down.

"Run," Sister Agnes had shouted, and her voice cut through the rain like a bell. "Run, girls! To the Meridian Grand! Go!"

So they ran.

They ran down the wet street, past the parked cars, past the dark shops, their dresses plastered to their skin, their hair streaming behind them, their tiaras catching the streetlights like sparks. Sophie fell once, and Gabriella pulled her up without stopping. Harper was crying, but she kept running. Nora did not make a sound, but she held Sophie's hand so tightly that her fingers left marks.

The hotel was four blocks away, on the corner of the avenue, its windows blazing gold against the rain. The girls ran toward the light, and they reached the revolving door, and they pushed through it, all four of them at once, into the warmth and the music and the smell of good food — and there, at the corner table by the window, sat a tall man in a navy three-piece suit, with dark hair and a paisley tie and a teacup in his tattooed hand, eating his dinner alone.

Gabriella did not hesitate. She ran to his table, and she ducked under the white tablecloth, and her sisters followed her, and they pressed themselves together in the dark space beneath the marble table, and they wrapped their arms around each other, and around his leg, and they tried not to breathe too loudly.

They had been hiding for eleven minutes when the revolving door turned again, and a man in a brown suit walked into the dining room, with a woman in a light-blue suit at his side.

And the man in the brown suit looked down at the white tablecloth, and at the small bare feet just visible beneath it, and he smiled his cold, oil-smooth smile.

"Mr. Hayes," he said. "I believe you have something of mine."

More posts