My father has tried to marry me off seven times, and I have defeated him with cat photographs every single time.
You should know the truth about me before I lie to an entire ballroom, because the lying is the whole point. My name is Grace Mercer. I am twenty-nine years old. I hold a master's degree in finance from Northwestern, and I secretly run a hospitality consulting firm called Wren Consulting that earned six hundred and forty thousand dollars last year telling hotel owners which of their executives are robbing them.
Nobody at the St. Aurelia Children's Fund gala knew any of that.
As far as Chicago society was concerned, I was Richard Mercer's disappointing daughter. The one who "helps with the books sometimes." The one who went a little strange after her mother died. The one in the oversized glasses and the cardigan with cats on it, who smiled nervously at powerful men and talked — at length, at volume, with visual aids — about her cats.
The cats do not exist. There are twelve photographs on my phone, downloaded over three years from rescue shelter websites, and I know each fictional animal the way other women know their own children.
Gerald is orange and bites when he senses emotional dishonesty. Kevin does not respect boundaries and requires his own humidifier because of his seasonal melancholy. There is a Siamese named Chairman Meow who screams at mirrors. There is a Persian named Duchess whose name I intend to give to my future daughter, a fact I share early and with great eye contact.
Three years. Six wealthy, eligible, increasingly relieved men. My act has never failed.
That night, my father had arranged suitor number seven: Ethan Romano, thirty-four, heir to the Romano fortune, a man so handsome and so certain of his own importance that the two qualities seemed to hold each other up. We were seated at a table in the great hall of Halston House, the old mansion on the lake that hosts every charity event in Chicago worth photographing. Crystal, string quartets, a children's hospital wing being funded one silent auction at a time.
Four hours before the gala, I had been standing in my real office in the Loop, in a suit that fit, signing off on a report that would cost a hotel group in Dallas its entire executive floor. My assistant Nadia — one of eleven people at Wren who had never seen my face, because the firm's founder worked by video with the camera off and was rumored by our own staff to be either a disgraced CFO or three accountants in a trench coat — had left the evening's briefing on my desk with a sticky note: Gala tonight. Your father's table. Godspeed and furballs. Nadia does not know what I do at those galas. Nadia has excellent instincts and no curiosity, which is the entire hiring philosophy of my life.
I changed in my office bathroom: out of the suit, into the gown; the cardigan over it like ivy over a fence; the glasses on last, the way other women put on a veil. In the mirror, the consultant went away and the disappointment arrived, right on schedule. I have done this in more bathrooms than I can count, and it never once occurred to me that it might be the most honest ritual I owned — the one moment of the day when both of my lives were in the room at the same time, looking at each other.
Twenty-three minutes into dinner, Ethan explained to me — gently, the way you'd explain weather to a child — why married women really shouldn't trouble themselves with complicated investments.
"A wife's energy," he said, turning his wine glass by the stem, "belongs in the home. Children as soon as possible, ideally. Finances are a burden a husband should carry."
"Oh," I said. "Oh, I completely agree."
Then I reached into my purse.
"Gerald doesn't trust men in loafers."
Ethan looked down at his own expensive shoes as if they had betrayed him personally. "Who is Gerald?"
I turned my phone around. An orange cat with the face of a hanging judge stared out of the screen.
"He bites when he senses emotional dishonesty," I said. "It's a whole thing. The vet says it's a gift."
Someone two seats down made a sound into their champagne. Ethan's brow furrowed. "How many cats do you have, exactly?"
"Twelve," I said brightly. "But seventeen litter boxes. You can't be too careful. And the house will need three bedrooms — one for us, one for the cats, and one just for seasonal cat bedding. It breathes better that way. Oh! And if we have a daughter, I want to name her Duchess. After my Persian. She'd be honored. The cat, I mean. The baby would just have to grow into it."
Ethan's shoulders had begun their slow migration backward around the word twelve. By seasonal cat bedding, he was a man watching a train leave a station he was relieved to miss.
"I should…" He folded his napkin with great care. "I should find my brother."
"Of course!" I beamed. "Give Gerald's regards to— oh. He's gone."
People ask — well, people would ask, if anyone knew — how I built the act. The truth is that it built itself, one emergency at a time. Suitor number one was a shipping heir who explained derivatives to me for forty minutes, wrongly, while I nodded and lost a staring contest with my own reflection in a spoon. That night I went home and downloaded the first cat photograph. Suitor number two got Gerald. Suitor number three got Gerald and Kevin, and asked if the cats would live with us, and I said, "They'd live with you. I'd visit," and he developed a sudden urgent appointment in another state. Suitor number four lasted through a whole dinner because he was either very patient or very frightened, until I told him my dream was to hand-knit matching sweaters for all twelve cats and then, eventually, for him. Suitor number five proposed on the spot to a commodities trader at the next table to escape me, which I have always considered the act's finest hour. Suitor number six cried — with relief, outside the restaurant, where he thought I couldn't see him. I could. I was delighted for both of us.
The rules were simple. Never be caught being competent. Never let the performance crack in public, because a crack is a thread, and threads get pulled. Wear the cardigan. Wear the glasses. Count nothing out loud, correct nothing out loud, want nothing out loud. The woman underneath — the one with the degree, the firm, the eleven employees and the six-hundred-and-forty-thousand-dollar year — she lived in a Loop office with no name on the door and came out at night like something nocturnal.
I want to be honest about why, because it wasn't only my father's marriage market I was escaping. It was the market itself. Every suitor my father produced was a man who had looked at Mercer's balance sheet before he'd looked at my face. They were not courting a woman. They were performing due diligence on a merger with a pulse. The cats were my way of making them say it out loud — of watching a man discover, fork halfway to his mouth, that the asset was going to be difficult. Gerald has excellent instincts. Gerald has never once been wrong about a man in loafers.
Seventh suitor, eliminated. Total elapsed time: twenty-six minutes. A personal best.
I waited until the crowd swallowed him. Then I sat up straight, let the nervous smile fall off my face, and reached across his place setting for the chocolate mousse he hadn't touched. Waste is a sin, and whatever else I am, I am not wasteful.
"Poor Kevin," said a deep voice to my left.
My spoon stopped halfway to my mouth.
Lucas DeLuca had been seated three chairs away all evening, between his brother Marco — who had been openly struggling not to laugh into his napkin for an hour — and his sister Sofia, who had given up struggling entirely around the humidifier.
Lucas himself had not laughed once. I had been introduced to him forty minutes earlier, and in that time I had become aware of him the way you become aware of a change in weather. Thirty-nine years old. Dark hair, silver starting at the temples like it had been appointed. A face that would have been merely handsome if the eyes hadn't ruined it — pale, patient, and absolutely unwilling to be fooled. The DeLucas owned half the luxury hotels in Chicago, freight companies, construction firms, towers of real estate along the lake. When there were microphones nearby, people called Lucas DeLuca a businessman.
Everyone else in Chicago knew he was the most feared mafia boss in the Midwest.
And all evening, he hadn't been watching my face. He'd been watching my hands. My posture. The exact moment, twenty minutes ago, when my eyes had snagged on the leather folder resting beside my father's chair — the folder holding the offering projections for the Lakeview Tower partnership, the deal between my father's company and the Romanos that tonight's dinner was quietly celebrating.
I had overheard my father's CFO murmuring to a Romano man: "…stabilized occupancy at ninety-one percent, so the tower clears its covenants in year two…" And under my breath, without thinking — the way you swat a fly, the way your real self moves before your costume can stop her — I had whispered, "Seventy-four. The convention calendar's double-counted. It's seventy-four, and year two doesn't clear anything."
Then I had smiled at Ethan and asked him if he thought cats could sense earthquakes.
Lucas's eyes had lifted at the whisper. I had seen it. I had spent the rest of dinner performing twice as hard to bury it, and sitting there with his mousse on my spoon, I understood that I had buried nothing.
"Kevin," Lucas said now, "is the one with the humidifier."
"Seasonal melancholy," I said, too fast, the smile snapping back on like a mask on a string. "It's very serious. The vet—"
"Grace." He said my name quietly, and it did something to the air between us. "Your spoon is in your left hand now. It was in your right all through dinner, because the helpless version of you is right-handed and nervous with cutlery. The version eating my dessert is neither."
I put the spoon down very carefully.
The quartet was playing something soft. Two hundred people laughed and bid and glittered around us, and at our end of the table the world had narrowed to one man who had just disassembled three years of my life's work without raising his voice.
"I need some air," I said.
I didn't run. Running would have confirmed it. I walked — cardigan, glasses, ridiculous little clutch — through the French doors onto the private terrace that runs along the lake side of Halston House, where the November wind came off Lake Michigan cold enough to file your bones, and I gripped the stone railing and breathed.
The door clicked behind me inside of a minute.
I didn't turn around. "It's a private terrace."
"Then it finally matches the conversation." Lucas DeLuca stepped up to the railing beside me, close but not touching, his eyes on the black water. "You corrected a forty-million-dollar projection under your breath, Miss Mercer. Occupancy, covenant timing, the duplicated convention calendar. My own auditors took six weeks to find that error. You found it between the soup and the fish, while explaining a cat's mental health."
"I don't know what you're—"
He reached up, slowly, giving me every chance to stop him, and took my glasses off my face.
The world went slightly soft at the edges — because the glasses, of course, are plain glass. They always have been. There is nothing wrong with my eyes. There has never been anything wrong with any part of me except the parts I invented.
He looked at the lenses. He looked at me. And Lucas DeLuca smiled like a man turning over the last card of a hand he's already won.
"You're faking all of it," he whispered.
I should have lied. I had lied to richer men, scarier rooms, higher stakes. But the wind was cold and his hand was still raised between us, holding my ridiculous glasses like evidence, and what came out of my mouth was the stupid, dangerous truth:
"Almost all of it."
"Almost." He folded the glasses and put them in his breast pocket, where they stayed like a hostage. "Then let's discuss the part you didn't fake. The projection you corrected tonight — the one in the folder beside your father's chair — is a lie, Miss Mercer. A very careful, very expensive lie. And in three weeks, at the Founders' Ball, in that same ballroom, your father is going to sign a partnership built on it."
He turned to face me fully, and the pale eyes weren't amused anymore.
"Men who sign deals like that don't retire," Lucas DeLuca said. "They get buried. So before you run back inside and perform an encore about the cats — tell me. Did you know?"
