Chapter 2: The Advertisement

Written by

in

Reading settings

The forge sold in the spring for enough to pay Heinrich's debts and leave Karl a start in life, and Natalie understood — standing in the lawyer's office with her hat in her hands, ducking under a lintel built for smaller people — that her share of her father's estate was precisely what she was wearing, plus her mother's laces and sewing basket, plus two hundred and eleven dollars in a canvas purse.

Karl did not cheat her. That must be said. Karl loved her, in the helpless way of a younger brother who has been carried through childhood in someone's arms and does not know how to carry them back. The division was fair on paper. It was simply that the paper belonged to a world arranged for people of ordinary size and ordinary prospects, and Natalie had neither.

Clara Beecham married Karl in June, in the church where Natalie had been christened, and Natalie sewed the bride's dress with her own hands and stood up with her at the altar, a head taller than the groom, while the congregation performed the small cruelty of not quite looking at her. Within a month the house had begun the process that crowded houses perform: Clara's things in the front room, Clara's mother on Sundays, Natalie's trunk moved — apologetically, reasonably — to the lean-to room off the kitchen where the hired girls used to sleep.

She took in sewing. She kept books for two merchants on the square, in a beautiful German hand, sitting at desks that pinched her knees. She was twenty-two years old, and Independence, Missouri, had begun to feel like a dress she had outgrown at fourteen and was still being asked to wear to church.

The young men were the worst of it — not their cruelty, for most were not cruel, but their kindness. They were kind to her the way one is kind to a landmark. They tipped their hats. They called her Miss Natalie with the careful respect due an aunt. Two of them, over the years, had come courting with every appearance of sincerity and had left before the second visit, and Natalie had watched each of them go with the same private arithmetic her father had once done: a man of five feet eight cannot court a woman of five feet eleven without the whole town doing the figuring for him, aloud, in the street. She did not blame them. That was the unbearable part. She did not blame anyone, and there was nowhere to put it down.

The advertisement came to her in August of 1878, in the back pages of a Kansas City newspaper wrapped around a parcel of sewing notions, and she read it three times standing at the kitchen table with the light going.

RESPECTABLE MARRIAGE IN THE WEST. The Idaho Matrimonial Aid Society seeks young ladies of good character and industrious habits for introduction to established gentlemen of Idaho Territory — miners, ranchers, and merchants of substance — who desire wives and lack the society of suitable women. Passage advanced against contract. All correspondence confidential. References required and given.

She wrote that night, at the kitchen table, in her beautiful hand. She was honest — it was the only vanity she had. She gave her true age, her true skills, her true faith, and then, after a long pause with the pen dripping, her true height. Nearly six feet, she wrote. Strong. Not afraid of work. She folded the letter before she could reconsider, and Karl, who found it on the mantel in the morning, rode it to the post himself without a word, which was his way of saying the only thing he knew how to say.

The answer took six weeks, and it was everything the advertisement had promised: a courteous letter from a Mr. Tobias Crane, secretary of the Society, informing Miss Zimmerman that a gentleman of the Salmon River country — no, of the Snake River settlements — had read her description with particular interest. That her passage would be advanced. That she should bring references, her belongings, and her courage. The Society's representative would meet the stage at Willow Ford in the second week of September.

There had been one suitor worth the naming, and she thought of him on the nights the dress was being sewn. Elias Ward, a widower of forty with a good farm and a dead wife's three children, had come to the house the autumn after her father died with every evidence of sincere intention — he had talked to her of books, of weather, of the price of wheat, he had looked at her face and not at the problem of her. For three Sundays Natalie allowed herself the dangerous arithmetic of hope. On the fourth, Elias did not come, and on the fifth a letter did, in a hand she recognized as his mother's: the family felt the match unsuitable. The farm needed a woman the neighbors would not remark upon. Elias himself rode past the forge land a month later, driving his own wagon, and did not turn his head — and Natalie, watching from the yard, understood that she had not been refused for anything she had done or failed to do. She had been refused for the length of her bones, which no repentance could shorten, and there is a particular desolation in being found wanting for a thing that is simply the shape of you. She never spoke of Elias Ward again. But the green dress got an extra row of her mother's lace at the hem, sewn in on the anniversary of that letter, and if any woman in Missouri had asked her why, she would have said: because I am not finished yet.

She sold what she could not carry. She sewed the sage-green dress by candlelight across the whole of one hot month, taking the lace off her mother's wedding gown stitch by stitch and setting it into the skirt, so that something of Anna Zimmerman would travel west with her daughter. She said goodbye to Karl on the depot platform at dawn, and he held on to her hand a moment longer than a brother needs to and said, "Write when you're settled, Nat," and she said she would, and neither of them said the other thing, which was that there had not been room, and there never was.

The journey took eleven days, and it taught her the West the way the West teaches everything: by scale. It also taught her the exact company she was keeping. At a river crossing swollen with late rain, the stage mired to its axles in the far bank, and while the driver cursed and the male passengers stood about making suggestions, it was Natalie who got down into the water in her traveling skirt, set her shoulder to the wheel with the horses, and walked the coach out of the river on the strength of her own back. She rode the rest of that day in wet boots, saying nothing, while Liddy stared at her with the worship of a girl who has discovered that heroines come in her size after all, and Rose remarked — to the coach generally, in her Boston voice — that any gentleman in Idaho who got that woman for the price of a train ticket was robbing the railroad. Natalie had laughed, truly laughed, for the first time since Missouri. It had felt like a door opening. She would remember that laugh later, on the platform, and understand it had been the last one the journey owed her.

The plains unrolled like something God had made too much of. The mountains, when they finally rose, made the plains look modest. She shared the last stage with three other Society brides — a widow of thirty named Mrs. Pell, who had kind eyes and a hidden bottle; a girl of seventeen called Liddy, who cried at night into her sleeve; and a sharp, funny Boston girl named Rose who read dime novels and announced that she intended to marry rich or not at all.

"There's to be a signing when we arrive," Rose said, somewhere in the dust south of the Snake River. "Contracts. Mr. Crane says the gentlemen prefer to settle the Society's fee and the passage money all at once, so nobody's beholden. Very businesslike. I admire it."

It was Liddy, white-faced, who asked the question that turned the air in the coach cold. "My cousin went out to Montana with a society," she said. "She wrote home it wasn't a signing. She wrote it was a sale. She wrote they stand you up in front of them and they bid."

The stage rolled on through the sagebrush. Nobody answered her. Rose closed her novel. Mrs. Pell looked out at the mountains a long time and said, finally, "Then we shall stand up straight, dear. Whatever it is. We shall stand up straight."

They came into Willow Ford at noon on the second Tuesday of September, and the first thing Natalie saw — before the false-front stores, before the hitching rails and the dusty wagons and the blue wall of the mountains standing over everything — was the platform.

It stood in the middle of the square like a scaffold's better-dressed cousin: raw timber, four feet high, with steps at the back and a podium at the front, and bunting. Someone had hung bunting on it, as if decoration could change what a thing was. A crowd was already gathering beyond it, men mostly, settling themselves the way men settle at a horse sale, and up on the platform a gray-bearded man in a black suit was arranging papers on the podium with the unhurried air of a man about to open a church service.

Mr. Tobias Crane met them at the hotel with tea and sandwiches and his secretary's smile, and explained — gently, reasonably, in the voice of a man explaining weather — that the Territory's customs were the Territory's customs, that the gentlemen wished to see the ladies they were contracting with, that the bids were simply a fair method of settling the Society's expenses and the cost of passage, and that the ladies were of course free to refuse any match — after the debt of their passage was repaid. Which was, in Natalie's case, one hundred and forty dollars. Which was, in Natalie's case, one hundred and forty dollars more than she had left in the world.

Rose, unpacking in the room they had been given to share, took one look at her face and produced — from somewhere in her carpetbag, with the air of a conjurer — a deck of cards and a deck's worth of irrelevant conversation, and kept both going until midnight, deliberately and kindly, a Boston girl talking a Missouri blacksmith's daughter down off the ledge of her own thoughts without ever once naming the ledge. Natalie understood what was being done for her, and permitted it, and filed Rose's particular brand of mercy away among the things she meant to repay in this life.

She stood at the hotel window that night and looked down at the platform in the moonlight, and at the mountains beyond, black and enormous and indifferent, and she understood the size of the trap she had ridden eleven days to reach. If she refused, she owed a debt she could not pay, in a town where she knew no one, two thousand miles from a brother's crowded house that had no room for her. If she submitted, she would stand on that platform tomorrow and be bid for like a mare, and the man who won her might be anyone. Anyone at all.

She thought of her mother saying do not make yourself small. She thought of her father saying stand straight.

She unpacked the sage-green dress, and hung it up to take the creases out, and pressed the lace with her hands.

"Well," she said to the empty room, in her mother's voice as much as her own. "Then we shall stand up straight."

She did not sleep. And in the morning, washed and dressed and laced into her mother's lace, with Liddy crying quietly in the room below and the crowd already gathering in the square, Natalie Zimmerman walked down the hotel stairs and out into the sunlight, toward the sound of a gavel being tested, experimentally, against raw timber.

More posts